Passion and Desire, Sin and Punishment

Jannie 2022-03-25 09:01:15

The family epic, the cannibalism of brothers, love and lust, crime and punishment, all make this film a clear Dostoevsky brand. More like a collection of Crime and Punishment and Brothers Karamazov.

After Visconti borrowed a family to migrate from southern Italy to the northern city of Milan, the five brothers’ different fate trajectories, on the one hand, showed the loss of nostalgia in the process of urbanization: the eldest took root in the metropolis, and the second lived in the city. Lost and depraved in desire, the third child can never forget his hometown, and he has the noble face and heart of a Christian saint, but in order to protect the second brother, he has become an unprincipled rotten good person. The fourth is relatively rational, and the fifth represents the future. hope…

Because of the appearance of a prostitute, the second child, Simon, and the third child, Rocco, had a big fight. The former even embarked on the road of jealousy and murder. Rocco's tolerance and forbearance failed to prevent the tragedy from happening, but instead resulted in a creepy flower of evil. .

Visconti reluctantly expressed the powerlessness and failure of religious redemption through the mouth of the fourth child, Quito. Sometimes unconditional good only leads to bottomless evil. Is it not Rocco's responsibility for Simon's ultimate destruction?

The prostitute Nadia is the trigger for the collapse of the whole family. On the surface, this is an image similar to the classic femme fatale in American film noir. But her true love for Rocco was unknowingly revealed from her cynical exterior. This makes her like a crucified Jesus when she is finally killed by Simon with open arms.

If it is said that Rocco symbolizes good, Simon represents evil, and Nadia is the embodiment of passion and desire. Simon's evil Rocco could not be saved, and Nadia could not be melted with her all kinds of amorous feelings. Where does this evil come from?

Anyone who has seen the movie knows that Simon is not an inherently bad person. When he first arrived in Milan, he also has the innocence and curiosity of a countryman. Visconti's ambitions have gradually expanded and fallen, and this, Visconti has made it clear from the repeated sighs of his mother and Rocco: it is this bustling city that makes people's hearts gradually lost and distorted... Including the savage boxing ring. It has become the best portrayal of urban life in which the strong eat the weak.

Therefore, Rocco, who is as pure as a saint, misses his hometown very much, which is the last holy land that has not been defiled...

It's a pity that he can't go back. At the end of the film, as a boxing champion who has attracted much attention, he has to fight non-stop on the battlefield. God knows if he will become the next Simon?

We had to pin our hopes on the still young Luca...

View more about Rocco and His Brothers reviews

Extended Reading
  • Zoie 2022-03-22 09:02:28

    The movie played in "The Man from the Windbox". After The Sinking, watch Visconti's second installment. The film is three hours long, the plot is a little procrastinated, and the story is more realistic and ordinary, but the film quality of a single scene is really good.

  • Joanny 2022-03-20 09:02:23

    saint. Like Dostoyevsky's novels, they are heavy and uncomfortable, but they lack some kind of resonance.

Rocco and His Brothers quotes

  • Rosaria Parondi: Ciro, my dear son, tell me: is it my fault these tragedies are happening? I brought my strong, handsome sons here to better themselves and not toil a thankless land like their father who died a thousand times!

    Ciro Parondi: You did well!

    Rosaria Parondi: Your father couldn't bring himself to leave the land. But during the 25 years we spent together I thought of nothing but leaving, leaving, leaving, leaving. I wanted it for Vincenzo, Simone, Rocco and for you. Nothing seemed beautiful there. That world was so small. Here I feel as if I could touch the sky. People on the street called me "Signora", imagine. Me, "Signora", here in this big city. Thanks to my wonderful boys. But now, everything's gone wrong.

  • Ciro Parondi: Brothers or not, we're seeds taken from the same sack meant to bear fruit. A seed gone bad must be weeded out. Just like when we cleaned lentils.