Question Directory:
(1) Did Akash recover his sight at the end?
(2) Did Akash recover his eyesight before taking the sago away with the doctor?
(3) Why did Simi go to Akash's house and just blind him instead of killing him?
(4) Why did Akash fake the scene of Simi's suicide?
(5) What is Akash's revenge plan?
(6) Why would Akash help Simi remove the blindfold?
(7) Which plots in the movie actually happened? Which plots are the stories made up by Akash.
(8) Doctors end up with life or death.
(9) Why did Akash pull the can so hard in the end?
(10) The role of the rabbit in the movie.
1. Did Akash recover his sight at the end?
In fact, Akash's fierce blow to the can from the end of the film already shows that Akash has recovered his vision. It is impossible to hit so accurately without seeing it.
Secondly, it is obviously too far-fetched to be able to judge Sufi by shaking hands without seeing him for two years. This can be regarded as a foreshadowing of Akash's recovery.
2. Did Akash recover his eyesight before taking the sago away with the doctor?
I think Akash did not recover his eyesight before Akash and the doctor took Simi away, because there is nowhere in the movie that Akash has recovered his eyesight .
Some people believe that Akash's eyesight was restored early because Akash's eyes were different when he was blind, and the blind rabbit also had different eyes, so he thought that one eye was restored early. But in fact, I think this argument has little to do with the argument. There are no two identical leaves in the world, and there are no two identical eyes in the world. The two blind eyes are different. This is more in line with reality. It shows that one eye is slightly injured and he has recovered early.
Next, let's take a look at some screenshots that Akash's eyes have not seen before, let's look backwards.
Akash overpowered Simi. When he rescued the doctor, he staggered all the way, walking along the wall to touch Simi.
After Akash broke the glass, he faced Simi and tried to get Simi to go to the police station with him for the last time. Then he was attacked by Simi and almost killed. It is impossible for a person to act when his life is in danger. If Akash can see it, it is impossible for him to almost die.
After Akash helped Simi remove the blindfold, Simi began to use a knife to break the rope that bound his hands. Akash didn't know Simi's movements throughout the process. If he could see Simi, there was no reason to let Simi break free at this time. Restraint and threaten oneself.
When a person is alone, he is the most authentic self. When Akash dropped a coin by himself, it was obvious that he did not receive the coin, and it fell below, indicating that he could not see it. Then he picked it up, and he had to touch it to know which side he had thrown, which also meant that he couldn't see it.
When one person goes to the toilet, he wants to understand the surrounding situation, plan to escape later, and fumble for the window. If he can see, there will be no such fumbling action, but directly open the window.
It won’t fall further. In short, there is no information or hint of Akash's recovery in the lens language, which means Akash did not recover his eyesight before Akash and the doctor took Simi away.
3. Why did Simi go to Akash's house and just blind him instead of killing him?
First of all, the main reason is Sufi’s sudden visit. We don’t know whether Simi was ready to kill Akash when he went to Akash’s house, but Sufi’s sudden visit was destined to be unable to Kill Akash again, otherwise she will be the first suspect . The purpose of the murder was to kill her mouth. For her own safety, killing Akash at this time obviously runs counter to her purpose, so she can only choose to blind Akash temporarily and seal his mouth.
Secondly, I don’t think Simi is a perverted homicide. Only perverted homicides enjoy the feeling of killing. Simi is only to cover up his crimes. As a normal person, if there are other ways, he will not choose to kill. Because this is also the most dangerous way .
In the end, I think it is possible that Simi was not ready to kill Akash. She had to use Akash first. She must know who knows the truth . This is the most important first step. Then decide how to seal it. So at the beginning, Sago was only poisoned in the offering, not poison for killing. Secondly, even if Sophie did not suddenly visit, for Simi, poisoning Akash is not the best choice, because poison killing is difficult to fake a robbery or accidental death, and she has no alibi.
4. Why did Akash fake the scene of Simi's suicide?
The main reason is to block the police's mouth and fake the illusion of Simi's suicide. There is no need to worry about the police conducting a search in the name of Simi's disappearance, and the pressure of kidnapping will be much less.
