The following is the repost, which is written in great detail. My friends who are on the horns can be relieved a lot after reading it, but there is no need to think so much. After all, the screenwriter did not think so much.
Intermediate: The Perfect Ending? 1. Is Lu Xiaoyu dead? Yes, the evidence is Xiaoyu's hair. Careful friends will find: Lu Xiaoyu has not traveled through time and space for five months, and her hair is longer than when she first met Ye Xianglun; the graduation ceremony and Ye Xianglun hug and Li Kebai are all longer hair. And Xiaoyu's hair that Ye Xianglun saw after traveling through time and space was short, not long! And it wasn't the day of the graduation ceremony, Lu Xiaoyu was doing his homework; and he didn't seem to know Ye Xianglun, it should be said that he didn't know him. Xiaoyu did die, and Lu Xiaoyu, who loved Ye Xianglun, died; to some extent, this is the biggest tragedy of the film. Because Xiao Lun did not return to the day of the graduation ceremony in 1979. Assuming that the graduation ceremony is on September 1st, and Xiaoyu discovered the piano score on March 1st, Xiao Lun may have returned to February 1st, 1979, when nothing happened. Moreover, according to the "parallel universe" entry of Baidu Encyclopedia, it shows that Xiao Lun may return to another dimension, and Xiao Yu in that space does not know Xiao Lun yet. 2. Where did Ye Xianglun go? I call 99 years space-time A and 79 years space-time B. Xiaoyu B of time and space B travels through time and space to have a love affair with Xianglun A of time and space A. When Xianglun A, who knows everything about time and space A also wants to travel through time and space, what Xianglun A comes to is not time and space B, but time and space C, met Xiaoyu C; time and space C was before Xiaoyu discovered the piano score of "secret", and everything had not happened. 3. How to interpret graduation photos? The unspoken rule of traveling through time and space is that only the person who sees it for the first time can see you. The graduation photo shows that everyone in time and space C can see Xianglun A; Xianglun A of time-space A stays in time-space C forever, and the unspoken rules are invalid. 4. Why did Ye Xianglun go to the third dimension? Lu Xiaoyu B from Time and Space B successfully came to Time and Space A every time. The original soundtrack CD of "The Secret That Can't Be Said" has 2 versions of the "Secret" piano music, one is the normal version of Lu Xiaoyu, and the other is the accelerated version of Ye Xianglun. Ye Xianglun was in an urgent situation at the time, so he popped up an accelerated version of "Secret" and returned to an earlier time-space C. And because it is impossible for Xiaoyu B and Xiaoyu C to meet in a space, it is impossible for Xiaoyu B to go to time and space C, and Xiao Lun in space C has not been born, so naturally he will not meet, so Xiao Lun A may go to time and space C. 5. How to change history? The primary chapter mentioned the consistency of two different time and space, so what was done at an earlier time will change the future history, so the final ending of this film is: time and space A's Xianglun A has returned to earlier than time and space B space-time C, changed all the history of space-time B and A.
