The failure of commercial films that are irrational and illogical

Diego 2022-04-12 09:01:10

Personal opinion don't like it, don't spray it

When you think this is a feminist story about the heroine's brave pursuit of her dreams, it's wrong. It will tell you bluntly in the form of subtitles at the end of the film. This is a movie about mother/Motherhood. This seems to be secondary. The film elements (the supporting actress who plays less than the heroine and is narrated in the third person - the heroine's mother) finally succeeded in becoming the theme of the film.

Secondly, pursuing a dream is not an excuse for not taking classes seriously, failing an exam, and skipping school. As a full-time housewife, the heroine's mother has already suffered from illiteracy. At the end of the film, when signing the divorce documents at the airport, the female lawyer had repeatedly reminded that every document must be signed. But apparently for the film she signed only one name and turned away and the educated engineer father couldn't recognize what document she signed and let the illiterate mother make it up. The father who caught up behind couldn't get off the table, so he deliberately set up the airport exit "you can't come back when you go out". Obviously, there is no rule that you can't go back in at the airport, not to mention that you can only get your boarding pass at the airline counter even if you already have it. After entering the waiting hall, I only need to go through the border check again, so my father can continue to catch up. This makes me wonder if the director and screenwriter have really been to the airport.

So let's say the heroine gets good grades, her guitar strings won't be destroyed, the computer won't be smashed, she can use her spare time to rationally pursue her dreams and get everyone's support, but the dream instead becomes an excuse to become a dream and academically There is a conflicting relationship. This is a wrong value. As long as you have a dream, you don’t need to study. It doesn’t matter. smashing the computer while the relatively uneducated mother of the heroine clearly recognizes its value

The heroine's mother is illiterate and has no job or any income. She also needs to steal small items from her father's wallet. She disappeared after pregnancy and brought her daughter back. In terms of patriarchal India like disappearing against her husband's will and returning with her daughter as if nothing had happened, isn't the husband not curious at all?

Not to mention that the music producer, who was set as a rogue, bought a plane ticket for the heroine without any credentials. After listening to the heroine's words, he changed his mind and denied himself, admitting that all his remix music was forced to be produced. A character who doesn't respect women is like a completely different person. The unruly character has no bottom line and agrees to the heroine. He makes two calls in a low voice and pleads with his ex-wife's lawyer for an interview. exist

The Glamour Award ceremony at the end of the film is even more absurd and bizarre. The actress relies on the online popularity of two videos in a short period of time (the data cannot be used as a reference) and a song published on the soundtrack of the movie to make the best female singer winner be denied on stage. It's impractical to have one's own career (one's own singing voice is weak) and handing over awards is impractical. Every award has a jury committee. Everyone should be judged by the popularity of the song, the completion of the work, the singer's popularity, album sales, etc. Whether you are eligible to win an award If an award can be freely given to others, then the award itself lacks objective credibility and has no value at all

The heroine pursues her dream, but all her efforts for her dream are to record a video of herself singing and post it on a video site. In fact, dreams are not so casually realized. Basically, all online videos require behind-the-scenes operations such as capital. Under the operation of multi-platform push, I would like to ask which Internet celebrity does not have its own team behind it. It is very rare that the heroine once gave up her dream for the sake of her mother. All success is done by others. She accomplished soaring online views, met a singer-producer producer looking for new blood, and stepped in to house chores and dealt with the heroine's family problems. The smooth sailing caused her to have to dream come true. too far fetched

Personally, I think that dreams can come true in thousands of different forms. Political correctness is also important, but it should not be used to deceive the audience with illogical and false content that is divorced from reality. In the name of dreaming of motherhood and feminism, it can be said to be very eye-catching and box office. low level

View more about Secret Superstar reviews

Extended Reading

Secret Superstar quotes

  • Najma: Did the chicken come first or the egg?

    Insia: It depends on the situation... If you want to eat chicken, the egg comes first - it hatches into a chicken, which you cook. But, if you want to eat an omelette, the chicken comes first - it lays the egg, which you make into an omelette.