contradiction

Edythe 2022-03-24 09:03:40



The story unfolds under the huge contradiction that the North won the Civil War and the Southerners assassinated Lincoln shortly after the victory. And the whole movie is under the background of this big contradiction, and it is struggling in more relatively small contradictions. Yes, tough. The most direct impression I felt when watching this movie was the dark light and shadow and the difficulty of walking, as if it was under the dark night, on a muddy road, struggling to move, but had to keep going.

In the beginning, Frederick Aiken, the victorious war hero, had to defend Mary Surratt, a Southern conspirator accused of Lincoln's assassination. His first meeting with Mary in that cramped cell was a spark of conflict. Mary pointed out calmly and sharply that he was no different from those who accused him. They all looked at her with prejudice. In their eyes, she was already a sinner. - This is actually a major contradiction that runs through the film. Of course, their prejudices are not incomprehensible. The civil war has just ended, and everything is waiting to be done, and at this time, their most beloved president, Lincoln, was assassinated, and the crowd was excited. This anger and confusion was the national mood of the entire period at that time. Just understanding does not mean it is correct. .

As the film progresses, Fredrick gradually understands the whole case, and gradually understands Mary as a person. He went from being the opposite of Mary to being on the same side as her. He believed that she was innocent. Then he found that he was on the opposite side of the world he had been in. It wasn't just that friends and lovers couldn't understand him, it wasn't just that he was shut out of social circles, that his belief in the world was shaken. Fredrick is a man of integrity, freedom of belief, justice, and love for his country. But at this time, freedom, justice and the state are in conflict. He had always believed that this country was built on the basis of freedom and justice, but the injustice Mary faced, obviously did not represent the spirit of this country. In the end, Mary was hanged, and he said to Mary's belated son, "I've left the law." He seemed to be able to hear his painful struggle and the shattering of his disintegrating beliefs.

In the last few lines of the film, it is mentioned that Fredrick eventually became a editor-in-chief of The Washington Post. This righteous idealist is also a wise man, and he finally found a way for himself to express himself freely.

View more about The Conspirator reviews

Extended Reading

The Conspirator quotes

  • Reverdy Johnson: Could somebody bring me the transcript of today's trial?

    Edwin Stanton: Shall I read it aloud to you?

    [brings transcript over]

    Reverdy Johnson: Oh, Ed.

    Edwin Stanton: Your young associate is putting up a spirited defense. Reminds me of a certain lawyer I had to face 25 years ago.

    Reverdy Johnson: Ah, he learned to fight in your army. Can I get you a drink?

    Edwin Stanton: No, no. No. I won't be staying long. Reverdy... You've done so much for this nation as any man I know.

    Reverdy Johnson: Oh. Feeling's mutual, Ed.

    Edwin Stanton: Don't you think it's time for us two old war horses to call a truce?

    Reverdy Johnson: Not if you insist on staging this travesty.

    Edwin Stanton: This trial will do more to keep the peace than any paper treaty could.

    Reverdy Johnson: Heh. How'd you convince yourself of that?

    Edwin Stanton: Because justice, swift and firm will help deter the South from ever conspiring again, as well as discouraging the North from seeking revenge.

    Reverdy Johnson: What about the rule of law?

    Edwin Stanton: My first responsibility is to ensure that this war stays won.

    Reverdy Johnson: Oh, and this is how you do it, by keeping fear alive as long as you see fit?

    [shows headlines and stories in a newspaper]

    Reverdy Johnson: Look. "Stanton warns of future rebel plots", water supplies poisoned, firebombing cities, yellow fever spreading all over the place. This is a frightening country, Ed. And you don't need to scare us anymore.

    Edwin Stanton: And who is to say that none of these things could happen? The unspeakable already has- Our president assassinated, 600,000 dead. The world has changed, Reverdy.

    Reverdy Johnson: Abandoning the Constitution is not the answer.

    Edwin Stanton: You may prefer dining alone. I just hope your young associate does as well. If he pushes too hard, he will make enemies who will not soon forget. On this, you know I'm right.

  • Frederick Aiken: Sarah. Sarah, where are you going?

    Sarah Weston: Conduct unbecoming.

    Frederick Aiken: I'm sorry about the party.

    Sarah Weston: You think I care about the party?

    Frederick Aiken: Please. Everything will be all right. I promise you.

    Sarah Weston: You are just like that woman, ready to go to the gallows for the most pointless cause. People do get left behind when you do that.

    Frederick Aiken: I can't ignore what's going on in that courtroom.

    Sarah Weston: But you can ignore me, us?

    Frederick Aiken: I didn't say that. Please, I have to do this.

    Sarah Weston: Do you? I find your devotion to this frightening. I waited such a long time for you.

    Frederick Aiken: I'm so sorry. I know. But I'm back now.

    Sarah Weston: No, you're not.

    Frederick Aiken: I am. I-ple -

    [Sarah gets on the carriage]

    Frederick Aiken: Sarah, please, will you just - We have to - we have to talk about this.

    Sarah Weston: Fred, I love you. I - I wish I could do this. I just-I can't. I just can't.

    Frederick Aiken: Wait. Let me see you at home at least.

    [looks back for Edwin]

    Frederick Aiken: Please wait.