Who is responsible for the dead prisoners of war?

Providenci 2022-03-30 09:01:07

The film adopts a cool tone and tells the story between a group of bomb disposal teenagers and the Master Chief with great restraint. As teenagers die one by one in the minefield, an air of despair hangs over the tiny beach and continues to torment the conscientious Master Chief. Can't help but think, why does such a human tragedy happen? Are the prisoners at fault? I think most of them did, for whatever reason, they did go to the battlefield, slaughtering their enemies, being the invaders to the Allies, the direct enforcers of their homeland. Therefore, the Allies can justifiably project the grief and hatred of the country's ruin on them, and let them do the most dangerous and hard work, and even expect their death. Therefore, prisoners of war camps are often starved and wounded. In prisoners of war, what you see is not the peace after the war, but the continuation of hatred and the distorted human nature because of natural revenge.

Based on emotion, it is understandable that the Allies' anger and revenge towards POWs is understandable, but is this really right, or is it worth advocating? If a father kills the gangster who killed his daughter, no one will understand that he is not sympathetic to the father, but there is no law, an axiom, that allows the father to not bear the responsibility of going to jail.

During the war, countless soldiers and civilians died. We are responsible for war criminals and prisoners of war. Is there anyone responsible for the death of prisoners of war? Especially the juvenile prisoners of war like the one in the film, who have never been on the battlefield or hurt a single life in their entire lives, just because the Germans have to suffer the humiliation, hostility and hatred of the Allied forces, and even sacrifice their lives for it. Do they really have to bear the pain caused by the war?

To be honest, I don’t know how to answer the question raised by the title. I also know that the prisoners of war in World War II had a miserable life, and their own country did not dare to protest. Retaliation and use of prisoners of war have become the tacit rules of the anti-fascist alliance. Xuan's secret, but I still think that people should not allow hatred for granted.

View more about Land of Mine reviews

Extended Reading
  • Godfrey 2022-03-20 09:02:21

    This kind of movie where a little boy and a dog are blown up one by one, my heart can't bear it?

  • Renee 2022-03-20 09:02:21

    CCTV6 National Edition, adapted from real life. A unique anti-war masterpiece with a unique perspective. After reading it, he was speechless. The "Let's Release" at the end is a stroke of God. Human nature should first be the fear of life. "After the war, more than 2,000 German prisoners of war cleared more than 1.5 million mines on the west coast of Denmark. Half of them died from mines, and most of these prisoners were teenagers." This is the shocking line at the end. An unconventional interpretation. What is commendable is that the film did not stop at the anti-fascist routine with the theme first, but went deeper and farther into the inner world of every German prisoner of war, every demining boy is Three-dimensional and lively independent individuals, like all teenagers, they have love, hatred, helplessness, and various dreams... They do not rigidly stay in the moral judgment of black and white, but from the encounters of a group of young people. (Deeply in desperate situation and forced to atonement) to explore the nature and cruelty of war. In a sense, war does not matter whether it wins or loses. There are only the pale lives that are crushed, trampled, and fooled, just like those young souls who are permanently fixed on the beach and die with the wind.

Land of Mine quotes

  • Lt. Ebbe Jensen: If they are old enough to go to war, they are old enough to clean up.

  • closing title card: After the war, more than 2000 German prisoners were forced to remove over 1.5 million landmines from Denmark's west coast.

    closing title card: Nearly half of them were killed or severely wounded.

    closing title card: Many were barely more than children.