Secondly, it can split the relationship between Simi and Manohar . Manohar knew that Simi could not commit suicide. He went to Regis but did not find Simi and Akash. The first reaction might be that Simi played him. . At this time, it was reported that Simi committed suicide, and a detective previously revealed that he killed Plummer and robbed 10 million "inside information". There are several possibilities. One is that Simi betrayed him, designed suicide and disappeared. He has money; second, Simi was really kidnapped, and then Simi told the kidnappers the truth; third, Simi was killed by the kidnappers, but the kidnappers had obtained the truth from Simi.
In short, Simi's suicide will make Manohar feel that he has been betrayed by Simi, making him even more convinced that the caller has the evidence in his hands, and he has no excuse to open a case to search for the missing Simi.
The fake sago suicide has another effect, that is, after getting 10 million, returning to kill the sago will no longer arouse suspicion. This also paved the way for the doctor and Akash to abduct the sago directly behind the movie .
5. What is Akash's revenge plan?
I think when Akash wants revenge, he still hopes that justice can be done through justice, that is, keeping evidence, reporting the case, and going through judicial procedures. He has not given up the hope of returning to a normal life. This can be seen from the recording when he cheated Simi and the arrangement of Mori and Saku to record Manohar. His plan was to collect evidence as much as possible; and when he was tied up he sang Plummer’s songs to guide the West. Mi approached him, and finally persuaded Simi to return to the police station together, which also showed that he still hoped to return to the police station to surrender through probation, so that he could return to his normal life.
Based on this, I guess Akash’s plan is like this: Simi’s lover Manohar killed Plummer and robbed him of 10 million, which is in line with Simi’s statement on TV. Then a couple of people kidnapped Simi together and recorded evidence to threaten Simi. They would let her go if they got 10 million, and hand her over to the police if they didn't get 10 million. Call Manohar for 10 million, otherwise report to the police. During the whole process, Akash made the plan, Morrie and Saku were responsible for the implementation, and the doctor provided a shelter (remote clinic) for the kidnapping. If he gets 10 million, he kills Sago and kills his mouth. Mori, Saku and the doctor share the money. The doctor removes Sago’s organs. Akash doesn’t need money, but he can get her cornea. If you can't get 10 million, then hand over Simi and Manohar to the police, and Mori, Saku, and the doctor will separate the lineman fees.
Of course, Akash knew that 10 million didn't exist. This was just a lie made up by Simi, and Akash made a plan to deceive the three of the partners, and it made Simi and Manohar unable to argue. Therefore, according to his plan, he finally mastered the confession of Simi and Manohar. Mori and Saku could not get 10 million, so they handed Simi and Manohar to the police and returned to normal life by themselves.
But from flipping a coin and groping for the toilet window, we can also see that Akash is not sure whether his plan will be implemented smoothly , that is, whether Manohar can be trapped, so he tossed a coin to gamble on his luck, and explored the toilet to prepare for a way out. .
Akash didn't expect Morrie and Saku to tie themselves up, which shows that the two of them didn't completely believe Akash's words, and were afraid that he would run away, so they tied him up. We can see that before Mori and Saku went to find Manohar to meet, they had never left Akash, including stepping on them in advance, but also pulled Akash to go with them. But during the action, it was inconvenient to take Akash, the blind person, so he had to let Akash stay in the clinic and wait, but he couldn't guard Akash, and the two were uneasy, so they tied him up.
6. Why would Akash help Simi remove the blindfold?
Akash helped Simi take off his blindfold after a ideological struggle. First of all, he did not expect that Morrie and Saku would tie himself up. His original plan was that even if he was unsuccessful, he would not be able to trap Manohar, and then send him and Simi to the police station, at least he could take advantage of it. Run away when there is no one.
It can be said that the unexpected situation of being tied up by an "accomplice" really made him a little bit at a loss. He felt that the two were untrustworthy, and they did not know how to treat him when they came back. In addition, when Simi was there to frighten him and pointed out the danger that Manohar would come and kill him if Morrie and Saku failed, he had to consider how to escape the current dangerous situation .
His first success also made Simi realize that she is now a burden to Manohar, because from the outside world, she is already a dead person, and if she is still alive, she will face the media and have a lot of trouble. The big trouble will lead to the risk that the truth of Plummer's murder will be discovered, it is better to let Simi shut up forever.
So the two realized that they were actually facing the same danger and reached a consensus . Simi first offered mutual assistance. She helped Akash free his hands, and Akash helped Simi remove his blindfold.
