Who is the movie talking for - "Doctor Zhivago" and "Gone with the Wind"

Verna 2022-03-27 09:01:09

2015.10.20 "Doctor Zhivago" reminds me of a favorite movie "Gone with the Wind", both of which are more than 3 hours long, both are adapted from novels, both show the cruelty of war, and the author They all hold an attitude of sympathy for conservative forces, and the films have won many Oscars, while the original won the Nobel Prize for Literature, and the latter won the Pulitzer Prize.

In "Gone with the Wind", the southern manor owner and the slaves get along harmoniously, and the master and servant are deeply in love. Before the Civil War, the owners of the manor lived a happy life with parties and dances all day long, and only for the sake of love. After returning home in distress and embarrassment, the young ladies who were originally well-dressed and spoiled, had to do farm work and live a tight life. In "Doctor Zhivago", before the civil war (as the characters in the play call the October Revolution), the aristocratic families were warm and happy, lived a prosperous and happy life; , but even the common people did not live much better, and it felt that the whole society was destroyed by the revolution. However, "Doctor Zhivago" does not show the aristocrats' discomfort with the plummeting life, but shows that they have created a new life positively, optimistically and calmly with the virtues of nobility, perseverance and tolerance. On the contrary, the image of the Red Army and the revolutionaries is really bad, cruel, indifferent, impersonal and unreasonable. This reminds me of "Forrest Gump", which reflects the mainstream values ​​of the United States (right and conservative), which portrays left-wing youth as the image of drug addiction, alcoholism, promiscuity, beating women and even wearing Nazi military uniforms, which is a bit too much. . Looking at "Doctor Zhivago" again in 1965, I suddenly realized that during the Cold War, the United States had a very bad impression of the Soviet Red Army.

When I watched "Gone with the Wind", I was still young and didn't think much about it, and my emotions were only tied to the protagonist; but now when I watch "Doctor Zhivago", the logic is a bit ridiculous. It deserves people's sympathy and grievances, so do the revolutionary people want to overthrow the old ruling class because they once lived well? Should they bear the burden of humiliation, be content with poverty, and think that it is natural for the nobles to lead a feasting life, and they should not think about it at all, let alone want to change? The aristocrats in distress are indeed pitiful, but it is even more pitiful that countless commoners have been in distress.

View more about Doctor Zhivago reviews

Extended Reading
  • Alaina 2022-03-28 09:01:04

    One of David Lean's epic trilogy, this time from the vast Arabian desert to the frozen Russian tundra thousands of miles, the snow scene has also become one of the biggest highlights, especially the eye-catching snow sculptures in the abandoned manor. Omar Sharif's tearful eyes and Julie Christie's performances were brilliant. With the sobbing accompaniment of the shamisen, this love story devastated by revolution and political struggle is extremely touching. (8.5/10)

  • Toy 2022-01-03 08:01:22

    When the military struggle is over, the political struggle is about to begin.

Doctor Zhivago quotes

  • Anna: But, Boris, this is genius.

    Medical Professor: Really? I thought it was Rachmaninoff. I'm going for a smoke.

  • Komarovski: [to Lara] And don't delude yourself that this was rape! That would flatter us both!