Since the book has only been published in the fifth volume, it is meaningless to compare the plot in the book with that in the play. But being divorced from the original does not mean that it can be played indiscriminately away from reality, completely ignoring logic.
Here are a few things that are unacceptable:
1: Oberyn's mistress killed Prince Doran, his son Tristan, on the grounds that the prince was not too keen on revenge, but persuaded her to endure. I think Oberon will probably regret that he didn't strangle his mistress and illegitimate daughter when he found out about this. What is the difference between their behavior and the magic mountain? Although the mistress and the sand snake are loved by the prince and Oberyn, their identity cannot be put on the table, let alone become the queen of Dorne, she only deserves the title of a bitch of Dorne. A retainer of the Martell family, the lords in Dorne have not been kind enough to drag her to pieces, so how could it be possible for her to take the power alone? Even in the play, Prince Doran is a man who bears humiliation and strategizes secretly. Such a death is too sorry for him. And Roose Bolton, the skinning owner, was too sloppy.
2: Dorne and Highgarden are inexplicably destroyed, and Lannister is unrealistically strong. In the Battle of the Five Kings, Dorne did not cost a single soldier, and his strength remained intact. Gao Ting's actual financial resources, material resources, and manpower surpass Lannister's. In Lannister and Pisces, after Stannis's fight, the two are even more incomparable. At the end of the sixth season, Cersei bombed the church, many of whom died innocently, Tommen committed suicide, and Kevan didn't know if it was affected, but it was definitely incompatible with her. This shows her crazy side, and Jaime's look at the end actually suggests that Cersei's throne is on the loose. When Lannister is in trouble at home and abroad, no one will ally with the losing side. So Euron and Tully and Cersei allied together, it really doesn't make sense. As for the Lannisters dispatching elite troops to attack the High Court later, not to mention that the Rose family has the right time and place, and the side besieging the city has to prepare ten times as many troops as the enemy. However, just because the people of the Tyrell family fought softly, the siege was simple and did not hurt the bones. Jaime's abandonment of Casterly Rock's strategy, even a military layman would understand, was ridiculous.
3: Several boss-level characters become irrelevant characters. After Tyrion killed his father, he didn't have much to do. The most impressive thing was drinking, chatting and telling jokes. Some people said that it was to draw out Missandei's words, but has it worked so far? If Missandei was a spy, Tyrion had no intention of guarding against her. The newly proposed two-way strategy is something that any mediocre general can imagine. Littlefinger wanted to catch Sansa and then seize the North, but was led by a Sansa who had just debuted, and became a person who only smiled slyly and followed Sansa all day in Winterfell, but was also killed by Jon. Hang up and threaten. When Ned grabbed the collar before, he had no power or power and could only endure it. He is now the owner of the Eagle's Nest City. If he is serious about turning his face with the North, the North will really die, but he still chooses to stay here with a hot face and a cold butt. There is also Xiongmei. It is estimated that it was popular last season. Now that there are more lines, the waist is hard. In my opinion, it is also very unreasonable, as if she is the number one general under Jon's command, and she can scold other lords at will, which is invincible. I don't even think about how many pounds I have. Robb didn't dare to do this when facing all the lords. Everyone in the conference hall is a big-name lord of Bichon-Mei, how could he be taught a lesson by a child? Her only credit is that she sent eighty soldiers to support Jon in the Battle of the Bastards. As for Varys' best intelligence ability, it was also invisible. After three episodes of Long Ma's army, the two major allies were removed, and the big reason was intelligence.
4: It is said that Jon is going to have sex with Long Ma. Jon, do you still remember Ygritte by the Great Ice Lake? Where is Jon who said to the girl in red, "I only love her"? Don't say that the two cherish each other and like each other. Compared with his first love, this relationship is like venting desire on a whim and forcing a pair together. The previous emotional scenes were touching. Even Littlefinger said: They took away the people we cherished (referring to Kate), and now they have to pay the price (forgot the specific, probably means this), I can see him Very fond of Kate. Ser Jorah is the only one who is struggling now. I was very moved to see the letter he wrote. If he died like this, it would be a very tragic ending, just like the saying in Rashomon: Only a heroic departure can It is more accurate to describe him as a famous person. However, in the next second, Sam came to a skin peeling therapy to disgust people, and the first episode specially put an anatomical fat man to disgust the audience, even adults would feel uncomfortable watching it. The previous scenes with heavy taste and blood have ended, but these two scenes of Xuecheng have already made such uncomfortable scenes as a selling point.
