Many people are spoiled by saving the world and destroying the world with great joy. They feel that the level of tragedy is measured by the scale of society. This is a very normal thing in the current era of blockbusters, because even Marvel movies are mostly rendering the world. A major crisis of physical destruction. But does that mean the film's "ethical drama", which has been criticized by many, is a low point of character?
The tragedy of Oedipus is not the destruction of the world, but the murder of the father.
Hamlet's tragedy is not to save the country and the people, but only the prince's revenge.
But that is the tragedy of the highest character.
Of course, Captain America can't be compared with the great classical tragedy. From the producers to the normal audience, there should be no one who wants to be compared.
It's just that some people say that tragedy is downgraded, and big contradictions become small contradictions. A little translation is: Hamlet plays a family.
Howard's "Sgt. Barnes" after recognizing old friend Bucky before his death, Bucky's "I remember each of them", Captain America watching one friend kill another and then a new round The cannibalization of friends immediately unfolded in front of my eyes, and the Iron Man witnessing the loss of control after his parents' tragic death had a far greater impact on my movie viewing than the issue of the bill.
What's the problem with the Captain America series? It's all too subtle, too much like the straight men of Team America's age.
Captain America misses peggy, is it sad to show you all day long? no. An understatement of "I missed an appointment" and then just go about your day-to-day life like a normal person. Even if we meet after half a century, the emotional outburst is only given to the old peggy, and this outburst ends with those two "steve" that are full of infinite affection and wistfulness. The men and women of those days were just like that, and have always been like that.
Leave this to some other movies and American TV series, and I will lose if the US team does not enter the Qiong Yao-style romance of the century.
The huge emotional tension behind Bucky's line "I remember each of them", if you change it to some producers, you can shoot countless midnight nightmares with lightning and thunder, and countless shadowy silhouettes. All-round close-up of the clenched fist, maybe even add a psychotherapy montage, very deep and dark. But in Team America, he was just taciturn, incognito, isolated, and he should buy groceries. Even being frozen voluntarily at the end didn't give you any exposed mental journey or hyped-up sublime, he just calmly said a simple truth. What is he actually up to? It's just an incompetent person who has been brainwashed and controlled. Freezing is not a penalty of negation, but a neutral prevention.
Is it difficult to shoot these bitter and bitter? Not only is it not difficult, but it is simply too simple, because these are absolutely excellent materials for bitterness and hatred. Just change the screenwriter and director of American dramas, and you can shoot as miserable as you want. But is this realistic? Is it human? Being separated by yin and yang from my parents, getting farther and farther from friends, and passing by with my lover, this is the common destiny of all mankind and a common sad experience. So, let's go out to the street and see how a human being with such a fate lives.
Let's talk about it further, look at Loki again, how does the infinitely entangled complex with his father and brother manifest? Brilliantly bad! Not to mention Iron Man. And new little spiders, need to mention uncle ben every day? Occasionally, under the excitement, he blurted out a sentence "you don't know what may have gone through", this is enough, does he need to care about what he has gone through and show it to you? No, after school he is still the little spider that the friendly townspeople let him perform somersaults.
That's the life force of superheroes and supervillains. This is also the most authentic and unconventional part of Marvel in my mind.
Conversely, going through life's tragedies and then dark secret mental illness every day, full of anger and paranoia? Call it human nature again? reality? I'm sorry, this is really not as good as ordinary people, it's just a superpower giant baby.
In the face of this giant baby, I support jjj, human beings do not need your rescue. I also support Lord Chou, go and see a doctor. There is no art and no truth in it, only catering to consumers who are eager to taste the "connotation" of other people's exaggerated pain.
Specifically in Captain America 3, this was originally a story that originated from the tragic life of Zemo, Dong, and Tie. It was these factors that were tearing up the character of Captain America, and the bill was nothing more than a fueling role in the development of the story. And in the end it was just a tool that proved its absurdity. This kind of absurdity doesn't need to be disputed, in the real world this bill must be necessary, in the movie world it must be wrong, it's as simple as that, you can imagine in a superhero movie universe, superheroes are all Civil servants?
So the Russo brothers are very wise. From the height of the film, they realized early on a fact that most fans do not want to admit: the superhero bill is not a contradiction that can support a serious and serious story. For this bill, Stark sold his teammates to his death, isn't it far-fetched? Not broken? Compared with the comics world, the biggest advantage of mcu is that it does not have the out-of-place behavior of those pipeline screenwriters who have no reverence and love for the characters. This Stark, who has been blackmailed in the comics in the past few years, and the Stark who saw his teammates in prisons with no human rights in the movie, who is remorseful, which is the one in Iron Man 1 Is it really necessary to fight for Stark's natural growth?
If I were to give my opinion on the transformation of this movie, my opinion would be diametrically opposed to most. Most people think that the weight of the bill line should be increased, and I think it is best to delete it directly. Under Zemo's design, the government wanted to arrest Bucky. Team America and Iron Man were torn apart purely out of different law enforcement positions. Team America Bucky escaped. Iron Man saw the other heroes who were arrested and learned that Bucky was controlled and framed. The truth, aware of the government's controlism, rushed to help Captain America, and then turned against each other because of his parents' past. This makes the story more concise and avoids confusion and unhelpful debate. Of course, the disadvantage is that it loses the comic civil war gimmick, but this is not important to me at all. The film adaptation of Manchurian and Ragnarok did not bother me at all. It doesn't seem to me that it affects the quality of the movie at all.
View more about Captain America: Civil War reviews
