"Assembly" is a completely unreasonable story

Merritt 2022-04-20 09:02:26

Just a few words:

An established company went through a fierce battle in the National Liberation War. After covering the retreat of the entire regiment with its own sacrifice, it disappeared without a trace, and there is no trace of it being completely wiped out? ? This is almost unimaginable in the army? !

A group of independent second divisions, 139 regiments, 3 battalions, and 9 companies that had been established as a cover for the safe transfer of the large troops disappeared. Did the superiors even ask questions? In "Assembly", it is difficult to justify it by using the reorganization as an excuse. The most important thing for soldiers is their experience and background. No veteran will ever forget the troops they fought. No matter how they are reorganized, they all know their roots.

It's not just that Gu Zidi can't figure it out, but anyone who has a little understanding of the PLA's organizational structure will not understand it! !

Secondly, a division, with a number of people + heavy firepower that can't be compared with company-level units, counts on a company that is responsible for blocking, under wide terrain, delaying hours of time, this kind of battle, if it is not commanding brain show Funny, or rely on fantasy to play. Of course, with a modern director's ignorance of war, anything is possible.

Also, in "Assembly", the company's instructor could actually be a timid cultural instructor who was temporarily pulled from the confinement room. This is completely unimaginable in an army where the party commands guns.

In a blocking war, the task of the blocking troops is to buy time for the action of the large troops. It is enough to stand firm or retreat after completing the task. In the operation of a regiment-level unit, retreating with the sound of a rallying horn is a very nonsense idea in itself. , unless it is a few hundred meters away!

"Assembly" is a story that can't stand any scrutiny (although the actors are good). It leaves the authenticity of history and uses a random story to talk about inspiration. It's completely nonsense!

View more about Ji jie hao reviews

Extended Reading
  • Rozella 2022-03-19 09:01:09

    I admire movies on this subject very much. I appreciate the fact that China can produce movies of this type and quality.

  • Miles 2022-03-18 09:01:08

    Samsung: What is missing, the tension is still insufficient. Compared with previous war movies on the mainland, the scenes are better, and the characters are more realistic and plump. But there is no reflection on the breakthrough of the war, especially for this civil war. Of course, this must take into account film control. I just thought, how did the descendants of the national army and the descendants of the communist army feel when they watched these kinds of movies together? Feng Xiaogang did not describe the national army positively, which is worth thinking about.