I re-watched this film on a whim today. I did have a new discovery, and it was a theory that others had ten years ago, but probably no one believed it at the time.
That is Ye Xianglun, who finally finished playing Hasty Keys. Did he go back to the past and meet Xiaoyu whom he didn't know?
In fact, he couldn't go back to the past. First of all, he didn't finish the tune. This is Jay Chou's hint to our audience. This is a clear clue, which directly implies to us that the tune hasn't been played yet, so Ye Xianglun didn't go back. You were crushed to death, and the subsequent scene of reuniting with Lu Xiaoyu, you can understand it as a near-death experience, or it can be understood as a fictional scene that the director did not want the audience to be too sad about this sad ending.
In fact, Jay Chou has never been an optimist, don't look at his laughing appearance, in fact, this kid is very addicted to tragedy. All his MVs basically have no comedy endings, but why does this movie give everyone a comedy ending? Because one of the women he cared about the most said she liked comedy endings. Of course, this is my own association. Whether it is or not, Jay Chou is still reluctant to let his film debut stay in an overly sad evaluation. He is still merciful. However, Ye Xianglun is still dead, and this answer will eventually be discovered, just as it has been discovered by me now.
It is estimated that people who read my film review will not be able to accept it. After all, everyone has been deceived by the director for so many years, and everyone has analyzed it for so many years. How could it be broken by my film review? Regardless of whether there are people who are destined to see my film review, I will write it out. The text will be recorded in the information space. Maybe in different time and space, I will meet people who resonate with me and come to the exchange through time and space.
Let me continue to explain why Ye Xianglun failed to go back in the end. Maybe I shouldn't be able to return it in the end, because it seems that Ye Xianglun can return.
First of all, although this is a fantasy movie, it strictly follows the logic of parallel space-time theory, not random. The screenwriter is very strict, and the impossible time and space will not appear.
Ye Xianglun cannot go back to the past. Only Lu Xiaoyu can stay in 1979, or go to 1999, which is like a time-space tunnel. But Ye Xianglun can't go back to 1979, because there is no way to go back, Ye Xianglun in 1979 does not exist at all, it is impossible for a person to appear out of thin air, so in 1979 Ye Xianglun did not exist in this time and space. There are three time and space in the movie, one is Lu Xiaoyu in 1979, the other is middle-aged Xiaoyu who was sick in 1999, and the other is because Lu Xiaoyu traveled to 1999 through the piano score and met Ye Xianglun, Qingyi, Dayong and others. short time. That is to say, Lu Xiaoyu can meet anyone in 1999 through time and space through the "rule of first sight".
As long as it's the first sight, it doesn't mean that she and Ye Xianglun are the only couple with fate. She and others also have fate, because every time she came to 1999, she would meet someone at first sight. And Ye Xianglun was only the first time she met, and in this short time and space, they were attracted to each other just because they were bosom friends. Although falling in love would never end, the two still fell in love.
Let me continue my analysis.
There were Lu Xiaoyu in 1979 and 1999. And if Lu Xiaoyu in 1979 did not die, Lu Xiaoyu in 1999 would not die either. Lu Xiaoyu in 1979 died, then the time and space would be rewritten, and the middle-aged Xiaoyu in 1999 would not appear.
Just like Jay Chou thought he would see Xiaoyu when he wrote the correction fluid, in fact, Xiaoyu is impossible to see. Xiaoyu and Ye Xianglun can only meet in this time and space disorder in 1999, and Ye Xianglun can't go back to meeting her in 1979. And this fantasy movie has practical significance, not fantasy for fantasy, and reality is just like that, there are many tragedies, many irreversible. On the surface, it can be rewritten infinitely, but in fact the rules are locked and there is not much room for rewriting. I don't know if many people have watched the Japanese drama marriage proposal battle? That show is also very logical. You can change a little decision at some important nodes and affect time and space, but the wheel of history is rolling forward, and man-made conscious changes are not very maneuverable.
What Jay Chou wants to convey is that if you miss something, you can't get it back. It's not that you can go back to the past if you want to play fast. Even if it's a fantasy movie, we still can't change the reality, so we must cherish and love the people who are there. The chance to be together, don't let her down, or you will lose her forever. In the end, you will only live in the fantasy that you are still in her world.
It can only be said that these two people have different time and space at all. They just met and fell in love by fate, but there is no condition for them to be happy together in the end - this is also Jay Chou's view of feelings and world view!
Don't say anything else, go back to the movie, people in different time and space should never fall in love, whether it's Lu Xiaoyu who stayed in 1999 (only one person can be seen, others can't see her, she exists like a ghost), or Ye Xianglun Go back to the impossible path of 1979 (Ye Xianglun did not exist in 1979, some people may say, you didn’t understand, the score is very clear, play quickly and you can go back to the past, and everyone I can see her! Many people are confused by what the piano score says, and give up the bigger logic (greater cycle), in fact, this is a wrong understanding, this is only valid for Lu Xiaoyu in 1979, because Lu Xiaoyu was originally from 1979. How could people in 1979 not see her? It's ridiculous. And Ye Xianglun was from 1999, and of course everyone can see him. However, if you assume that Jay Chou can really wear it back to 1979 Can everyone see him? This is nonsense. Xiaoyu is a piano score that Xiaoyu picked up in 1979. The meaning of the text corresponds to that Xiaoyu can briefly travel to the future time and space that did exist in 1999, and can also go back to 1979. That Xiaoyu was still in the time and space of Tamkang College, but Ye Xianglun could not wear it to 1979. As I said just now, there was no Ye Xianglun in 1979.) Another point, when Xiaoyu died in 1979, 1979 and 1999 Even if the piano room has not been demolished at this time, it will not change anything for Ye Xianglun, Xiaoyu has completely disappeared from Ye Xianglun's world, because any connection between Lu Xiaoyu and Ye Xianglun depends on the relationship between Lu Xiaoyu and Ye Xianglun. Yu Lu Xiaoyu, not Ye Xianglun. Therefore, there is no such thing as Ye Xianglun who can go back to an earlier past, and cannot go back at all.
I don't know if everyone understands what I wrote, and it doesn't matter. If someone analyzes this movie in the future, they will definitely accept this view, although it is a little sad.
View more about Secret reviews
