The reason for the poor script

Declan 2022-04-19 09:02:47

1. Explain the past of the old lady, and subtract points from this story, because this is not a movie about the old lady. To talk about the interaction between the old lady and the heroine, you must focus on the interaction between the old lady and the heroine.

2. Why does the heroine love music? I didn't make it clear at all. What was the effect on her of being raped and murdered by the character of Jia? What does it have to do with music, no explanation. Missing script.

3. World War II that is inexplicable. It doesn't have to be related to war to be called depth.

4. If you like jazz, you should be anti-classical? There is clearly a lack of aesthetics and understanding of music. Since the heroine is a musical genius, she can obviously appreciate classical music, but she prefers jazz, and she will never depreciate classical music just because she likes jazz, because classical music is also free. Music itself is very free.

5. The old lady doesn't seem to play any role in educating the heroine's piano skills. Because the heroine's last dazzling skills are all her own abilities. Then the whole drama becomes "I play the piano very well, there is an old lady to teach me, but it is useless, my dick has nothing to do with her", then what is the significance of their interaction?

If the old lady is the spiritual education of the heroine, this makes sense, but the movie obviously did not make this point, and the inexplicable flashback weakened the strength of the final bow.

6. The director obviously didn't think about what to shoot, and didn't know the priority. Do you want to shoot the heroine's spiritual freedom? So her freedom is in life-and-death competitions, showing off her skills (nonsense)? (Although it's not called nonsense, but the heroine obviously didn't take this game seriously) Do you want to film the old lady's education of the heroine? See the previous paragraph for the reason.

7. After playing the piano, the audience was stunned for a few seconds and applauded - a bridge that is too old-fashioned, too old-fashioned, and too tacky. Check out the popping drummer. And at that time, the audience's reaction was simply secondary, the important thing was the old lady's reaction, the camera should be given to the old lady immediately, and the audience's applause could be given by the voice.

View more about Four Minutes reviews

Extended Reading

Four Minutes quotes

  • Gertrud 'Traude' Krüger: You think today was an easy day for me? Why do you think I've stayed here for 60 years?

    Jenny von Loeben: Because of a dead body? Great! A lesbian who likes corpses. You're a perverted freak, madam.

  • Gertrud 'Traude' Krüger: Today is my last day. I just want to get my piano.

    Kowalski: Tell me, Mrs. Krüger... What do those guys have that others don't?

    Gertrud 'Traude' Krüger: One's a murderer and the other raped his niece.

    Kowalski: I'll miss you, Mrs. Krüger.