A bit of logical confusion

April 2022-10-04 01:58:57

There are two lines of light and dark: the open line is what actually happened outside the perspective of the male protagonist; the dark line is that the protagonist’s first wife died in a car accident because of his alcoholism history, causing his traumatic stress response in the following life, that is, the whole The film allows the audience to see the protagonist’s post-traumatic stress response, forgetting the suspicious narratives that are unfavorable to them.

The whole movie can basically watch everything that happened in the dark line male lead’s perspective from beginning to end, looking back

——I feel that there are some loopholes in the timeline on the light and dark lines, and it is easy for people to appear incomprehensible. At the beginning, when the husband and wife quarrel, my daughter asked for batteries. He went to the rest station instead of buying batteries. Instead, he bought wine, for follow-up After the daughter fell down by accident, his wife came to question him and was accidentally killed. The open line plot planted the foreshadowing. In a flashing moment in the film, the alcoholic male protagonist appeared to forget these bad things due to the stress reaction to protect himself. Fake the fact that the wife and daughter are absent again: the daughter only had a broken arm, and the wife's unharmed family of three went to the nearest hospital for medical treatment. For the bright line: the time to deal with the wife and daughter's corpse should be chosen again after his traumatic stress. Memory rewriting? Since the male protagonist has selectively forgotten what happened, he shouldn't deal with the scene of the first crime: Did he deal with the corpse after the moment he had forgotten? The actual police should be able to see the body of his wife and daughter when they went to the first scene of the crime. This is in line with the plot setting of "male protagonist's post-traumatic stress syndrome-alcohol dependence".

——Why did the doctor consult with his daughter about organ donation when the dark-line male lead was admitted to the hospital? This is a bit of a nuisance, because according to the story of the male lead’s two admissions, the male lead did not actually bring his wife or daughter into the hospital. How did the hospital know Do an organ transplant....

——The dark line male protagonist deliberately believes that the hospital is going to rescue his wife and daughter under the premise of hacking his wife’s and daughter’s organs, but in the hospital’s dark line plot, he did not explain to the doctor to deal with the head contusion for him, even if he slept in the hospital. Great sleep, the stress reaction subsided the next point, but the anxiety in the male protagonist’s heart has not been reduced by half, and it is a turning point of this persecuted delusion... how this male protagonist is a person with complex and comprehensive psychological depression. ..

Even if the male protagonist is tossing about three shots of adrenaline after taking a tranquilizer, his absurd perspective is completely muddled, but there shouldn't be some timeline ambiguity. What a non-factual hidden line technique wants to express can only be more uncertain, untenable, and all is a madman’s fantasy-delusion-chaos. The eye-catching point of this film is estimated to be this point of arrogance. But the logic of incompatibility makes it difficult to swallow...

View more about Fractured reviews

Extended Reading

Fractured quotes

  • Dr. Berthram: So, what's the story, young lady?

    Peri Monroe: I fell.

    Dr. Berthram: Yeah. Sooner or later everybody does. Right dad?

  • Ray Monroe: Next year we fly.

    Joanne Monroe: How about next year we stay home...

Related Articles