Goodbye Christopher Robin: Behind the fairy tale is cruelty

Watson 2022-03-26 09:01:13

Emotions are too restrained so that the actors are always acting, and there is always a sense of drama and jerky; childhood Moon is good, but it lacks the simplicity and agility, adult Moon is too flat and sorry for Lowther's talking eyes; set, lighting, Photography is beautiful, but only superficial. Behind the fairy tale is cruelty, and behind the warmth is alienation. Milne healed the world with Winnie the Pooh, but also destroyed Billy Moon's childhood with his own hands, just as Gandhi brought peace to the whole country but destroyed his own family. So what is true virtue? Is it to save countless unfamiliar lives, or just to warm the people around you?

View more about Goodbye Christopher Robin reviews

Extended Reading

Goodbye Christopher Robin quotes

  • Daphne Milne: You know what writing a book against war is like? It's like writing a book against Wednesdays. Wednesdays... are a fact of life, and if you don't like them, you could just stay in bed, but you can't stop them because Wednesdays are coming and if today isn't actually a Wednesday it soon will be.

  • Christopher Robin Aged 18: There it all is. Just as I left it. As if nothing had happened.

    Alan Milne: When I came back, everything seemed wrong. I didn't fit anywhere. Until I came here. Those days with you... I wanted to keep them all. Put them in a box.

    Christopher Robin Aged 18: The things that I said before I left...

    Alan Milne: They were all true. You're here. That's all that matters.

    Christopher Robin Aged 18: In the desert, we were under fire... and one of the men started singing one of the hums of Pooh. He changed the words a bit, but...

    Alan Milne: [low chuckle]

    Christopher Robin Aged 18: You know. And I thought, "How on earth do you know that song?" And then I remembered...

    Alan MilneChristopher Robin Aged 18: Everyone on earth knows that song.

    Christopher Robin Aged 18: But I knew it first. It was mine before it was anyone else's.

    Alan Milne: Then I gave it away.

    Christopher Robin Aged 18: When they were singing, they were remembering. It was like a magic charm... it took them home to a fireside and a storybook. You did that.

    Alan Milne: [inhales] Thank you. I'm sorry you paid the price for it. If I'd known, perhaps I...

    Christopher Robin Aged 18: What? Not written it? No. You reminded people what happiness was... what childhood could be when everything else was broken.

    Alan Milne: But your own childhood.

    Christopher Robin Aged 18: Was wonderful. It was growing up that was hard.

    Alan Milne: [smacks lips] Who would have guessed that bear would swallow us up?

    Christopher Robin Aged 18: Exactly. This was all ours, wasn't it? Before it was anyone else's.

    Alan Milne: Yes. And it always will be.