the dialectics of life

Lacy 2022-03-23 09:02:00

Let's talk about the protagonist Dan first. As a white history teacher, he likes to use dialectics to explain historical phenomena. In the class, he enthusiastically introduces the civil rights movement in history, full of ideals. In his unknown spare time, he indulged in bars and indulged in drugs. Is he a good teacher? When the old student's father greeted him in the bar, he was too slow to remember the student's name; was he a hopeless dude? Behind the intertwining of Gongchou, there is a lot of knowledge, and even research on communism. When you see such a person, you will sigh at the complexity of human nature. Two completely different life states are so naturally compatible with one person: positive and negative, upward and downward, breaking free and sinking, firm and hesitant... Perhaps, As Dan himself said: "One thing doesn't make a man".

Dan's life becomes more entangled with Dray's intrusion. Dray, a black schoolgirl, had no father since she was a child, her brother was imprisoned for drug trafficking, and her mother was unable to take care of her because of her heavy work. She just wanted to earn a little pocket money by selling drugs, but Dan angrily stopped her. In this way, Dan and Dray had a deeper communication in the classroom. But the film is also adequate, and the relationship between teachers and students is ambiguous. Emotions are also complex, and this complexity stems from the simplicity of human nature - it is independent of all acquired classes, races, identities, and so on.

Dan and Dray are two very different people, and if Dray hadn't stumbled upon her teacher's drug use, there might not be such a story. I think it is problematic to explain this story with love. The relationship between them is not as simple as love, and it is not as complicated as love. The only thing the two have in common is loneliness. They are also helpless in the face of the complicated life, no one understands, nowhere to talk, and no escape. There are also comments that they are two people who redeem each other. I think that when two lonely souls are together, they can only warm and care for each other, and there is no salvation at all. At the end of the film, Dray brings drugs to Dan, and the two tacitly agree. Strong people save themselves, great people save others, and Dan and Dray are just two ordinary people.

I was very confused about the title of the film, and I checked the information to find out that Half Nelson is the action term for wrestling. I think the director is using this as a metaphor for a state of stalemate, a struggle for which there is no visible result for the time being. This is also in line with the atmosphere of the whole film. The gushing out emotions are very restrained, like the undercurrents under the calm sea and the molten lava tumbling in the crater. The film has always been straightforward: the overlapping of shots, the dodging of eyes, the wandering of language, the obscurity of expressions... Drugs, ethics, human nature, emotion, race, civil rights, these elements are constantly interspersed and elusive. There is no particularly shocking so-called climax in the whole play, just like a driverless train, without acceleration or deceleration, it just runs along the rails and goes with the flow. The film offers a great way to explain life - it's a challenge to try to explore the dialectics of life. The director interprets life from a dialectical point of view everywhere, but he is very clear that many specific issues cannot be explained clearly, such as human nature and feelings. These are destined to blur the outline of the film.

Dialectics can explain many things that are the unity of opposites, but life can never be as clear as a coin. Life is never pure color, either black or white, but ambiguous gray. It has its own pattern, and we can only copy it. What is the best way? Does this movie have any real meaning to life? It's a matter of opinion.

View more about Half Nelson reviews

Extended Reading
  • Kaleigh 2022-03-26 09:01:06

    There are only two processes of saving and self-help. The world heals faster if you can see the other's weakness and help.

  • Lenny 2021-12-14 08:01:12

    An idealist must be lonely in a utilitarian society, right?

Half Nelson quotes

  • [from trailer]

    Dan: The sun goes up and then it comes down, but everytime that happens what do you get? You get a new day.

  • Dan: Change moves in spirals, not circles. For example, the sun goes up and then it goes down. But everytime that happens, what do you get? You get a new day. You get a new one. When you breathe, you inhale and you exhale, but every single time that you do that you're a little bit different then the one before. We're always changing. And its important to know that there are some changes you can't control and that there are others you can.