old fashioned but clever romance

Heath 2022-03-29 09:01:02

Young Alice Lacey left her mother and sister Rose because of the lack of job prospects in her hometown. Although they were reluctant to bear Alice, they still supported her decision. Alice's landlady, Mrs. Keogh, is a picky woman. Through the local priest who helped her settle down, Father Fleur, Alice got a job as a salesperson in a store. It was a tough start, but Alice worked hard and slowly impressed her supervisor, Ms. Fortini. Alice also went to night school and learned bookkeeping at a local university. She was learning quickly and hoped to become an accountant one day. At a community dance, Alice meets Tony Fiorello, a boy of Italian descent who works as a plumber, and their relationship is both gentle and educated. But battered by family tragedy, Alice returns to Ireland for a brief sabbatical. When Alice extends her vacation to attend a friend's wedding, Alice's mother begins to find ways to keep her daughter permanently. She offers Alice some job opportunities, while trying to match Alice with a kind local boy, Jim Farrell. The road of life is torn into two directions, one is her hometown of the motherland, and the other is her new life. At the same time, with her love for Tony and her affection for Jim on the other, Alice must recognize her own heart and make the best choice.

The film is an old-fashioned romance, cleverly placed within the framework of an immigrant story, not chasing trends. On the contrary, it infuses a painful sincerity and a timeless eternity. In a certain sense, director John Crowley's film instead chose to adapt it based on a best-selling novel with great characteristics of the times. While targeting adult audiences, it shows a soft and restless youthful love.

View more about Brooklyn reviews

Extended Reading
  • Moshe 2021-12-01 08:01:26

    If it were before, I would probably not understand this movie. But after I watched a documentary about Irish immigrants, walked through the streets of Brooklyn, and watched this movie today after three and a half years in a foreign country, I seem to understand everything. In many cases, major decisions seem to be rushed, but they are only timing and fate. Even if you want to leave your hometown, leave your parents behind, and abandon your comfort, some decisions are made and you have to make them. There is no way out, let alone regret.

  • Alexandrine 2022-03-20 09:01:42

    Watching it for screenwriter Nick Hornby/Colm Tobin. Really disappointed, the plot aspect is like a student study: just because an old woman came to the conclusion "I almost forgot what this place looks like"? The way of echoing from beginning to end is also cliché. And finally, there was a bit of a dramatic conflict. I was about to see the inner struggle of the heroine, but the movie ended in a hurry...

Brooklyn quotes

  • Mrs. Keogh: I'll tell you this much: I am going to ask Father Flood to preach a sermon on the dangers of giddiness. I now see that giddiness is the eighth deadly sin. A giddy girl is every bit as evil as a slothful man, and the noise she makes is a lot worse. Now, enough.

  • Frankie Fiorello: So, first of all, I should say that we don't like Irish people.

    [General cries of outrage around the table]

    Frankie Fiorello: We don't! That is a well known fact! A big gang of Irish beat Maurizio up and he had to have stitches. And because the cops round here are Irish, nobody did anything about it.

    Maurizio: There are probably two sides to it. I might have said something I shouldn't, I can't remember now. Anyway, they probably weren't all Irish.

    Frankie Fiorello: They just had red hair and big legs.