First time writing a long film review "The Name of the Rose"

Ethyl 2022-03-25 09:01:09

It was first written in the public account
that the crusades took place in the twelfth century, and Syria was conquered for the first time. After the crusades, it was surprisingly discovered that medieval Europe had destroyed all the civilizations of Greece and Rome. Therefore, at that time it was discovered that the most important achievement of Greek civilization was philosophical thought. The most valuable part of philosophical thought is the thought of Aristotle. The vast majority of Aristotle's thought is based on experience from observing everyday life. So, otherwise, it was destroyed, and no Latin version was left, and for this reason, in Syria, Constantinople, Sicily, and in Spain, these areas where Christians and Muslims came into contact. There was a massive movement to translate Aristotelian philosophy back to Europe. There is a part of it, when it was passed from Sicily back to the island of Italy. The name Rose plays is an example of this.
In the movie, why would the church object to Aristotle's comedy? His logic goes like this: The church only asks for one thing, to make people believe in God. And what the Bible says, God loves us. Believe in the Son and the Holy Spirit. And in the process of believing, people can't not be afraid. Because people are not afraid, they will not believe.
Like this, if there is nothing to be afraid of, you will not believe it. The problem of poverty is a very serious problem, and in this difficult environment, we are very afraid of the future. Everyone will be very resigned, and after resignation, they will catch the first piece of belief, belief, principle, and dogma.
If you read comedy, you find it funny, and if you laugh, it means you're not afraid. If you are not afraid, it is not easy to be educated. (Of course the logic here is not necessarily correct) If you don't teach it, don't believe it. If you don't believe it, those priests are finished.
The implication is that these priests also know that no one believes these things, so they use a horrible way. Then, the church talked about something. Driven by this curiosity, everyone talked during the day that we must believe in the existence of God. I was reading Aristotle's comedy at night, and I laughed and laughed. I was so happy.
That monastery in the mountains of northern Italy, the abbot, excavated it was so funny. He made a crazy move. Well, he painted the corners of Aristotle's comedies with poison, because at that time, reading was done with the mouth. Then plastered with poison. The person who reads that book, when turning the page, poisons him to death, the more they turn, the faster they die. Then, making sure he didn't make a mistake, he gouged out his eyes.
The story is wonderful here. Aristotle's charm makes those who want to fight against God find that they can't do it, so they have to goug out their eyes. So in a very strange way, the Franciscan church sent another monk named William to investigate the incident of this series of deaths. So it includes that in the process of seeking knowledge, under the curiosity of each person, the more you do not let him read, the more he wants to read.
What is very important or great about Christian philosophy is that their religious teachings are very simple in content: believe in God and gain eternal life. However, they took over all the development and content of Greek philosophy. The first to undertake Neoplatonism, and later, in the thirteenth century, Thomas took over Aristotle's system, once Aristotle took over. Aristotle was very great, Aristotle was a great observer, through the way of observation, biology is still believed to this day.
Rediscovering Aristotle, Aristotle's main reason comes from translation, and today's religious issues, Syria is very troubled. No Arabic is now nor Aristotle readable, at least not complete. Because Aristotle was lost in the process of development and was completely preserved in Arabic. Like Ptolemy's astronomy's Almagest, AL is the Arabic article. Muslims have preserved the Greek classics, especially Aristotle. Plato's works do not have much problem of being lost, because we can understand that Platonism is completely a copy of Christian philosophy. But Aristotle is very different. Aristotle's critique of Plato is that the world of rational forms exists independently. The existence of all objects must be the combination of rational form and material. How can there be a rational world. How can the soul be immortal. The way the soul exists is only by the ability of human thinking. Therefore, since Greek thought is based on reason and Christian belief is based on faith, conflicts are inevitable. The bishop of Paris once banned the reading of Aristotle's works of natural philosophy, including physics, physiology, metaphysics, and excommunication. What is interesting? Although the Church explicitly forbade the reading of Aristotle's philosophy, it did not oppose Aristotle's philosophy. So this understanding of it becomes an antecedent means. Until 1255, Aristotle's philosophy could be taught publicly.
It was originally written in the public account Menghualu

View more about The Name of the Rose reviews

Extended Reading

The Name of the Rose quotes

  • William of Baskerville: I too was an Inquisitor, but in the early days, when the Inquisition strove to guide, not to punish. And once I had to preside at a trial of a man whose only crime was to have translated a Greek book that conflicted with the Holy Scriptures. Bernardo Gui wanted him condemned as a heretic; I - acquitted the man. Then Bernardo Gui accused *me* of heresy, for having defended him. I appealed to the Pope. I - I was put in prison, tortured, and... and I recanted.

    Adso of Melk: What happened then?

    William of Baskerville: The man was burned at the stake and I am still alive.

  • William of Baskerville: The only evidence I see of the antichrist here is everyones desire to see him at work.