The fatal wound and preciousness of "One Life"

Nick 2022-04-19 09:02:50

The fatal flaw of "One Life" is that it tries too much to show a complete story, and the protagonist's life and destiny development are described too trivially and mundanely, so that what should be the willpower of the movie characters through the initiative of revenge (let The film exhibits a critical force), degenerates into a passive desperate struggle with reality, and eventually degenerates into a vulgar tragic tale of fatalism that undermines the entire film. The same is death, a person who does not want to live, and a person who wants to die are two completely different things. From tragic to tragic, the subjective will of knowing that it cannot be done must be more fully displayed. The poster said "Life を hang け て, ask う", at least in this way, the movie does not have this slogan as loud and powerful.
Aside from this regrettable shortcoming, this is still a solid samurai film with character. The image performance and dialogue of lines hidden in period dramas by Ichikawa Haila are full of personal charm. It is difficult to find other candidates of the same type among actors of the same age in the current Japanese entertainment circle. Ryuichi Sakamoto's soundtrack is clean and concise, neither flooded nor overly emotional (which is vastly better than most Japanese movies, not to mention Japanese dramas where the music is overwhelming). Director Takashi Miike has some parts that compromise the audience, but he also maintains a consistent authorship, showing the audience a cruel and real scene without hesitation, and even exaggerating this cruelty (such as the detailed description of Eita's repeated belly-cutting with a bamboo knife).
It is unrealistic to compare it with Kobayashi Masaki's "Cut the Belly". Times are changing, the environment for filming is changing, and the needs of the audience are also changing. According to Miike's expectations, the film has been trying to show a lost masculinity that may no longer conform to the spirit of the current Japanese era, showing sincerity and exposing shortcomings. It is not perfect, but it is already commendable.

View more about Hara-Kiri: Death of a Samurai reviews

Extended Reading

Hara-Kiri: Death of a Samurai quotes

  • Kageyu: Each man has his own honor. We are nothing without it! Without the heart to preserve that, we can preserve nothing!

  • Motome Chijiiwa: A husband must provide for his wife and child.