Akash refused at first, but he has no other way out of the current predicament. So he began to try to guide Simi to help him free his hands, but when guiding, Akash did not speak but sang songs, and it was Plummer’s song, which was also played on TV when he mourned Plummer. songs, he hopes this song will cause the repentance of sago .
After Akash was unlocked, he also tried to escape on his own, but he couldn't see it and the form was urgent. At this time Simi continued to persuade Akash, saying that as long as she helped her remove the blindfold, she didn't need to help her loosen the tie, she could help him show the way. Akash wanted to just take off the blindfold. If it was not loosened, Simi would not be able to escape and would not be threatening , so he helped Simi remove the blindfold.
7. Which plots in the movie actually happened? Which plots are the stories made up by Akash?
I think the big liver-shaped tree that the doctor and Akash drove by at the end of the movie is a very clear dividing point . What happened before the two drove past the big tree was real; but two years later, when they continued to talk, the two stopped by the big tree. What happened afterwards was a story made up by Akash. .
This tree with such a distinctive appearance has obvious differences before and after the demarcation point, which is an obvious hint to the audience from the director , and an obvious demarcation point for the audience. If it was all made up by Akash before, there is no need to continue speaking twice but the scenes are different. One is driving past the tree and driving into the distance, and the other is stopping by the tree.
Another thing is that if only the plot where Sufi appears is true, the other plots are false, which means that the other scenes without Sophie are stories made by Akash, which makes no sense. Because other scenes include the life of the Plummers, the voyeurism of the child, the conversation between Simi and Manohar, the life of the Manohar family, the manohar being trapped in the elevator, and many other plots. It's impossible for Cash to know, and it's impossible to tell Sophie. In other words, if the other plots are all stories made by Akash, then the movie will have to delete a lot of content and go through a lot of changes to be like a version of the story.
What they did before driving past this big tree is real shots. This movie is very rigorous. It doesn’t end like some domestic movies and doesn’t come back. So they say that everything is actually a dream and fantasy. , Are all fake, this is actually very low-level.
8. Is the doctor alive or dead in the end?
Based on my previous analysis, I think the doctor survived, at least until Akash separated from him.
In other words, Akash and the doctor reached a consensus to help him kidnap Simi and remove her organs. They drove through the big tree to Mumbai Airport. After harvesting the liver of sago, they received $1 million. The doctor also gave Akash part of the money. Akash used this part of the money to perform an operation, recovered his light, and went to Europe (it only costs 200,000 rupees, less than 3,000 U.S. dollars to get to the UK).
Let's analyze why it is impossible to kill the doctor on Akash Road. First of all, according to the previous analysis, Akash is still blind and can’t see anything . It is impossible to kill the doctor-drive to the airport-kidnap sago all by himself-remove the liver of sago-get money to cure his eyes and go to Europe the process of.
Let’s take a look at Sheikh’s request to Dr. Swami, that everything is done well, that is, the transplanted liver must be provided before we receive 1 million US dollars. Akash does not possess the skills to remove organs. And if Akash did not have the money to sell sago, it would be impossible for him to earn money to heal his eyes and go to Europe. Should the blind have to raise the huge cost of the operation first?
Akash also knew that he had no other way to return to a normal life, except to follow the instructions of Dr. Swami. He gave Simi hope for the last time and asked her to go to the police station with him. It was Simi who broke his hope. Now Akash, as a blind person , has no choice but to believe in Doctor Swami .
Similarly, Dr. Swami knew that Akash had no other choice, and that such a person was actually the best choice as an accomplice, because there was no need to worry about betrayal. Akash did not pose any threat to Swami. Instead, he was on the same boat as him and shared common interests at this moment.
Some people say why Doctor Swami didn't kill Akash Monopolize? I analyzed the following reasons:
(1) Doctor Swami is not a heinous murderer. Swami does not care about the lives of other people, but he does not cause trouble to himself. For example, if Akash, who was blind before, did not harvest his organs, he would be killed by a train, and if his organs were harvested, he would not be suspected by the police if he was hit by a train. For example, Simi at this time has already The police believe that he committed suicide. This person no longer exists in this world, and her organs will not cause trouble; and if you act on Akash at this time, no matter where you kill Akash, you will Cause trouble for yourself.
