At the end, I really want to know where the teacher took the children.
Unfortunately, the director did not tell us directly.
Then for a shot, Meng Dan looked at the school, smoking a cigarette.
What does that mean? What role does this character have so many laid out? Among the 60 children's group portraits, one who sang the best, one who sang the youngest, and one Mengdan, the three accounted for the most space (other minor figures included the child who injured the doorman and the child who stole money) what was the intention? (Some children are not well educated? The director spends a lot of space, just to make a negative teaching material?)
Looking back at the review of the Mengdan incident:
1. Background: Meng Dan was brought over from the Santa Feia Junior Management Office to do research on his adaptability in a more free environment. The intelligence chart is divided into full, normal, slightly inferior, mildly mentally handicapped, moderately mentally handicapped, deeply mentally handicapped, and idiot. Looking at the picture, Meng Dan is generally above normal (I don’t know if the horizontal axis of this test indicates age, Pi Simon In the test, psychology and French-speaking friends can help to see if Tencent’s translation is accurate here). According to the data on the chart, Meng Dan’s intelligence has been at a higher level than normal. Can read and write.
But as a child with violent tendencies, as an experiment in scientific experiments, to investigate how he fits into the ordinary group or whether he can integrate into the ordinary group. (According to a test, this child tends to be violent, parasitic, destructive, and... lying is sexual, and the characteristic of lying is particularly emphasized)
Analysis: Here we have to distinguish whether it is true or it is said to be so. When Mr. Superintendent first arrived at this school, he said that the children here were also children with various problems. (At the bottom of the pond, the school for re-education of problem teenagers) And very important, with a special emphasis on lying, it can be said that he has been set at the moment the character appears on the scene. (But can lying be done through a certain test? Even now, polygraphs need to be determined based on heartbeat, sweat secretion and other methods, and the accuracy has not been 100% certified so far.)
2. Question: Mengdan's growth
1) The teacher said that if you don't follow the rules (smoking), you will look good; then, he deliberately took a sip and looked at the superintendent provocatively.
2) The teacher asked, can you sing? He said, I will, but you won't like it. . . . Then sang a yellow tune. . . Somewhat proud of "I told you earlier." . . Then the teacher ignored that you still have a good baritone voice. . . Then he approached the teacher with an offended expression on his face. "What's the voice?" (As the child grows up, it can be seen that no one will talk to him well; it is often insulting words more than praise, so when he hears A word that I haven’t heard is, I intuitively treat it as a curse)
3) The fight with Mo Hangzhi-the result was naturally confinement
The teacher said that in the letter to your parents, you can tell them to visit them every month. Here we pay attention to the answers of the three children.
Meng Dan said: My old man, I don't want to see him.
The teacher said that maybe Mo Hangzhi would like to see his mother, and then Meng Dan replied that there might be some problems with the translation here. According to the plot, what Meng Dan said might be "then he is not here alone" (meaning that Said that he was still left here), so Mo Hangzhi would look back and stare at him bitterly.
In the first communication with Mo Hangzhi, Meng Dan showed his favor to the other party in his own way, handing cigarettes, I will protect you; what is the reason? It is because I feel that Mo Hangzhi is of the same kind. There are parents, but the parents don't care about themselves. They leave themselves in places like juvenile control schools and problematic juvenile schools, and then go happily on their own.
From this we can guess, Meng Dan’s life experience is roughly: his father has problems (alcoholism, domestic violence or other, we don’t know, but it must be the father he does not want to see, and the father himself does not care about the child), mother Maybe they are engaged in special occupations (whether to make a living or to be happy for yourself, from Meng Dan’s proficient singing of yellow tunes, we can probably guess one or two, since childhood, watching my mother doing this kind of occupation, learning from the mouth of a prostitute Those minor tunes), Meng Dan, who has grown up slowly, is walking around on the street. The way he knows to make friends is to smoke and drink together. The dialogue he knows is to threaten "Whoever laughs at me will make you look good" (from here It can be guessed in the sentence, in his native circle, other children often laugh at him)
4) Blackmail Pepino, then steal sausages and drink in the cafeteria
In his life, bullying, blackmailing and making money, he survived by this way of survival. Then, in the juvenile control office (or other controlled schools), the superintendent who stunned you on the surface was probably the one he had encountered before, because others treated themselves well and trusted others, but were betrayed. , The boy stabbed the former superintendent in a rage on impulse. Probably this is where his violent tendency assessment came from.
