people are born unequal

Garnett 2022-04-01 09:01:18

Quite a sensational movie.

I just happened to be reading Hemingway's novel A Farewell to Arms. Compared with the soldiers in the deserted wasteland of World War I in the novel, the treatment behind Chance is too grand. But the fact is that no matter how many medal ribbons are used, no matter how the national flag is wrapped, no matter how high-level the ceremony is, it cannot change the fact that parents lose their children forever. I don't like this movie because I think it's glorified for government propaganda. It does not touch on another important question: those who are the masters of the people, when you decide on a war, do you think about the suffering of thousands of families in the future? Humanity has gone through too many wars, from World War I more than 100 years ago, World War II to the Iran-Iraq war in recent years, etc. These wars have never brought any good news to mankind, but have left a lot of holes. The world is for future generations to repair. The United States, the most civilized country, has always advocated that all people are created equal. If Chance's life is precious, what about other people whose lives have been taken by the United States? Why does the news report how many Americans died for the country, but never hear how many civilians the United States killed by mistake? This movie, in the final analysis, is to whitewash its own values. Politics is all about desires, but unfortunately people don't know what to do, and they happily go to the slaughterhouse wearing garlands.

View more about Taking Chance reviews

Extended Reading

Taking Chance quotes

  • 1st Lt. Dan Robertson (Chance Phelp's platoon commander): [voiceover, from his 09 April 2004 letter to the Phelps family] It's ironic, but I am certain that if the world had more men like Chance Phelps, there wouldn't be a need for a Marine Corps.

  • LtCol Mike Strobl: [voiceover] Chance Phelps was wearing his St. Christopher medal when he was killed on Good Friday. Eight days later, I handed the medallion to his mother. I watched them carry him the final fifteen yards. I felt that as long as he was still moving, he was somehow still alive. When they put him down in his grave, he'd stopped moving. I didn't know Chance Phelps before he died. But today, I miss him.