I really think that some of the details and plot logic in this movie are too mentally retarded! ! After watching it, I don't say it and feel full of grievances!
Write it down first, I have never seen Korean war movies except this one, and I have little contact with Korean movies and TV dramas, so my vision will be narrower.
Let me talk about two military theoretical doubts.
First: It can be seen from the beginning of the movie that the reason why the two sides did not negotiate the peace talks is because of the ownership of this high ground, not to mention whether there is a high ground on the entire front that has delayed the negotiation process, but this high ground can also be regarded as a key attack. (Defense) Target, right?
However, in the whole movie, the Korean army has an M1 or Garand, and the automatic firepower is terrible. (Maybe I didn't pay attention to it, but I don't seem to have seen a Thomson or other submachine guns, but the North Korean army and the volunteer army. There are some pps.) Not to mention heavy weapons, there are no tanks, cannons, and heavy machine guns. When attacking a fortress, one person and one rifle go up. When defending, there are no heavy weapons such as heavy machine guns, and all light weapons are defending.
According to common sense, this kind of hard-bone highland is still the kind of highland that determines the direction of negotiation. No matter what, we have to use elite troops or a large number of reserve troops into the battlefield. However, this has always been this army, and the heaviest infantry firepower is the old one. Sergeant's RMB, the only attacking firepower support is a few attack aircraft... When did the American father become so stingy? What about infantry fire support? What about tanks? What about heavy artillery? What about bombers?
Second, the whole movie is very exciting and in-depth, but the military literacy of this unit in the movie is very uneven. From the protagonist to the military camp, there is a feeling of unorganized and undisciplined. This is a deliberate arrangement by the director. I understand, but according to the development of the plot, the war continues, and everyone's cohesion and fighting consciousness have been raised, why is it still a lack of organizational discipline.
For example, if a small group of people went to kill a sniper for "two seconds" and knew how to kill a sniper, how could they still play on a bare mountain top? Is it so relaxing and romantic? It feels like a group of people going on an outing. In the end, the position where the little soldier stood, let alone the sniper, was standing on the top of the mountain with a human target...
Moreover, in the section where the top commander was shot dead in the war room to take command, I only saw the word mutiny in this section... Yes, brothers' lives are important, comrades-in-arms are of great importance, and the commander "misjudged"...
But from a global perspective, the supreme commander ordered you to stick to this hill. This hill is of strategic significance, you cannot give up, and fight to the last person! Then the soldiers and non-commissioned officers below thought, Supreme Commander, you TM fart! Then he shot the supreme commander of the battlefield and ran away from the strategic target with someone! ! Ran! !
This is like, the Japanese invaders surrounded Nanjing City, the chairman ordered, TMD Nanjing City cannot give up! There are people in the city, and Nanjing City has strategic significance! Fight to the last person, waiting for the addition! Then the soldiers in the city thought, my brotherhood! Friendship is important! My life is important! And then mutiny, ran away from Nanjing City, the result? (I don't know much about Nanjing City as an example, no offense)
If wars are fought like this, what are they fighting for? What do you want the headquarters for? Direct skirmishers can fight guerrillas! (stand up)
And this commander is also very fascinated. I don’t know who is the commander from the beginning to the end. a feeling of. (Maybe I didn't look carefully)
And those Japanese lines are too weird, right?
"This war will end with our own hands!" (black question mark face)
finally! Regarding the plot of the shooting of the friendly army when retreating, it is still as I said. Since you know that the commander needs to be in the order after you have shot and killed the highest commander, should the commander be killed in battle? ! !
How to retreat is the same as crowding a bus? There is no commander to arrange, and there is no commander to arrange, everyone is just squeezing each other? It's a retreat or a rout... even if it's a rout, you hit an allied army with a .50 machine gun (this machine gun is a large caliber machine gun mounted on a tank, plane, or jeep carrier, and can be used to hit the opposite plane or light armor , you can also beat people into blood fog.), the friendly army next to him just watched, and no one stopped him, and he was washed white after the end? ? The war is really cruel, your brain is broken, right? It's not enough to scare twice with a machine gun. Those brothers who didn't get on the boat are still eligible to surrender!
Then there are all sorts of familiar plots. The hard currency in American war movies—chocolate, is also given when you see it, and there are also various scenes that you can’t tell where you’ve seen it. For example, let the protagonist go to Investigating the red comrades in the army. Before leaving, I mentioned that there was a friend in the army under investigation. My first reaction was that this person must be a red comrade. Wait, there are too many...
However, the looks of the actors and actresses in this movie are really amazing. I used to watch war movies and saw a disgraced girl and thought it was a beauty in the army. As a result, the heroine in this movie looks amazing! Ha ha
There are so many complaints, in fact, the movie is very good, and the war scenes are also very grand and amazing. The central idea of anti-war is even more enlightening. It is the details and the logic of the plot that really make me a little confused, maybe because of the war between Europe and America. The show is spoiled (laughs).
View more about The Front Line reviews