However, when the superintendent here stood up because he bullied Pepino, he was probably shocked. Here, the superintendent is no longer just a teacher. Is there a father who looks like a father, a father who cares about his children, will he with anger, restraint, and keep bad children away from his children, and then he will say In any case, I have to protect him and not allow you to hurt him.
Meng Dan did not refute this time. He was suppressed by the teacher's anger or shocked by the protection like his father.
In the direct eyes, we can no longer see the provocation and hostility at the beginning; while the downward eyes, in the behavioral sciences, this is a manifestation of confession or submission.
3. Outbreak
First, as an introduction, he enters another teacher’s room to steal the watch (steal? Or curious? Just as children enter the teacher’s room, unlock the lock and take away his music score, I wonder if it’s a kind of front and back here. correspond.)
Here, we saw a sentence from the supervising teacher saying "Wait a minute" "Wait for something" "He is my only baritone."
In fact, from here, I guess, Mengdan is in transition. He has become a member of the chorus and is slowly participating in the process of change.
However, once you make a mistake, you will make a mistake for a lifetime. This is how most people think of him. After 15 days of confinement, what is Meng Dan thinking about?
If you want to get better, then you get better? No one believes you anyway. I also want to sing like Mo Hangzhi. What's the use then, you are already a bad guy. In the dark confinement room, two selves are in a tug of war and dispute, which one prevails? Is it disappointment or despair on the back of his face?
Then he took the opportunity to run and ran away. (Actually, Mo Hangzhi also ran out secretly, but the superintendent said that no matter where he went, he came back anyway) What is Meng Dan for? Where did you go? Is it flying to a freer place outside with the singing? (Although the picture below happened after the film, are the changes in the hearts of the children the same?)
In short, it is very unfortunate that 100,000 francs are gone at this time. The principal called the police. The police caught him and sent him back to the school. The principal played for more than half an hour, and started over again and again "Where is the money? Who stole it?" Meng Dan kept saying "I don't know, it's not me." Starting from the beginning for the last time, Meng Dan's body was trembling, his eyes changed, and he stopped answering and stuck the headmaster's neck directly. After the teachers rescued the principal, the principal said, "Call the police, he has already admitted."
The confessed crime is no longer just a problem teenager. From behind, we know that he is going to be sent to prison.
Looking back at this smile at last, what was it? Personally, this smile is a very bright smile in the whole movie of this character. (It can be compared with the smile that started to put the smoke ring on the teacher's face)
Facts have proved that everything is just unnecessarily charged. Mengdan was sent to prison for being accused of stealing. Faced with the facts, what the principal said, even if he did not do this, sooner or later he would commit a crime. (Society probably sees these children in this way, terrible determinism) But this conclusion also overturns all previous descriptions of Mengdan. Is it preconceived that this child has a problem? There is still a real problem. The so-called lying and stealing have become doubtful at this moment.
The most classic French masterpiece, Jean Valjean in Les Misérables, remember that story? An event that changed his life. He stole the candlestick from the church. When the police caught him and took him there, the priest said it was given to him. (Seeing this, this story pops up again, is it very similar? Or is it a similar story)
The smoking school, Meng Dan's back, blew a cigarette. . . . . . Does all this mean that Mengdan burned the school? Is this conclusion the same as the teacher and principal of that school? Because it is a bad boy, so in order to get revenge, burn the school?
Mengdan, who was supposed to be in the police station, was sent to Dimodo (probably the name of the prison) the day after tomorrow. Why did he show up here?
It should have been released.
Where did the superintendent go? Are you really going to hide and seek in the forest? This answer is too absurd, so absurd, it is just a reason to make up casually. What does the teacher say when the principal is not in the children’s class? Say "I have a better idea" (maybe to teach children a more important life lesson, fairness and honesty)
The real reason was probably that the superintendent took the children to the local police station and explained the situation. (Probably with the cash he found) Then under the circumstances of witnesses (children who surrendered) and physical evidence (not Mengdan stole, but the cash from the school), Mengdan was released.
The school fire is probably just a coincidence.
View more about The Chorus reviews
