Room in the Tower

George 2022-03-23 09:03:29

In a clip from the movie The Enigma of Kaspar Hauser, Kaspar wonders why the rooms in the tower are smaller than the tower itself. Kaspar's reasoning is as follows: when he is placed in a room, whatever he sees left, right, forward, or backward is the room; but when he turns his back to the tower, the tower is gone. He deduced from this that the room should be bigger than the tower. If we use the metaphor of the room and the tower here, then the relationship between the two is like the relationship between the movie and reality.
In reality, Kaspar is controversial. Many people who came into contact with him agreed that Kaspar was a frequent liar and had a strong sense of vanity. Critics suspect he is a liar, and even the letter he held when he first appeared in Nuremberg is suspected to have been written by him. As for the note that was finally found when he claimed to have been stabbed, there is ample evidence that this chapter was forged by Kaspar himself: the spelling errors in the contents of the note were consistent with Kaspar's usual spelling mistakes, and the folding method was the same as that of Kaspar. He usually folds letters in exactly the same way. Therefore, the authenticity of Kaspar's experience has been questioned.
However, the film portrays him in an extremely positive way, while giving those around him some negative quality to make it easier for viewers to side with Kaspar. The portrayal of the characters in the film is undoubtedly realistic, but it is precisely because of these successful portrayals that it is easier for the audience to become like people in the room, valuing a small part of subjective opinions and ignoring the towers of the outside world. , both for the controversy of the real person Kaspar. But the film itself is not at fault, because the purpose of the film is not to restore reality, but to compile a believable story. This story is just one of many interpretations of Kaspar's life. If this movie can teach us anything about life, life, then it's done. As for whether the room or the tower is bigger or smaller, which is right or wrong, it is just a subjective question.

View more about The Enigma of Kaspar Hauser reviews

Extended Reading
  • Kurt 2022-03-13 08:01:01

    Herzog's masterpiece, won the Cannes Jury Prize. The video interpretation of Locke's "white board talk", from the previous [Wild Child] to the later [Elephant Man], the circus exhibition is like the tame version of [Freak Man]. Gas Hober, who was born into a mystery, is lonely and innocent like a child, questioning faith (priest), scientific reason (logician), and decent civilization (old aristocrat). Fuzzy twinkling dreams, disobedient apples, pilgrimages in the fog - death on the top of the mountain, the blind. (9.5/10)

  • Joanie 2022-04-24 07:01:25

    Struggling to find evidence just to prove that we are civilized and correct, but never wonder if we are hypocritical

The Enigma of Kaspar Hauser quotes

  • Professor Daumer: Kaspar, what's wrong? Are you feeling unwell?

    Kaspar Hauser: It feels strong in my heart... The music feels strong in my heart... I feel so unexpectedly old...

    Professor Daumer: You've been such a short time in the world, Kaspar...

    Kaspar Hauser: Why is everything so hard for me? Why can't I play the piano like I can breathe?

    Professor Daumer: In the two short years you have been here with me, you have learned so much! The people here want to help you make up for lost time.

    Kaspar Hauser: The people are like wolves to me.

    Professor Daumer: No. You mustn't say that...

  • Kaspar Hauser: It seems to me that my coming into this world was a very hard fall.