excerpts from small papers

Malvina 2022-04-20 09:01:27

Introduce the overlap between the film and reality, and dive into a few key points:

*Christine Collins

Christine Collins is a working-class single mother who lived a comfortable and simple life of happiness until his nine-year-old son disappeared. Until March 1928, his youngest son disappeared forever, and his life changed greatly. After a series of baptisms, Christine, who was forced to recognize a stranger as her child, strengthened her willpower. With the help of St. Paul's Presbyterian pastor at the time, Gustav Briegleb, the lawsuit against the Los Angeles Police Department was finally won. Just like the slogan of the film: "To find her son, she did what no one else dared

"

There have been many scandals in the police department. The most famous of these happened together in 1992. At that time, an all-white jury acquitted four white police officers of beating black youths, causing widespread racial riots.

It was the same, even more inhumane, in that period eighty years ago. In my opinion, if Gordon was sentenced to death for that murder, given that his irresponsible approach to the disappearance investigation resulted in a missed opportunity to rescue those children, then Chief JJ Jones It is not an exaggeration to be regarded as an accomplice and sentenced to life imprisonment.

*Mental hospital and Article 12

As mentioned earlier, under the direction of the director, Christine was later placed in the psychiatric department of Los Angeles General Hospital. When entering the hospital, "It's Article 12 again!" the medical staff shouted. Because Article 12 comes in because they are charged with disturbing the police, Christine learns this from a prostitute. There's a line in this that impressed many people: "There's absolutely no winning with the doctors. If you smile too much, you're delusional. If you smile too little, you're depressed. If you're neutral, then you've lost touch with basic human emotions. All anyone can do is learn how to behave properly.”(Translation: There is no way you can fight these doctors. If you keep laughing, you are delusional; if you If you don't laugh, you have depression; if you don't do anything, you lose basic human consciousness. All you can do is be more correct.)
And after negotiating with the attending doctor, Christine always refused to sign the discharge. Agreement: The doctor told her he would let her go as long as she admitted that the fake Walter was her son. Of course, Christine showed her usual spirit of not giving up.

*The Presbyterian Church of St. Paul

played an important supporting role in the whole incident. Pastor Gustav Briegleb used to criticize the corruption of the government and the police. He publicized the hidden and ugly secrets through the radio. After learning about Walter's disappearance and what happened to Christine's mother and son, he chose to help Christine to the end at all costs. He hired the best defense lawyer to win the case for her or for the more wronged and persuaded the people to stage a protest march. When the movie is played here, it can't help but make people happy.

*Hearings

The United States in the 1930s was still a very closed era, but fortunately, there was such a judicial institution that stood up to the authorities and could clear up the grievances of innocent people. The victory of the whole event is based on such circumstances. Imagine that if there is no such a complete and fair judicial system for trial, then after 80 years, we will have no way to understand the documents and truth of that period.

View more about Changeling reviews

Extended Reading

Changeling quotes

  • Christine Collins: Why would they do this?

    Rev. Gustav Briegleb: To avoid admitting they made a mistake when they brought back the wrong boy. Of course, anyone reading the newspaper with half a brain would see through it instantly. Sadly, that would exclude about half the readership of the Times. Mrs. Collins, I have made it my mission in life to bring to light all the things the LAPD wish none of us ever knew about. A department ruled by violence, abuse, murder, corruption and intimidation. When Chief Davis took over the force two years ago, he said...

    Chief James E. Davis: We will hold court against gunmen in the streets of Los Angeles. I want them brought in dead, not alive, and I will reprimand any officer who shows the least mercy to a criminal.

    Rev. Gustav Briegleb: He picked fifty of the most violent cops on the force, gave them machine guns and permission to shoot anyone who got in their way. He called them the Gun Squad. No lawyers, no trials, no questions, no suspensions, no investigations, just piles of bodies. Bodies in the morgues, bodies in the hospitals, bodies by the side of the road, and not because the LAPD wanted to wipe out crime. No. The LAPD wanted to wipe out the competition. Mayor Cryer and half the force are on the take: gambling, prostitution, bootlegging, you name it. Because once you give people the freedom to do whatever they want, as the Lord found in the Garden of Eden, they will do exactly that. This police department does not tolerate dissent or contradiction or even embarrassment. And you are in a position to embarrass them and they do not like it. They will do anything in their power to discredit you. I've seen it happen too many times to start going blind now. That's why I wanted to meet you, to let you know what you're getting yourself into and to help you fight it, if you choose to.

    Christine Collins: Reverend, I appreciate everything that you're doing and everything that you said, but I'm not on a mission. I just want my son home.

  • Dr. John Montgomery: He had two cavities that needed filling. He put up a fight, but I took care of it.

    Christine Collins: And?

    Dr. John Montgomery: Your son's upper front teeth were separated by a small tissue, a diastema. It made them sit about an eighth of an inch apart. The boy in that room has no such gap.

    Christine Collins: Can that change with age? Because that's what they're going to say.

    Dr. John Montgomery: In some cases, yes, it's possible. But the tissue between Walter's teeth prevents that from happening. You see, they can never come together without an operation to sever the tissue, and I can tell you right now that he has never had such an operation.

    Christine Collins: Would you be willing to put that officially in writing?

    Dr. John Montgomery: Pardon my language, but hell yes.