No, I can't do this question! (BGM Snowflakes Fluttering North Wind Xiaoxiao)

Cheyanne 2022-03-26 09:01:14

Indian Xiaotie, last time I was pricked by Uncle Monkey God and I didn't want it. This time, there is another movie with a large-scale thinking space.

Let’s talk about the background first. The two most populous countries in the world bordering developing Asia are like two students in the first grade who are studying and studying. They have different learning styles and different learning environments, but they still encounter the same exam questions. Today, Indian classmates gave their own answers on which starting line the child will win.

What about the problem solving steps?

The contradiction 1 of this question is: First of all, the huge population directly leads to the scarcity of social resources. Public resources such as educational resources and medical resources are always insufficient under people's increasingly broadened vision and needs, even if everyone There are, but there will also be a distribution problem in the distribution process of who eats the meat and who drinks the porridge.

Conflict point 2 is about to emerge. Who will make the distribution rules and put the meat in whose bowl? The Taiping Heavenly Kingdom of Great Harmony in the world has been proved by contradictory evidence by Comrade Xiuquan, who begs you to stop showing off, that our productivity is not enough to support his ideal world, so in India, which has a market economy with socialist characteristics, they still choose to hand over educational resources to In the market, private schools have a greater advantage. That's good. Some people who have more say in the market can use the rules of the market to give themselves the power of preference, which has become a foundation for this movie. background.

But the third point of contradiction comes, we have realized very early that "everything is inferior, only reading is high", I can be the champion in reading, and I can ride a big horse, let my wife who grinds tofu use rouge gouache, let me I have become a grandfather since I was a child. Perhaps from ancient times to the present, the most obvious name of the elevator that shuttles through the pyramid of human stratum is called reading. Those few people have a lot of educational resources, and those who stay at the top will still let their knowledge genes, knowledge genes, Cognitive genes are passed down from generation to generation, and guarding resources is like guarding tools in the era of slash-and-burn farming. This is the nature that our ancestors gave us, and no one is to blame.

Therefore, the problem is not necessarily the ignorant parents in the final auditorium, it is the rules of the game in the old world. Maybe that's what this movie is trying to prove.

What about the proof method?

Path 1: Since human nature cannot be blamed, why should human nature be hurt and distorted?

What impressed me the most in this movie was the kind-hearted big brother of the poor. Here, such a character is described in a pure and kind way. Be willing to believe in others, think about the problem from the perspective of the other party no matter what, see the big brother trying to defend the male lead; see the male lead deducting his salary, and give him his own salary, because he cannot be a father who cannot bring back money; In order that the male protagonist's children can also receive a good education, he would risk his life to touch porcelain. This point is a twisted point that came so suddenly. The twist is that the physiological needs and safety needs of Marlos' needs theory must be at the bottom. , but for the needs of society, regardless of the basics, this is a distortion of human nature. It seems illogical, but there are many in society. This distortion is like a needle, which pierces the heart.

Of course, the poor brother's wife is also a good interpretation of this kind of hurt and distortion. The same poor people, facing a little bit of injustice, we can "come on and hurt each other", but they are just a resource allocator, Injustice to the public, in front of them, we can only bow our heads and bear it silently, and our hearts are still awake. Oh, there are only so many neighbors next door, forget it. The attitude towards unfairness, because of the so-called class, human nature is distorted again.

Path 2: Change the rules of the game, I can let you see better development

This is the last time, a plan by the male protagonist, a speech, and an almost revolutionary activity. The male protagonist shouted, give poor children resources, their performance is not necessarily worse than children in private schools, but why don't you admit it? Why are you silent when you see it? I'm calling you can't you hear me? Hope to win at the starting line is character, not the so-called erudition. Of course, because the parents here admit that under completely fair competition conditions, their children will have a greater competition crisis, they choose to remain silent and choose to cover up, because there is a social curtain to help them cover up this shame.

This is the time to end the film and bring out the proof of the end. There is no ending, there is no ending. In the end, when children grow up, what will they look like? Which rules will they take as the core of their values? This is a question of the times. Only actions and time can give the final ending.

Well, with a Chinese-style problem-solving idea, I have finished this film review. It feels like I am making up the number of words, just for a little favor, but I also feel that I have raised such a question for myself. Finally, let’s return to the essence. It must be a good movie that can give people space to think.

View more about Hindi Medium reviews

Extended Reading

Hindi Medium quotes

  • Raj Batra: My life is Hindi but my wife is English.