Sorrow of the Birds

Creola 2022-05-09 19:48:50


On a chilling winter night in Chicago, see Mauritanian director Abderrahmane Sissako's film Timbuktu (2014). Timbuktu is in Mali, West Africa, at the southern tip of the Sahara Desert. In 2012, extremist Islamic militant groups occupied the city for several months; in 2013, French and Mali government forces drove the rebels out of the city. The film tells exactly what happened in Timbuktu under the rule of extremist Islamic groups. Many residents have fled (especially Christians). People with nowhere to go, no smoking, no music, no football, women wearing veils and gloves and socks. Those who sang were punished with whipping; couples who "adultered" were punished by "stoning". The kids play ball games without football, very powerful. There are always donkeys walking through the streets without incident, giving the illusion that animals are living more freely.

Film photography, editing, music, etc. are all proficient and exquisite. He also has enough understanding of the characters, delicate and restrained, calm and peaceful. The director Chissako studied film at the Moscow Film Academy for several years before working in France. The film, a French-Mauritania co-production, post-production in France, won a Christian Jury Prize at the Cannes Film Festival. All of these hint at why the film substitutes facts for reasons, idealizes life before extremism, emphasizes the anti-human oppression of extremist Muslim militants and the silent resistance of civilians, and the role played by colonial history and the reasons for the emergence of extremist forces. are ignored. This is destined to be a film that meets Western expectations, and the explanation of the "jihadists" (some joined from France, so the language in the film is not only Arabic and local languages, but also French and English) is ambiguous. However, who is qualified to present a more comprehensive, profound and relatively fair picture? Colored glasses have invaded all sides, and some historical truths are destined to be submerged or distorted.

View more about Timbuktu reviews

Extended Reading
  • Orland 2022-05-09 22:44:57

    Prose-style narrative film. The clues are intertwined like idle pens, decorated with a few large visions of the Sahel in West Africa, and the documentary presents the "now" ancient city of Timbuktu. However, the story is outstanding. The most shots in the film give close-ups of the characters' faces, always focusing, and freezing repeatedly. Undoubtedly, this is an ambitious story, although many people do not buy it for such an exposed expression. It is also possible that because of its foreign background, this style is between the desperate commercial film and the silent art film, and it is more tolerant praise. Anyway, I am now more concerned about the "place" behind the image, the desert isolated by modern civilization. PS: Malians can speak French really well

  • Milton 2022-05-09 11:25:45

    The simple lens records a calm story, no strong conflicts, no bloody violence, but ordinary life is swallowed up in a calm conflict, whether Allah or Allah is finally annihilated by human desires and reduced to self-satisfaction. Tool of. "I am not afraid of anyone, the Lord is afraid of Allah; I do not forgive, maybe I will forgive in the future, but not now." The best line!

Timbuktu quotes

  • Omar: Satima?

    Satima: I'm listening.

    Omar: I'm Abdelkarim's driver. I have a message from him: "He can't do anything to help. It's over".

  • L'Imam: [to a jihadist] Stop this. You cause harm to Islam and Muslims. You put children in danger in front of their poor mother. You even hit the mother of two children without any good reason. Before you came, a woman was here to complain that you forced her to wear gloves-- here they are-- without convincing her of their usefulness, as is prescribed by Allah and His prophet. Remember the words of Allah the Almighty: "So pardon them. Consult them in the matter. Speak with them. Once you've made a decision, put your trust in Allah, for He loves those who rely upon Him." Where's leniency? Where's forgiveness? Where's piety? Where's exchange... exchange? Where is God in all this?