Advanced: The Hidden Secrets of History
Do you think you know all the secrets of the movie? Did you really understand "The Untold Secret"? One, three time and three light rain. Xiaoyu B of time-space B died, Xiaoyu C of time-space C and Xianglun A lived happily together; what about Xiaoyu of time-space A? Xiaoyu C in space-time C is earlier than space-time B and space-time A, so Xiao Lun changed the fate of Xiaoyu C in space-time C, so that Xiaoyu C did not die. You may say that the light rain B in the space-time B is not dead, and where is the light rain A in the space-time A? If you think carefully about the words that Xiaoyu engraved on the table, it was originally not there, but it suddenly appeared, because Xiaoyu B in space-time B changed; Assuming that there was no misunderstanding, Xiaoyu B would not have been stimulated and died of an asthma attack; A's desk has no words until Xiaoyu B in space-time B does not write. Similarly, before Xiaoyu B in space-time B dies, Xiaoyu in space-time A also does not die! But Xiaoyu A in time and space A is in 1999, and of course Xiaoyu A in 1979 is not dead! 2. Xiaoyu's existence in Time-Space A in 1999 proves that Xiaoyu's mother was not crazy in 1999. Xiaoyu at this time should be a middle-aged man in his forties. The first time Xiaoyu B took Xianglun A to the roof of her house, before going upstairs, a middle-aged woman was photographed watching Ye Xianglun go up the roof (she couldn't see Xiaoyu B), that person was not Xiaoyu's mother, It is the middle-aged Xiaoyu A. The second time Xiaoyu B didn't go to "class" for many days, Xianglun went to Xiaoyu's house to meet her mother and bought a lot of apples. Of course, the apple is for Xiaoyu, not because of madly missing Xiaoyu who died. The third time Xianglun went to Xiaoyu's house, Xiaoyu's mother said that Xiaoyu was resting, and then went into the house. At the same time, the camera cut to the second floor of Xiaoyu's house. Ye Xianglun's movements were consistent with the movements of Xiaoyu's mother when she first entered. The person watching on the second floor was not Xiaoyu's mother, but middle-aged Xiaoyu A. The fourth time Xianglun went to Xiaoyu's house, it was also the first time he went in. It was also the time when Xiaoyu found out that Xiaoyu was missing, and it was also when Xiaoyu found out that Xianglun was holding Qingyi's bracelet and died of grief and illness. Xiaoyu's mother asked Xianglun to come into the house and said that Xiaoyu listened to songs in the house. Indeed, Xiaoyu A listened to songs in the house, but the corresponding Xiaoyu B 20 years ago died before Xianglun entered the house. Time and Space A The history of Xiaoyu was changed because of the change of time and space B. At the same time, Xianglun discovered Xiaoyu's hand-painted portrait of Xianglun. At the same time, Xiaoyu's mother cried and said, "Mom should believe in Xiaoyu." At this time, Xiaoyu's mother was also changed by history, Think Xiaoyu is dead. Before Xiaoyu's mother always said that Xiaoyu was there, it was not crazy; it was true that Xiaoyu A existed before. 3. Analysis of the ending Time and Space A Ye Xianglun's father lost his son, maybe he was punished for not keeping Xiaoyu's secret, it was a tragedy; Time and Space B Road Xiaoyu's mother lost her daughter because her daughter read "secret" The piano score is considered a tragedy; Time and Space B's Lu Xiaoyu is not believed by everyone, even teased, tortured, and died with endless grief, which is considered a tragedy; Time and Space A Ye Xianglun wants to go to Time and Space B to find the way to love him Xiaoyu B, but there is no way to see each other again, it has become an eternal tragedy; Dayong is fooled by believing in Xiaoyu, Qingyi wrongly falls in love with Ye Xianglun but has no results, it is a tragedy... The last time and space A's Xianglun A went to time-space C, changed all the history of time-space B and time-space A, prevented all tragedies from happening, and became a perfect ending, which can be regarded as a more dramatic ending. (This is also the ending that the audience wants to see) Notes: Time and Space A: Time and Space of 99 Years B: Time and Space of 79 Years C: Time and Space of 79 Years Before Xiao Yu did not discover the piano score. Corresponding to the three time-spaces, there are three Xiaoyu ABC and one Xianglun A; the time-space B and C in 1979 did not exist in Xianglun BC, and they were not born. *Multiple time and space: Our space is divided into countless copies by time; only special forces can travel through it. Li Kebai: also known as "correction fluid" and "correction fluid" 4. Supplement to the synchronous change of history (a secret that I didn't want to tell) In the movie, like traveling through time and space, it brings the same unexplainable phenomenon, the synchronization of history. Change. Everyone knows about the Li Kebai incident. The words