Quoting a paragraph first, please skip it if you have read it.
-------------------------------------------------- ---------
From the discussion on the Internet, I saw that many people put forward the views of "Xiaobai is Wu Sang's girlfriend", "Qin Fen is an informer", I did not think of these when I read it, but carefully. In fact, there is a lot of evidence to show the truth, especially the scene of Wu Sang driving alone on the mountain road in Hokkaido, singing and crying. It lasted for 5 minutes. It can't be meaningless. The buried Easter egg, after careful recollection, suddenly realized that blind date and marriage proposal are just excuses for playing tricks. In fact, Feng Xiaogang's main purpose is to tell us another story, a story about Xiao Bai, Wu Sang, and Qin Fen
. Without the DVD, I can only rely on the recollection of the movie clips, and the language details may not be accurate.
Possible truth: Wu Sang and Qin Fen are good friends and work abroad. A group came from China, and there was a girl named Xiaobai. Wu Sang and Xiaobai fell in love and had a relationship, and at that time, they might also be pregnant. Wu Sang wanted to keep Xiaobai and begged Qin Fen. But Qin Fen told the secret. Xiaobai had to go back to China with the director. Finally committed suicide in the country. The child in the belly also died.
Evidence 1. When Qin Fen and Xiaoxiao exchanged secrets, he burst into tears.
Qin Fen said that he did not drink alcohol because he was afraid of thinking of Xiaobai who died because of him. But after drinking sake, Windsor Whiskey did not see any resistance from him. This inference must be a lie. But what is he trying to hide? Of course it is the truth. Before going to the Four Sisters, when Qin Fen and Xiaoxiao fell out in Hokkaido, Qin Fen confessed that he had been playing games with Xiaoxiao all the time. "Naturally, it's part of the game. Qin Fen told Jian Nanchun that what he said was the truth that reversed black and white, but the cry was real.
Evidence 2. Why did Wu Sang and Qin Fen go to the temple to attend the funeral first, and then go to the church for confession? Qin Fen may have arranged the
route . Qin Fen's trip to Hokkaido may have an important purpose to go to confession. First, he insisted on going to the temple, Unexpectedly, the temple happened to be holding a funeral. Qin Fen's cry at the funeral came from the heart, although he died later, he would not admit it. The temple failed to achieve the purpose of repentance, so he went to the church later, and he had to repeatedly confirm that the priest did not understand Chinese. , Because Qin Fen really wanted to tell the truth and hoped for redemption, but even in the face of a priest who didn't understand Chinese at all, Qin Fen still didn't have the courage to speak out after 4 hours. He actually didn't have the courage to face himself.
Evidence 3 .In the end Qin Fen gave Wu Sang money
Qin Fen gave him money, and said that the money was for his wife and children (the dead Xiaobai and the child in his belly), Wu Sang drove alone in the mountains, singing Japanese folk songs , sobbing slowly. He actually forgave Qin Fen, but Qin Fen never forgave himself. Xiaoxiao's suicide made Qin Fen's guilt turn into action. In Qin Fen's eyes, Xiaoxiao was Xiaobai's stand-in. What he owes Xiaobai, he can make up for her by smiling, so as to get out of the psychological shadow.
Maybe many people think it is nonsense, but I 100% believe that there is a poignant love story behind it. If everyone thinks it makes sense, you can Let’s analyze it together. If we can restore the truth behind this story, it will be very interesting.
PS-1: The cost of one minute of film is at least 30,000 yuan, and the director has to “card” a few times, and several million will go out. Are experienced masters really stupid enough to spend so much money and just describe their trips to Hokkaido to visit temples and churches with some low-level funny purpose?
PS-2: Ge You has never played an honest person, from editing This is the source of Uncle Ge's humor.
PS-3: If you only want to joke based on the surface content of the movie Is it too reluctant to have a love that lasts forever between Xiao and Qin Fen? If You Are the One is actually a tragedy, and this is also the realm that Director Feng has been pursuing in recent years. It's completely market demand, at least the smile that can bring me is very unnatural.
-------------------------------------------------- ---------
First of all, we assume that the above inference is true, then there are some doubts about Wu Sang's appearance in Hokkaido and taking root in Hokkaido. He himself is definitely not Japanese, as can be seen from Qin Fen's words: You look more and more like a Hokkaido farmer now, but your eyes are more cunning. This proves that Wu Sang must be Chinese. Traditional Chinese Confucianism is accustomed to self-deprecation. On the one hand, the word cunning has a playfulness among friends, and on the other hand, it also praises the wisdom of the Chinese people in terms of temperament compared with the Japanese, which is different. Then why did Wu Sang choose to stay in Hokkaido?
We can draw some clues from the conversation between Wu Sang and Qin Fen before leaving. Qin Fen said: The money is for your wife and children. In other words, Wu Sang got married and had children in Hokkaido. This raises new questions. The whole film Wu Sang's wife and children did not appear. This obviously makes no sense. If it is reasonable to say that Wu Sang's wife and children did not play together due to the language barrier, why didn't they show up when they picked up Qin Fen? You must know that Japan is a very polite country. This kind of human accident cannot be ignored, right? From Qin Fen's point of view, even if Yu Wusang's wife and children have different languages, as a guest, at least greetings and care must be indispensable, right? no! Chinese people love to be lively, I don't think anyone would mind playing with their friends' wives and girlfriends, right? It should be said that it is willing and like to get along with it. The seemingly loopholes in this whole film are also quietly showing some clues to us.
From the scene where Wu Sang drove away alone, with a sad face, crying, and the song repeated twice in Qin Fen and Wu Sang's mouth, combined with the above analysis, the answer is obvious, Wu Sang does not really have a wife And children, Qin Fen's wife and children refer to Xiaobai and the unborn child in her womb. Xiaobai is Wu Sang's girlfriend and is from Hokkaido, Japan. This conclusion is reasonable and reasonable for the entire film.
I think Xiaobai should be a lover of Chinese culture, so he chose to live in China and became a tour guide. In the process of leading a group, I met Wu Sang, a tour guide who also speaks Japanese. Meeting a soulmate in a foreign land, coupled with the misfortune of the family, the two hit it off at first sight, and sparks collided. The cruel reality of Wu Sang's helplessness prompted Xiao Bai's death. This was a knot in Wu Sang's heart that couldn't be shaken. The loved one died by himself, Wu Sang resolutely came to Xiaobai's hometown Hokkaido to fulfill their lifelong vows. Some people say that this is an escape from Wu Sang. Then I can only say that you don't understand what love is. The highest state of love is not to escape, but to face it. Wu Sang faced it, and in Qin Fen's guilt, the past was presented, humming the inspirational song that the three of them hummed together, and his thoughts burst out of the embankment like teardrops that were broken.
And what's the use of this, ten years of life and death are boundless, without thinking, since it is unforgettable. On the mountain road, who is humming the faint thoughts, and who is listening silently in the sky...
View more about If You Are the One reviews
