an incompetent philosopher

Jessyca 2022-09-13 19:34:39

This is a very charming professor of philosophy, but the content cannot stand up to scrutiny. He is complex, sensitive, romantic, charming, not even a coward in the general sense. Convinced and willing to give his life to prove it: he pulled the trigger with a loaded revolver pointed at his head and told his students that this was existentialism at its best. He has his own ideas, not to plagiarize everywhere for the sake of acting in a play. It's fair to say that he put a lot of effort into the drama and has the mental capacity to understand his own actions, so in a sense it almost exonerates him of hypocrisy - you could say he's just fallen, not I don't know what I'm doing. After all, in the eyes of many people, depravity is better than hypocrisy.

But he is the most hypocritical, and his depravity stems from a sincere dedication to a hypocritical life. So he brought many calamities to himself, and many pains gathered in him. He indulged in it, pain became a tool for showing off, and depravity became a means of hypocrisy.

Everything about him is a show. It would be superficial to separate his slump before he got the idea of ​​killing him from the excitement after he had it. The second murder was a necessary product of murder, but murder was a necessary product of all his previous immersion. It's an inseparable, coherent narrative. This important coherence is what Woody Allen has deliberately portrayed—this is not a film about depravity, this is a film about hypocrisy. Without the first half, there would be no hypocrisy in the true sense - the fear of admitting that murder is not hypocrisy, claiming to have lost the enthusiasm for life and even willing to commit suicide in a high profile in front of others, but unwilling to face the tragic ending alone in the contempt of former admirers, It is profound hypocrisy. Taking loneliness as a motto, but not being able to accept abandonment, is the real hypocrisy, the dark side that Woody Allen wants to dig out of everyone's life.

To pierce his hypocrisy must start with his smug philosophy of life - he builds a philosophical wall for himself that seems to fit perfectly, but in the end the wall is too low and his level is too stinky. Life is as charming as his whitewashed talent, but it doesn't stand up to scrutiny. It is not like a tree with deep roots, which leaves countless people in the sun, but it is like a dandelion. The beautiful moment needs the proof of others. After the flying catkins are scattered, nothing can be left. Although he seems to have a rich heart, he is the life clown who can't be alone and can't escape the attention of others. Others are his oxygen, and others are his hell.

His philosophy is weak, unable to break free from the fall to hell with the knowledge of a wise man, that is to say, he who flaunts loneliness and wisdom, fears not only true loneliness, but also true wisdom. Emma Stone said to him at the end, I don't have enough intelligence to refute your ghost theory, ironically he himself, without enough intelligence to maintain the face of a wise man, push himself into the abyss of others. If he really had some wisdom, he probably knew his fears in his heart - this deep hypocrisy, probably connected with his deep inferiority complex - this is the only reason we can pity him, because who of us doesn't Fear of being abandoned and ridiculed?

View more about Irrational Man reviews

Extended Reading

Irrational Man quotes

  • [first lines]

    Abe: [narrating] Kant said human reason is troubled by questions that it cannot dismiss, but also cannot answer. Okay, so, what are we talking about here? Morality? Choice? The randomness of life? Aesthetics? Murder?

    Jill: I think Abe was crazy from the beginning. Was it from stress? Was it anger? Was he disgusted by what he saw as life's never-ending suffering? Or was he simply bored by the meaninglessness of day-to-day existence? He was so damn interesting. And different. And a good talker. And he could always cloud the issue with words.

    Abe: Where to begin? You know, the existentialists feel nothing happens until you hit absolute rock bottom. Well, let's say that when I went to teach at Braylin College, emotionally, I was at Zabriskie Point. Of course, my reputation, or should I say a reputation, preceded me.

  • Abe Lucas: Jill had been right in her appraisal of me. I was teetering on the brink of some kind of breakdown, unable to deal with my feelings of anger, frustration, futility. They say that drowning is a painless way to go.