The meaning of realism under the magic

Kenton 2022-03-24 09:02:37

From the trailer, you can basically know that the reasonable expectations for this film should include: Southern French scenery, Colin Firth's Mr. Darcy, Emma Stone's Bambie eyes, sarcastic and snobbish conservations, in short, two hours of happy time, with class joy. If that's what you expect, you'll be satisfied. Although, the ending is to be expected by looking at the cast.

It was roommate O who went to the movies together. I am a Ph.D. student in Western Art History, and my dissertation is on 16th-century Dutch painting. O's ex-boyfriend is a young and promising professor of marine biology. He has received NIH funding and tenure at a young age and loves art and philosophy. The two had been in a long-distance relationship for many years, but after O decided to drop out of school, moved to Illinois to work, and lived with her boyfriend two months later, they broke up quickly. And they did not quite part as friends.

On the way home after watching the movie, it was inevitable that we started chatting. After exchanging consolation that Colin Firth is in good shape, Olivia, a character who only appeared in the film for 2 minutes, was brought up. Olivia was Colin Firth's girlfriend/fiancee before she met Emma Stone. Mature, educated, logical, sophisticated. You would think her to be a perfect match or even soul mate for CF but such a reasonable girlfriend, in a movie with the word "Magic" in the title, naturally cannot A good start and a good end. After receiving a breakup call, she calmly did not cry or make trouble, and rationally analyzed "such a thing will happen sooner or later". For such a "sensible" reaction, most people's feeling should not be appreciation, but to further confirm that this Olivia is not cute.

I think what Woody Allen wants to express is nothing more than: the joy of the spiritual world, the miraculous moments in ordinary life, the beauty beyond the material world, the preciousness that has nothing to do with religion, but is indeed related to belief, and even the meaning of life. However, the setting of the characters and the direction of the plot always have the subconscious mapping of the main creator and even the audience. Just imagine if it was a love story between a successful female artist and a young male liar, would we still watch it with such peace of mind, of course. In the relationship between the sexes, reason, wisdom, power, and maturity seem to be deriable only in men, and lovely women should be, sensual, innocent, youthful, and beautiful.
For example, Colin Firth might think there is almost no hope for Emma Stone's brain (And I highly doubt they can have any deep and meaningful conversation), but his heart fell for her. It's passion; it's love at first sight. And we don' t even question the sincerity.
Olivia, the older and wiser woman, can't win affection from either Colin Firth or us. In a skit romance full of romanticism and nostalgia, the setting of the characters, but with the reality The expectations of the world are just right. The prototype in the real world is the drama of countless successful men breaking up with their wives for love.

Compared to another romance, Linklater's Before sunset/sunrise/midnight. Julie Depley is sensual, innocent, beautiful, but also neurotic, idealistic, and intelligent. The acquaintance of the two protagonists also has the element of "love at first sight". But what the audience can't forget is the two people's endless conversations about life, love, growth, art, and philosophy, as if this is the magic of love. Especially in the third part, two people who have entered middle age and have to face the simple real life every day still have love.

So, Moonlight is actually much more realistic than Midnight. Then I continued to talk with O about the philosophical metaphors in Bruegel's paintings.

View more about Magic in the Moonlight reviews

Extended Reading

Magic in the Moonlight quotes

  • Stanley: The comparison makes me laugh! Olivia is a person of accomplishment and charm. Sophie's a street finagler who makes her way living off one bit of hokum to the next.

    Aunt Vanessa: Well, I don't see how you can compare the two.

    Stanley: Well, don't put ideas into my head!

    Aunt Vanessa: Well, far be it from me!

    Stanley: Of course, she does come from dire circumstances. I mean, it's very easy to be judgmental about people who are born into circumstances less fortunate than one's own.

    Aunt Vanessa: Well, life is harsh. One must do what one must to survive.

    Stanley: Well put. And people do sometimes make the wrong choices, which they regret, even though no serious harm was done.

    Aunt Vanessa: Which of us has not made some blunders in life?

    Stanley: And there is a rather appealing quality about Sophie. Despite her disgusting behaviour.

    Aunt Vanessa: Yes, her smile is rather winning. Of course, it depends how much value you put on the purely physical.

    Stanley: Well, no, I... I, for one, esteem the higher virtues.

    Aunt Vanessa: Hmm... Beauty of the soul...

    Stanley: Although her eyes are rather pleasant to look into. And that she can be amusing, under the right circumstances.

    Aunt Vanessa: Oh, but Olivia is an educated, cultivated woman. One that befits a man of your artistic genius.

    Stanley: Yes, now, my genius must be factored in. On paper, there's really no reason to prefer Sophie to Olivia.

    Aunt Vanessa: Well, I would say the opposite.

    Stanley: ...And so your, your suggestion that I, I be honest with Olivia and tell her that as irrational as it seems, I've fallen in love with, with Sophie - that's a preposterous notion.

    Aunt Vanessa: It's lunacy.

    Stanley: ...Yet I can't help feeling that...

    Aunt Vanessa: ...That you love Sophie. Yes, I understand. You're puzzled and bewildered; because your foolish logic tells you that you should love Olivia.

    Stanley: Foolish logic?

    Aunt Vanessa: And yet, how little that logic means when placed next to Sophie's smile...

    Stanley: What are you saying?

    Aunt Vanessa: ...That the world may or may not be without purpose, but it's not totally without some kind of magic.

    Stanley: ...I have irrational positive feelings for Sophie Baker. It's like witnessing a trick I can't figure out.

  • Aunt Vanessa: Which of us has not made some blunders in life?