The director successfully structured the positive and negative aspects of the American Dream in the public mind, but also successfully structured the positive and negative aspects of human nature. These two positive and negative contradictions are intertwined: the successful people in the eyes of the world eventually die in depression because of the loss of their humanity; while the losers in the eyes of the world finally retain the beauty in their hearts and live with a clear conscience.
Why do you say that?
First, it was the first time I watched this film, and the chaotic editing of time and space at the beginning left me puzzled, and it returned to normal as the narrative became normalized later. I feel that the emotional rendering is not in place, and the brotherhood and love are not impressive. Then I suddenly remembered that I didn't understand it at the beginning, so I pulled the film again the next day. Surprise can't be said, but suddenly enlightenment is definitely there. Like tea, the more you taste, the more flavorful it is. Many seemingly strange lines can really be felt when you read them again.
Second, the film was shown in Europe with a nearly 4-hour version, which is also on the market now, but the director originally planned to edit it for 6 hours, because he felt that there was not enough time to support the entire film. However, when it was released in the United States, due to the many restrictions of the theater, taking into account the needs of the audience and the exhaustion period, it was finally cut into one and a half hours, and finally a series of criticism and abuse followed. related to this.
A movie in theaters will not come again after one pass, and this film, you have to chew it over and over again.
I will talk about what other bean friends rarely talk about but which impresses me very much - the opening paragraph of Fat Boy and Noodles
Caps chased the middle-aged noodles, and the fat boy resisted stubbornly, even though he might think his friend betrayed him
To be violently killed at the end, forced to say the slender hiding place under threat
When the caps went here, Noodles probably understood that Fat Boy leaked secrets, because they were the only brothers who knew the Chinese Theater.
But he understood very well. He believed that his brother was out of nowhere. The proof was that he escaped from the theater, and the first place he went to was the Fat Boys Tavern.
Fat Boy gave him the key, but there was only a pile of paper left in the box.
I think he should have concluded that the fat boy had stolen it, and only a few of them knew where the box was placed, and at least four people must be present to open the box, and the key was kept by the fat boy. That is to say, only the fat guy who keeps the key has this possibility.
And this lays the groundwork for their old age encounter: both parties feel that the other party has stolen the money
And the noodles even suspected that it was the fat boy who exposed his traces for 35 years, because no one among the brothers survived except him.
Let’s sort it out, before we met, Fat Boy thought that Noodles had swallowed a lot of money and betrayed himself and his friends; Noodles thought that Fat Boy had swallowed money and betrayed himself
But what impresses me the most is
The old fat boy showed a familiar smile when he saw the noodles, because he was released from prison after receiving noodles when he was middle-aged.
In this situation, you can't help but think that this is the most sincere and beautiful smile in the world
Back in old age, the fat boy had the urge to hug when he saw the noodles.
But Noodle deliberately took out a key to stop this action, because he had too many questions, and even had been observing Fat Boy and his place since he entered the door
The fat boy is really good. The old man is running the tavern by himself and is helpless.
He has never changed his original intention. He almost cried when he said the following words
What heights such trust has reached! How many people can do it? Even if you think your friend betrayed you
In fact, Fat Boy has always been the person who cares about noodles the most.
Not only that, when the middle-aged noodle and Deborah were dating, the fat boy specially turned off the hall lights and directed a band to play melodious movements.
wow~ so interesting
In fact, there are many details in the film, including noodles and MAX, noodles and Deborah's...
Without the impediment of MAX over and over again, the two of them have already made it. If they succeed, this love will be another story.
We all know that Deborah likes noodles very, very much, even if she finally meets Noodles, she persuades Noodles not to come to the banquet, in order to try to keep the best memories in Noodles heart
But she looked down on him, the way of dressing and ruffian life, and she yearned for a better life, a more noble art
But even so, in the film we can see a lot of details about liking noodles, this kind of liking really only comes from the heart, not for money, not for power, not for anything, just for love
That conversation in the barn, the passage she read from the bible, was just a confession, and in the end they all kissed, sweet and beautiful
This is the purest love
Teacher Dai Jinhua said that this is one of her favorite films, and her interpretation of it is that success structures the positive and negative sides of the American Dream.
Loyal, kind, pure, and loyal people ended in tragedy. They lived alone and terrified for decades. In the end, even the most beautiful memories in my heart were shattered.
And the evil, scheming, snobbish person has gained power, money and women, but he is unhappy, in the eyes of the world he is brilliant, but in the end, he got nothing, of course the noodles can be seen, Just said this:
Therefore, the director successfully structured the positive and negative aspects of the American Dream in the public mind, but also successfully structured the positive and negative aspects of human nature. These two positive and negative contradictions are intertwined: the successful people in the eyes of the world eventually die in depression because of the loss of their humanity; while the losers in the eyes of the world finally retain the beauty in their hearts and live with a clear conscience.
Does it sound familiar? Isn't it like this in real life?
People are busy setting their sights on the so-called success paradigm, but they ignore the more magnanimous human nature and beauty. People are busy pursuing marriage within the established social framework, but neglect to pursue more authentic love.
View more about Once Upon a Time in America reviews
