This is not a 1+1=2 movie conspiracy theory OR therapy theory OR infinity theory

Felicia 2022-04-20 09:01:05

In fact, whether it is a conspiracy theory or a treatment of Lun, there is something that makes sense but it seems a bit far-fetched, isn't it? (A is a conspiracy theory view, B is a therapeutic view view)
1. When you first arrived on the island, all the guards were heavily guarded.
A. Because there is a conspiracy on this island, there are untold secrets, and the bailiffs are here. Do you think they will not be on guard?
B. Because Leonardo was originally the patient No. 67, he was doing role-playing psychotherapy, and he had a strong tendency to violence.
2.A. If it is therapeutic theory, why do you have to force the protagonist to surrender the gun? It is too realistic, right?
3. B.chuck's inexperience in handing over his gun shows that he is not a bailiff at all, but a doctor.
4.B.Leonardo recalled for the first time that when his wife died, the sky was filled with ashes, which at first glance seemed to have died in a fire. But the blood that kept pouring out of his wife's stomach seemed to tell us that his wife was not killed by a fire at all, but by a gunshot that coincided with the theory of therapy.
5.A. In order to treat a patient, all the people on the island are required to cooperate with the performance. The doctor may, but will he really join the patient? Also cut off the high-voltage line through labor?
6. When A.Leonardo asked the old woman, she panicked and wrote 'RUN' when only Leonardo was there. To remind him that there is a conspiracy here, let him run away quickly.
7.A. I remember when he was in the middle of taking him on a boat ride, he ran into a doctor with a syringe in his hand trying to subdue him.
B. can also be understood as a tranquilizer.
8. This is probably the most controversial episode. Leonardo found the real Rachel in the cave.
A. She was lighting a fire at that time, right? And she walks around the beach every day, of course her shoes are wet. Of course she waited until it was dry before wearing it. The next day, I'm going to move the nest, and of course I'm going to put on my shoes and go.
B. This is completely the imagination of the hero. The reason is that she was barefoot when she first met Rachel, but woke him the next day to find she was wearing shoes.
9.A. Finally Dr. Cowly told him that he was insane and his wife drowned 3 children. But why Leonardo always only dreamed and fantasized about one little girl, didn't he love the other two? Therefore, he had no children at all, and the knowledge he had dreamed of had acquired the mother and daughter before he had time.
B. If he is not crazy, how come the picture the doctor took out is the same as in his dream? Drugs can produce hallucinations, but they are not so powerful, right?
10. Finally, Leonardo's "Die with dignity, or live with the walking dead? (Some translate it to live like a monster or die like a good person?" Also There is Chuck's meaningful "Teddy?"
A.Leonardo is not crazy at all, he has not been successfully brainwashed. He thinks it is better to be a fool without thinking than to be a crazy person who pretends to be crazy. In the end, Chuck called him Teddy, it is necessary to finally Still roleplaying. He really is Teddy.
B.Leonardo is patient 67, but he is completely cured through roleplaying. He can't stand the pain of his previous crimes, killing his wife and losing his children .So I would rather choose "die". Calling him Teddy is really role-playing. Because before Leonardo said that when we escaped together, he had already responded to his "boss".
Anyway, everyone has their own understanding and opinions. No need to be sarcastic and abuse to refute others and prove their point of view. Some even think that it is both a treatment and a conspiracy. Others think that the protagonist is the German soldier who attempted suicide--



View more about Shutter Island reviews

Extended Reading

Shutter Island quotes

  • Teddy Daniels: They're experimenting on people here.

    Chuck Aule: I don't know, boss. How can you believe a crazy guy?

    Teddy Daniels: That's the beauty of it. Mental Patients make the perfect subjects, if they talk nobody listens to them!

  • Teddy Daniels: I am a federal Marshall. They can't stop me.

    Rachel 2: I was an esteemed psychiatrist from a respected family. Didn't matter.