When I see things of a suspenseful nature, I always like to try to analyze before solving the puzzle, can I come up with the second solution.
Five questions:
1. Before the male protagonist shovels his hoe to kill the aunt, can all the known clues accuse anyone other than the aunt as the deceased? That is, at this point in the story, can everyone except the aunt be cleared of suspicion? Especially Miyazaki, how to prove that she is not the dead? (Don't rush to answer this question first, answer the next 5 questions first and then consider the first question)
Second, about the desk.
One of the strongest evidences in the animation showing that the real deceased is pity is the number of desks: when the dead started in April, the desks did not lack that the deceased was the teacher. But why doesn't the desk question explain the stereotype that Saki is lying? Seeing that for some reason or if she herself is the deceased, is it true that her sister died in April this year? After all, the other clues in the first few episodes are far from coming out, and the easiest explanation to think of should be seeing Saki Ming lying.
Third, about the eyes.
In the appendix, I will argue that it is impossible for Ming Qi to be cured of a malignant tumor in 1988 (and it is still in the position of the eye), and he will not die or relapse for 10 years, and he is still alive and kicking. .
The original author Pedestrian has always been more rigorous in details, especially medical details. I didn't think it was a bug at the time, so Ming Qi's words about the removal of malignant tumors in the eyes were a lie. But judging from the ending and the zeroth chapter, it doesn't seem like a lie. How should this be explained?
4. The hint of the opening song animation The
pictures of those puppets with broken heads or hands and feet that appeared in the opening song did not appear in Chapter 12?
——These are also important reasons why I listed Miyazaki as the number one suspect, because seeing the pictures of these dolls (obviously all from Miyazaki's adoptive mother's shop) in the opening animation were damaged and broken, I naturally had to. In the later period of Lenovo, there must be bloody episodes such as Haunted House, Blizzard Villa or Battle Royale that happened in that store. Seeing Qi Ming as the host, there is a high probability that he will not be able to get rid of the relationship.
5. The hint of the ending song animation In the
characters that appear one by one at the end of the movie, is the back of the woman in the red dress who finally appeared at the balcony door, see Qi Ming? She is not that tall. And the hair is a little longer.
——Besides, she flashed and disappeared, combined with so many clues of her suspicions, I couldn't help but take this special effect as a hint. Alas, who knew that the opening and ending songs weren't actually hints?
The above five points plus Ming Qiming deliberately concealed that he could see the dead, he did not tell the truth when he knew the truth, was wronged and hunted down but did not try to explain these behaviors, so I still think that Ming Qiming is a Another deceased (because at the time I didn't know that episode 13 was an extra, I thought it would be reversed again). So there is the first question: Can we clear everyone's suspicions before shoveling the aunt to death, or can the previous clues also point to another person?
Appendix:
About the eyes:
I paid special attention to the year of the story. The story happened in 1998, and the protagonists were about 14 years old. Miyazaki claimed that her eye was lost when she was 4 years old, that is, around 1988, because of a malignant tumor in the eye, which was surgically removed.
That's weird. Malignant tumor is another term for invasive cancer. Malignant tumor is different from benign tumor, it is the middle and late stage of tumor development, and has the characteristics of invasiveness and metastasis. These definitions are available in literature and medical books. The nerves and blood vessels of the eye are very rich, and they are very close to the central nervous system - the brain, and the transfer is very fast and violent. In addition, three facts must be considered:
2.1 Miyazaki was 4 years old at the time. He was young and weak and could not resist. Some classical treatments were too young to be used.
2.2 About various types of cancer.
In particular, breakthroughs in research and clinical treatment of nausea tumors occurred in the 1990s. In the 1980s, there was no clue about the mechanism of cancer. A lot of common treatments today did not appear. The most widely used chemotherapy was not popularized, and the toxicity was too high and the mortality rate was too high. Even in the 1990s, advanced cancer was basically considered an incurable disease, let alone such a small child. I don't think 1988 can cure eye cancer alive and live normally for more than 10 years.
2.3 Even if there is a time-travel in science, and seeing Qi Mingzhi alive, anyone in the family who has a family member who has had cancer must know that cancer is very easy to recur, and a large number of normal immune cells are bound to be killed when treating malignant tumors. Therefore, after being discharged from the hospital, the patient's physique is bound to be very poor. People will either lose weight and have poor complexion, or they will become swollen and fat (if they take hormone drugs), and they should take frequent anti-relapse courses and take medicines to increase immunity, and the price of follow-up treatment will definitely not be cheap. . But the fact is, not only did Jian Qiming not take any supplementary immune drugs, he did not engage in anti-relapse treatment (not even traces), and his body shape and face shape couldn't be better (although anime should take into account the image, but it can completely make the heroine It's thin and skinny), and the financial situation seems to be good, and there is no trace of the large expenditure required for the follow-up treatment.
2.4 The most amazing thing is that she has a strong physique. Regardless of the miraculous performance of her escaping that night at the shrine, even I can't do somersaults on the horizontal bar. People with such a medical history can't do it.
Therefore, it is determined that Miyazaki did not have cancer; or she had cancer, but because she has died, there is no such contradiction. I always suspected her because she was lying about it
View more about Another reviews
