Can he be tortured to extract a confession? Is it possible to force a confession by killing his relatives?
If they object, tens of millions of lives will be sacrificed. Will anyone still object?
This film presents to the audience such a philosophical question that is extremely dilemma. It also corresponds to the film's title: "Colonel, the Geneva Convention states that...
"
"Colonel, the Geneva Convention states that... "
"
Enemies engaged in illegal activities under the Military Commission Act may not invoke the Geneva Convention."
" The Military Commissions Act, no unlawful enemy combatants, may invoke the Geneva Convention." "The Act stipulates that torture is illegal. Enemy forces who violate the law
have no right to habeas corpus, and the courts can’t make any accusations, let alone prove it!" "That act declares torture illegal. Unlawful combatants have no right to habeas corpus, They can't bring any claims to court, so how do they prove it?"
"That's against a foreign enemy engaged in illegal activities, and he is an American citizen"
"That's alien unlawful enemy combatants.This man is an American citizen."
"
"That was revoked yesterday. He's now stateless."
Discussing whether prisoners can be abused depends on the social background. If we are in the celestial dynasty, then any detention center can do it, but in the United States, there is the Eighth Amendment to the Constitution: it’s not right. The prisoners imposed cruel and extraordinary punishments. However, the problem is that it is limited to American citizens. Soldiers dare to abuse prisoners of war in Iraq. As for the Geneva Convention, there are even more loopholes...
"
Jack, the suspect is being tortured. This is unconstitutional."
"Helen, if those bombs explode, The constitution doesn’t exist anymore!"
"Helen, if those bombs go off, there will be no fucking Constitution!"
"Do you want to know where the bombs are? This is my duty! Do you want me to win or he wins? ?"
"Do you want to know where the bombs are or not? "
It's my responsibility! You want me to win, or you want him to win?"
"H 放下刀"
"H, put the knife down."
"That Have you decided to let him win? You are so fucking selfish, it's not just about you! This is war and sacrifice."
"So you made a choice, you want him to win? You're all so fucking selfish. This is not about you! This is war. This is sacrifice."
"The man killed 53 people, among them there are women and children. What I say is wicked? "
" that man over there killed 53 people. s Some of Them Women and Children, and yet somehow the I'm at the Villain? "
" shut up you fucking crazy you this is the devil! "
" the Keep your by you mouth shut, you maniac. You're fucking evil!"
These three dialogues show that H has always adhered to his philosophy: to get the location of the bomb at all costs. It is even extinct. Can you say he did something wrong? He is saving the lives of tens of millions of people...
"
I love my country, you are ravaging it! I love my country, you people crap on it!
I love my religion, you are spurning it!
I love my religion and you people spit on it!
Don’t forget that I chose to come here!
Just remember something, I'm here because I want to be here!
I chose to contest with the oppressors face to face!
The I chose to Meet My oppressors face to face!
You said I brutality
You call me a barbarian.
Then you own it?
The Then the What are you?
You expect me to mourn 50 civilians?
The What, You expect me to weep over 50 civilians?
You are slaughtering so many
people every day ! You people kill that number every day
!
How does it feel Brody? This has nothing to do with me. This is your problem! How does it feel, Brody? This is not about me. This is about you! How does it feel? You
don’t have the right to decide here! No!
How does it feel? You have no authority here! None
!
There is but one authority and it is not you!
You are a scourge!
You are a blight!
You are a cancer!
You are a cancer!"
Younger's shocking roar showed how terrifying a person with extreme beliefs and not afraid of death and torture is. And H sits quietly, watching this person whose conviction is above his punishment, doubting herself for the first time, and Brody, she has neither the ability to stop the torture suffered by Yang, nor the ability. Save the people who are about to die.
"You can't do this! We are fucking people, if you want to explode, let's explode! We can't do this!"
"You can't do this! We're fucking human beings. Let the bomb go off! We cannot do this !" The
last sentence comes from Brody. Out of human instinct, she can’t hold on to her duties. If the film ends with a happy ending and the bombs are all removed, then this would be a movie with the main theme of humanity prevailing, but unfortunately, that the fourth bomb
bomb countdown indicates 1000W person's life will be taken away, Brody will regret their decision? The director is still torturing the audience at the last moment...
View more about Unthinkable reviews