on the table suddenly appeared; this phenomenon has never happened in real life, at least it has not been confirmed. The reason why words suddenly appear on the table is because someone in time-space B has changed history, so the time-space things after time-space B have changed accordingly, but due to the coexistence of multiple time-spaces, the changed time-space has It seems like something suddenly comes out or goes out. So suddenly words appear on the table, suddenly someone disappears from history, suddenly someone's memory is modified and so on... Xiaoyu A and B both fell in love with Xiao Lun at the same time, experienced misunderstanding incidents, and disappeared from history at the same time, but it was only 20 years later; but all of this was experienced by Xiaoyu B, and Xiaoyu A was just passive synchronous change Having the same experience, Xiaoyu A actually did not have direct contact with Xiao Lun, but was constantly changed by history and eventually disappeared. In fact, this is just a movie, a fantasy plot; in real life, human beings have not yet proven a feasible plan to travel through time and space; there has not been a synchronous change in history, and even if it does, it is impossible to know. Maybe "The Theory of Relativity proposed by Einstein itself is a fallacy", or maybe human technology has not yet developed to that point, in any case, this is just a fantasy movie plot. I hope you can understand the above content, and even if you don't understand, don't continue to ask questions. This is a fictional movie in itself, not a reality. That's reality, that's a movie. Some people would say that Ye Xianglun went back to the past to change all history. Isn't that how he has two selves? God will arrange another person for Huang Qiusheng to be his son. Xiao Lun talked to the air and no one found out? Others can't see Xiaoyu, so naturally they can't hear Xiaoyu's words. This question is really "good". If you turn it over, if you are talking, the person opposite you can only see you opening your mouth, but can't hear you. voice, that only shows that you are not a normal person. Xiao Lun never asked other people about Xiao Yu, so he found out that there was no such person. Dayong is not being beaten stupid, is it... What is it, do you want to travel through time and space to ask him? I can give a satisfactory ending to those who are on the horns: Xiao Lun is a patient in a psychiatric hospital, and it turns out that all this is just his fantasy. I can give a satisfying ending to those who don't want to think about it: Xiao Lun returned to 20 years later and continued to live happily with Xiao Yu. Everyone should be back to reality, this is just a movie. What I want to say myself: I started to regret it after I wrote the whole article. It was originally a "secret that couldn't be told" and shouldn't have been written; it's enough for everyone to be moved. To the author of the above paragraph: In fact, if it wasn't for what you wrote, maybe no one would read it many times to find the answer, and it also helped many people answer the questions that they still don't understand in their hearts, so thank you! (I know this is not a place to follow up, so I'm sorry, I just don't know how to tell the author) 6. The central idea of this film is that what has happened in the real world has no way to change history , In fact, what Jay Chou wants to express in this movie is: Cherish the most beautiful things around you, including love and family. The correction of the secret that cannot be told and the correction of the four questions. In the above-mentioned plot synopsis, Xiao Lun returned to the classroom after the graduation ceremony and recalled about Xiaoyu and saw "I am Xiaoyu, I love you, do you love me?" ?" After the words, he wrote "Where are you" crazily. When Xiao Lun wanted to write "I love you too", he was completely out of oil. Xiao Lun tried his best to carve a heart with the tip of his pen (seeing that he was desperate because The last stroke of the heart has a long tail. Probably too excited). Then I went to Xiaoyu's house. Question 1: The note incident The students passed the note to Qingyi because they could not see the light rain. Why does Xiaoyu know, the camera points to Xiaoyu and smiles at Xiaolun, even if Xiaoyu sees the note in Qingyina, she should understand Xiaolun's misunderstanding. A: Xiaoyu should not know. According to the dialogue: Dayong: "Dayong thought Xiaoyu was going to bounce back." Xiaoyu: "No, I'm here to find Xiaolun." Dayong: "I made you fail again." Xiaoyu: (laughs) ... Zhou Dayong: "Qingyi is here." Then Xiaoyu followed curiously to see... Simple can be understood as: coincidence of time. And isn't tragedy the result of so many bad coincidences? Question 2: Why did Dad Ye even know what Xiaoyu and his mother said when he recalled Xiaoyu, and what Xiaoyu thought (the bracelet incident). A: Start