In addition, let me say one more thing, some of the remarks of the Game of Thrones fans are even more ridiculous. As long as someone mentions the bad things about this drama, they will belittle others for watching the devil, like Wu Yifan and Luhan, so I don't have enough brains to understand this drama with a quick turn of the plot (Bah, it's called a drama, many historical dramas in China are better than many historical dramas) It is so much more amazing, what qualifications do people who recognize it as a divine drama have such self-confidence that their IQ is superior to others, and they can’t even see such serious bugs, or they choose to turn a blind eye and argue with you with some unconvincing fallacy). It is also said that if it is not a paying user, why do you say this and that. Are only those who have paid the right to express their opinions? There is a problem with the plot, can't you say something that can't be explained? Keep saying that others do not pay, do you have to pay? Have to buy Blu-ray, peripheral products? Some fans like a certain character and even protect him like a bodyguard. They say what happened to Tyrion. He used to have the means and ability in King's Landing, and the actor also won everyone's love. point out? To always maintain his image of wisdom? Some people will even say that this has nothing to do with you at all, and indeed it has nothing to do with you, but what's the point of saying this? At that time, the detective Sherlock was also like this. The first and second seasons were well-produced and it was a good drama. In the third season, there was nothing but selling corruption. Where did the careful reasoning of the detective drama go. As soon as you bring this up, those CP fans will say that you are a troll, want to grab attention, don't want to look at it.
Having said so much, what I am really disappointed about is not that the show is going unfinished, nor that many people worship it blindly, but that too many people call those who don't like this show to be stupid and mentally retarded, and think of themselves as lofty. Turning a blind eye to many serious wrong choices, the focus is on making up cp, the big scene. As if Jon and Daenerys would get himself an orgasm by sleeping together, Drogon comes in a small fire of rage, and the ice dragon can completely cover up these flaws as soon as they appear.
—————————————————————
Now that the sixth episode has been updated, I think if you think about it when you watch the drama, you will know that no matter how far-fetched the explanation is, the unreasonable parts cannot be explained.
What has the little devil done recently? First of all, I advised Long Ma not to ride the dragon and the army to attack King's Landing, on the grounds that it would cause a large number of civilian casualties. What the hell is this? If Long Ma rides a dragon to attack the Red Castle in the middle of the night, at most, the nobles in the castle and Cersei will be burned to death, and the people in the city will have nothing at all. Even without the use of dragons, would pushing down the walls of King's Landing with the Unsullied cause massive civilian casualties? Not necessarily, the Unsullied will not hurt civilians, burn, kill and loot after entering. This is certain. So he said that he hoped that Daenerys would not be as cruel as Cersei, which is really weak. As a result, the war could not see the possibility of an end, and there was no hope for the united front to attack the White Walkers, during which Daenerys's two allies were destroyed.
Let Daenerys split up to fight Casterly Rock instead of focusing on King's Landing. As a result, the Unsullied army was surrounded by Euron's fleet at Casterly Rock. His reasoning was that Casterly Rock was a Lannister citadel, and capturing it would not only cut off support but also deter the enemy. It seems reasonable, but the primary and secondary order is wrong. The attack on Casterly Rock should be placed after the capture of King's Landing. The Lannister remnant really has nowhere to escape and it is difficult to turn over. It's hard for Tyrion to do so without doubting his eagerness to take possession of Casterly Rock. After all, if Long Ma took Casterly Rock City, Tyrion could not give it if he asked for it.
Episode 5 insists that Daenerys not take King's Landing, instead suggesting working with Cersei. He even put forward a suggestion that makes people laugh out loud, but everyone thinks it is very useful: catch a ghoul and come back to Cersei to see, so that she will believe that the disaster is on the line and must unite against the enemy. First of all, let's talk about what will happen to fighting the White Walkers with Cersei. Cersei saves his strength and hides, and Long Ma leads the main force to fight the White Walkers. After the war, what is the reference to the National Government. And Tyrion knows his sister so well, he must know this is the result. And then catching a ghost to show Cersei, well, I don't think it's much different than catching a lunatic to show Cersei. And Cersei has seen a lot of black magic things in Cobain, I am afraid she is not new to seeing ghouls. Next to her is a corpse transformed into a soldier. As for the consequences of catching a ghost, if Daenerys hadn't rescued him, the team would have been wiped out, and Jon was one of them. As soon as Jon died, the North was going to be in chaos again, and Long Ma's last ally was gone. Now Daenerys goes to the rescue, losing a dragon. The Night King got one, and the dragon on Daenerys' side will definitely not be able to retreat in the future.
So when I see this, I wonder if Tyrion is stupid enough to have no medicine, or if he has bigger ambitions. Continue to weaken Daenerys, create chaos, and balance the two forces. Spoilers for Season 8 recently leaked, ending with Tyrion helping young Lyanna (the daughter of Jon and Daenerys) to run the government. Although I can't believe it, it deepens my doubts about him.
View more about Dragonstone reviews
