The Importance of Civil Officials' Absolute Control over the Army from "13 Days"

Antonetta 2021-12-23 08:01:18

It is quite meaningful to watch this film on the occasion of the 50th anniversary of the Cuban Missile Crisis. It should be said that this film exceeded my expectations.

Watching "Obama's Wars" two years ago, I felt the bargaining between the military and the White House for the first time. In a country like the United States that regards the civil control of military as the foundation of the nation, the military dared to be so bold. Watching "13 Days" today, it should be said that we have seen the "tit-for-tat" between the US military and high-level government. The two episodes are the most shocking. One is the Secretary of Defense McNamara's rage against the Secretary of Naval Operations at the Pentagon, and the other is the President's attack on the table with the chairman of the Joint Council. It should be said that when I grew up as a military family, there is no doubt about my feelings for the army, but I did not hesitate to stand on the side of civilian officials.

It is true that from the perspective of human nature, the army, as a national violent machine, can best realize its value in war (of course I am talking about the army as a whole, not the sacrificed and disabled combat troops on the front line), and can gain career A sense of accomplishment. However, the improvement of individual people, or the overall value of the military, is based on the endless suffering of countless families and individuals. Such values ​​are bloody values ​​and cannot be condoned.

In 1986, the US Congress passed a bill to remove the Joint Council from the chain of command, making it a pure staff member of the President and the Secretary of Defense. From the perspective of this film, it is really necessary.

After all, the ultimate value of the existence of armed forces is to prevent the outbreak of war.

View more about Thirteen Days reviews

Extended Reading
  • Margret 2022-03-21 09:02:15

    A good political movie. Between countries, between the various factions of the government, between one's own people. If you say a wrong word, you may fall into a pit, and this pit is likely to be dug by yourself.

  • Jedidiah 2022-04-20 09:01:53

    The right to speak, the United States really holds the right to speak firmly through the export of movies and other cultures. War makes people feel disgusting, politics makes people feel dirty, what is the use of studying state politics? In the end, it is not all middle-aged and elderly men who decide the fate of the whole country and even the whole world by their own status. Turns out Kennedy was a pacifist. After reading it, I feel the importance of communication, how people communicate, figure out, and game when the language fails. And the secret withdrawal of Turkish missiles, who came up with this idea is too strong, it is better than "secret". Jervis' book, Perception and Misperception, was extremely useful in the Cuban crisis.

Thirteen Days quotes

  • [Soviet ships turn away from the U.S. blockade of Cuba]

    Dean Rusk: We were eyeball to eyeball and I think the other fella just blinked.

  • Robert F. Kennedy: We've got a bunch of smart guys. We lock 'em in a room and kick 'em in the ass until they come up with some solutions... I'll do it.