Barren as me, great as Anderson.

Kevin 2022-03-27 09:01:22

A few years ago, I watched Roy Anderson's "The Quietness of the Birds", but I didn't understand it. I watched his "Singing from the Second Floor" last year, but I was speechless by those very creative shots. I watched it tonight. His "You Are Alive" is also impressed by the flashing shots.

Never know Sweden, but intuitively think that Roy Anderson is the most creative director in the Swedish film industry, no one. How much talent does it take to make a movie like this? The last time I felt the same way was the Japanese director Shuji Terayama who died young.

Some films are realistic, and the director expresses his expression through a complete concrete story.

Some movies are freehand, but some unrelated screen lines can express the desired expression more profoundly. But such films are often obscure, sometimes only understood by the director himself.

And I think Roy Anderson is somewhere between the two. He is neither realistic nor freehand. He uses a realistic approach to freehand but also uses a freehand approach to be realistic.

Realistic films usually describe specific things, such as sounds and shapes. And Roy Anderson's style is that the silent is better than the sound. He uses the silent to describe the sound and the invisible to describe the form.

In fact, I don't know what I want to talk about, but I'm a little excited after watching this movie. I have to record how I feel at this moment, even if I'm just talking nonsense.

View more about You, the Living reviews

Extended Reading

You, the Living quotes

  • Mia: Serving non-alcoholic beer with food that smells so good. It's torture!

    Uffe's mother.: I only want what's best for you.

    Mia: Best! Is this what's best for me? Enduring this damned existance... with all the shit and deceit and wickedness and staying sober? How can you expect or even want a single poor bugger to put up with it without being drunk? It's inhuman. Only a sadist would demand that.

  • The psychiatrist: Oh dear, oh dear, oh dear.

    [examines the large stack of patient's files]

    The psychiatrist: I am a psychiatrist. I have been for 27 years. I'm completely worn out. Year after year, listening to patients who aren't satisfied with their lives, who want to have fun, who want me to help them with that - it wears you out, I can tell you. My life isn't exactly a lot of fun either. People demand so much. That's the conclusion I've drawn after all these years. They demand to be happy, at the same time as they are egocentric, selfish, and ungenerous. Well, I would like to be honest. I would like to say that they are quite simply mean, most of them. Spending hour after hour in therapy, trying to make a mean person happy... There's no point. You can't do it. I've stopped doing it. These days, I just prescribe pills. The stronger, the better.