(2) Killing was never the purpose of Dr. Swami, he was only engaged in the profession of harvesting and selling human organs. Each of us has our own life and is accustomed to our own life. If a sudden event occurs, such as a murder, it will definitely break our original perception, change our original life, and have to reshape our own perception. Knowing that everyone is unwilling to do this lightly.
(3) Akash saved him from the Simi Knife. Doctor Swami is not a heinous person. Each of us has our own values to gain a foothold and survive in society. Facing life-saving grace is at least You can't kill the benefactor instead. A person who is over half a hundred years old does not have to reshape his three views, but is more inclined to live in his comfort zone.
(4) We can see that when Dr. Swami wanted to remove Akash’s kidney, he needed the help of Mori and Saku. At this time, he kidnapped Sago and removed Sago’s liver. It's hard to do it alone, he can't even beat Simi. In order to reduce the risk and complete the task smoothly, he needs an assistant at this time, and there is no more suitable candidate than Akash.
(5) Repaying Akash only needs to pay 1.2 million rupees to meet his expenses for surgery and going to Europe, and the remuneration he can get is at least 70 million rupees. Anyone knows that 1.2 million is only a trivial fraction of 70 million. It is a bargain to hire an assistant for only 1.2 million rupees, and killing Akash will cause great trouble. Dr. Swami could not delay his purchase of 70 million for Akash's 200,000 kidneys at this time.
In summary, Swami has no motive and unconditional killing of Akash, but has the motive of repaying and needing help to hire Akash. Akash had no other better choice, so the two formed an alliance.
9. Why did Akash pull the can so hard in the end?
From the end of the film, Akash’s beautiful piano sound and affectionate lyrics can be seen. Although it has been two years, Sophie Akash, who gave him the feeling of love and inspired him, is still pregnant. There are very beautiful yearnings and longings. Reunion again, and hope to continue the front line, so he made up a story that is not stained by himself, hoping to get the approval of the goddess. So he offered Sophie an invitation for a concert in the main square.
In his heart, the image of Sufi is a pure and perfect goddess and a symbol of beauty. But later he heard Sophie say: "She killed so many lives, you should listen to Dr. Swami, take off Simi's eyes." He was shocked and astonished. He didn't expect his goddess to say this. He just stupidly wanted to maintain his image in her heart, but she thought he should have taken Simi's eyeballs, which made Akash feel that Sophie had already It's not the Sophie in my heart.
I think Akash opened the jar fiercely, and felt unhappy . The goddess in his heart has changed, so he is unhappy; everything in life has become so realistic, with his own pursuit of art and his own heart. The expectation is different, so I feel uncomfortable.
I think Akash opened the jar fiercely, and there should still be a feeling of letting go of the past , the pain of the past, the sins of the past, the fetters of the past, kick them all away, life can only continue, can only continue to act, I Is the actor of life!
10. The role of the rabbit in the movie?
In the movie, the rabbit is the symbol of the protagonist Akash . The image of the rabbit is very weak. The rabbit faces the hunter, just like the tuner faces the murderer and the police.
This rabbit is a blind rabbit with both eyes blind, symbolizing the blind tuner. And the reason for this rabbit's blindness is different. The left eye may be blinded congenitally, while the right eye has scars, indicating that it may be acquired blindly, implying that the protagonist Akash's eyesight is also twists and turns, not as simple as a born blind person. .
Although the rabbit is weak and small, its two ears are thin and long. It is a very alert animal, which symbolizes Akash's excellent hearing and alertness as a tuner.
The rabbit finally escaped the hunter's pursuit and left unharmed, which also hinted at the end of Akash, and escaped the pursuit of Simi and Manohar.
In summary, the image of the rabbit really fits Akash's experience, so Akash chose a rabbit head cane as his lucky charm after getting out of danger, and made up such a story based on what he had at hand.
-------------------------------------------------- -------------------------------------------------- ------------------------------------
Since the dialogue of this film is mainly in Hindi, most viewers in our country can only understand by subtitles, and the translation of subtitles is not very accurate, so this makes it more difficult to understand some plots in this film. . In this case, we can only understand it by watching it a few more times and making reasonable inferences through the plot of the film before and after it.
-END-
(The film review was first published on the personal public account: Xueye Sunshine)
View more about Andhadhun reviews