telling a story. The protagonist of this story is no longer the storyteller. Question 3: Except for the people Xiaoyu first saw in the film. Others can't see the light rain, so if a classmate walks like a light rain and can't see the light rain, will the light rain be a transparent classmate and pass through her body? Have you noticed carefully that when the corridor is very crowded, some people avoid the light rain while walking. Answer: Since the theory of time and space travel is all negative, the physical properties of the objects passing through can also be arbitrarily assumed. It can be explained like this: Explanation 1: Especially in the college corridors, people don’t often run around, so if you see someone walking by with closed eyes, you will let them open more. Explanation 2: In the paragraph of recollection, Xiaoyu should know that there are many people “discussing” when he is counting his steps, and Xiaoyu is a smart person. Judging from the empirical evidence of several “back to the future”, he is very good at “picking the time”. ". Correct answer: "When the corridor is very crowded, Xiaoyu walks to avoid Xiaoyu", that is Xiaoyu's test 108 steps to Xianglun's classroom 20 years ago. When Xiaoyu went to 1999, people who couldn't see her could also touch her (if Xiaoyu didn't get out of the way), if Xiaoyu took an apple to eat in front of people, others could only shout: "There's a ghost~..!" Because seeing apples floating in the air being bitten by invisible things. Question 4: Regarding the incident of Xiao Lun passing the note.. Correct answer: Xiao Lun wanted to pass the note to Xiaoyu, but the classmates could not see Xiaoyu and passed the note to Qingyi by mistake. Since Qingyi, Xiaoyu smiled at Xiao Lun because Xiao Lun often turned around and smiled at Xiao Yu, so Xiao Yu didn’t know the note. When she was in the piano room, Xiao Yu just wanted to find Xiao Lun after school, but she didn’t know Xiao Lun. The affair between Lun and Qingyi. Hence the misunderstanding. I would like to ask: After Xiao Lun returns to the past, is it only Xiao Yu who can see him? Then Xiao Yu will have to date someone who no one else can see? Then Xiao Yu will still be able to see him. What should I do if I am called a neuropathy by others? Will the graduation photo really be taken for granted? 1. Xiaoyu, who went to 1999, can still touch physical things. For example, she can pick up an apple to eat and a glass to drink water, but when people who can't see her see her, they will suspect that she is a ghost. So the piano keys can be pressed down, and the piano sound can be released. In addition, what the bearded teacher heard when she was found was not her laughter, but the sound of something in the cabinet almost falling down. 2. Xiaoyu didn't know about the note that day. She just wanted to come to Xiaolun after school. She happened to meet Qingyi, and at the same time she heard the sound of the piano that Xiaolun was playing, so she went to have a look. As a result, the tragedy began. . 3. There is no limit to the number of times to travel through time and space, so Xiaoyu selectively took some courses in 1979 and some courses in 99. 4. When I didn't show up and saw Dayong for 15 days, why did Xiaoyu see the wrong person or take a few steps wrong, but didn't go back and forth between 1979 and 1999 until he saw Xiao Lun? Because of Timing, choose the time carefully, after the class bell rang; before the get out of class bell rang and a few minutes before the end of school, the number of people in the corridor was minimal, and you were not afraid to close your eyes and bump into others. And after school, you can't go wrong, because Xiao Lun went home after wasting time. If you keep looking at the wrong person, the sound of the piano playing back and forth can attract a lot of attention. 5. Why was the old piano demolished along with the old piano room? Apart from common reasons such as "poor sound", "decision of the school", I guess it is because people have been hearing the piano sound from an old piano that no one has played for a year, and it was misunderstood as haunted, Unlucky old pianos are of course abandoned. 6. The guqin is responsible for creating a magical resonance with the player of
1. First of all, this play is actually a tragedy, but the mystery in it is often fascinating, and the final graduation photo also comforts everyone, which is a perfect place for this movie. 2. The details of this drama are very strict, which is in line with the characteristics of the drama. 3. The interlude of this film is good enough to not mention it. There is another point. When Xianglun and Xiaoyu chatted for the first time, they played Likebai I. Later, when Xianglun adventured the secret, they also played Likebai I. Ingenious. I can only summarize these points. With these points, it can be fully explained that the meteor,
View more about Secret reviews
