Strong Chinese Complex

Edna 2022-03-24 09:03:20

If you go to America, you should never lose your Chinese heart. As a Chinese director in Hollywood, Wayne Wang seems to have a strong Chinese complex, he made a lot of movies which involved in many Chinese elements or show original China directly. Also he didn't produce too many classical movies except this, his courage and practical action are worthy of praising.

So, what's the story does this The Joy Luck Club talks? This movie focus on three generations, eight Chinese women who immigrated to America. As a coincidental chance, one of the girls has to go to China to find her sisters that her mother left when she was in China. Before her farewell, her good friends and their mothers began to recall their old days in China when they were young .

Their talks vary from marriage to destiny. They reflect the educational systems in two countries. They tried to keep a balance between cultural differences. They fought for love, for job and for honor. Maybe many immigrated people could taste the bitter starred by heroes. But the ending is bright, which pinned the director's blessings.

However, there still some flaws in the film. For example, the structure is too mediocre. And some actors' performance is too dull and exaggerated. Except these, it's still a good movie to reflect China's history, Chinese culture, Chinese thought and Chinese women.

View more about The Joy Luck Club reviews

Extended Reading
  • Emil 2022-03-16 09:01:07

    Not feeling the compassion for the suffering women, more like a legend about the racial other. The mothers of the mothers died or were absent, and the mothers brought the old society/Oriental sufferings to open their hearts and let their daughters (also mothers) learn from the experience of others. It is assumed that the other must be covered with blood, tears and scars, and the suppressed, come to the United States with hope. Although saying this will fundamentally challenge the foundation of the story (question whether it must have come to the United States because of suffering), I still feel that the scars of the movie are too clumsy to expose. Perhaps it is because of the sharp contrast that the drama can be produced, but there will be a better way to deal with it. In addition, the repetition of the structure is clumsy and not sophisticated enough. The four stories seem to be polyphonic and seem boring.

  • Jordy 2022-03-25 09:01:19

    The novel is good. I'm also very impressed with the TV version - the suffering and hardship of women who are shaky but still passed on under another culture shock. The entire film version has a translation accent, some lines are blunt and comical, plus the accents of individual actors, obviously reading Chinese stories, but there is a strong "alienation". I think the story could be a bit more refined, and the use of voiceovers is still too much. When looking at Yu Feihong, she was not as bright as she was when she was 40 years old.

The Joy Luck Club quotes

  • Ying Ying: By then I realized what kind of man I had married... happiest when he was cruel.

  • Suyuan: [Takes off necklace she is wearing and gives it to June] June, since your baby time, I wear this next to my heart. Now, you wear next to yours. It will help you know. I see you. I see you.