The "good guys", the bad guys, and the villains

Theresa 2022-04-20 09:01:07

After reading a lot of reviews, first of all I want to say that the translation of "the ugly" in English is definitely not the meaning of "bad person", and it is definitely not the meaning of "ugly person", but the meaning of "little person". There are many translations of this point. It's all wrong, and so are many viewers.
Secondly, the good does not mean a good person, but a "good person". That guy Brandy is definitely not a good person. First, he caught the wanted villain Duke, but conspired with him to earn bounties many times, instead of letting him go because the bounty was not enough. Later, he terminated the cooperation with the villain Duke because he thought that his bounty was not high and could not deceive much money, so he found another wanted criminal and cooperated with him to defraud the bounty, which also led to the partner being hanged. Could this be a good person?
Second, in the final duel, he was not an upright gun-fighting at all, but did some tricks in advance. This is ugly and sinister and despicable. Can he be considered a good person?
Third, when the bridge was bombed, the "good guy" and the villain agreed to tell the other half of the secret. The villain told the truth, but the "good guy" deceived the villain. This good guy is even smaller than the villain. . .
Fourth, this guy is sadistic. He abused the villain twice, but the villain only abused him once, still in revenge. Does that make him a "good guy"? ?
So, this guy is not a good person at all, he just pretends to be a good person. A bad person never hides his badness for survival and profit. A villain never cares what is good or bad because of survival and profit. A good person is always pretending to be a good person even for survival and profit. Good people, bad people, villains, they are actually a kind of people, neither good nor bad in the environment without laws and order in the west.
It is precisely because of this that the "good guys" will win the final duel. This is what the director wants to express. In the western environment where there is no law and only iron and blood, it is difficult to have really good people. Everyone is for survival and interests. . The pursuit of nihilistic justice is a joke, and it takes the wise to adapt to the wild west. This isn't the traditional "good triumphs over evil" old-fashioned western! And it also brought a little bit of irony and black humor, didn't you see it? Shoot and shoot, don`t talk more. Hahaha.
However, the "good guy" in the whole film got better twice, once when he helped the North Army to blow up the bridge, and once when he finally fulfilled the agreement after teasing the villain and left him half of the treasure.

View more about The Good, the Bad and the Ugly reviews

Extended Reading
  • Shanie 2022-04-24 07:01:02

    Watched it a second time to write a review, still so insistent that it was the best example of a Western.

  • Jeanne 2022-03-24 09:01:10

    Leone’s most personally styled western film, the most imitated movie in the golden age of Hong Kong film, The Good, the Good and The Good, the classics are being imitated in every passage. The confrontation between the three is like an ancient dragon. Sometimes I feel like watching martial arts, yellow sands, deserts, and lonely shadows. It's a bit like watching Wong Kar-wai's smiling and proud rivers and lakes, and it's a bit like watching Quentin's various movies. The revolving gun was beyond words, and Eastwood was indescribably handsome. Thanks to the library.

The Good, the Bad and the Ugly quotes

  • Blondie: [watching the soldiers fighting on the bridge] I have a feeling it's really gonna be a good, long battle.

    Tuco: Blondie, the money's on the other side of the river.

    Blondie: Oh? Where?

    Tuco: Amigo, I said on the other side, and that's enough. But while the Confederates are there we can't get across.

    Blondie: What would happen if somebody were to blow up that bridge?

    Tuco: Yeah. Then these idiots would go somewhere else to fight.

    Blondie: [lighting his match] Maybe.

  • One-armed Union soldier: [Wallace and Tuco are at the train station, handcuffed together] Hey, corporal, afraid he'll get lost? Where's the Rebel going?

    Cpl. Wallace: To Hell, with a rope around his neck and a price on his head.

    Tuco: Yeah... three thousand dollars, friend. That's a lot of money for a head.

    [He flips the soldier's empty sleeve]

    Tuco: I bet they didn't even pay you a penny for your arm.