I read [Part 1 ] first Set], bad! Episode 1 was so bad. . I picked up [Episodes 1 and 4] and thought it was very bad, not as good as the original one, the screenwriter was very strange, deleted the important plots, but made use of the unimportant ones, the same order and way of telling the story Different, the effect is much worse! To be fair, re-watching the old version, it's really good and engaging! So without hesitation giving one star.
It didn't take long for someone to reply to me, saying that the new version is based on comics, and the old version has been adapted, so it shouldn't be said that the new version is bad. Ok. . Who kept me from reading the manga for too long and can't remember. So, check out the comics again. Conclusion: Both new and old TV versions have adaptations. Let's see where the difference is~~
1. The first is the screenwriter. It's not that VT can't be original! ! Everyone hates the new version of the original, because the new version deletes key points and adds unnecessary plots, which seems extremely procrastinating! The addition of the old version is to enrich the characters and strengthen the personality. There may be more episodes, but it is very compact. Even if there are only 10 episodes in the new version, it is very procrastinating.
[In terms of screenwriting ability, a. Comparing the opening scenes with Xiaojie, Kurapika, and Leorio saving people, you can know how much the rank is different! The new version lacks momentum. b. The first acquaintance of Biqiya's appearance and Xiaojie. Bringing out the cause through an accident is better than dictating it directly, right? ! c. Wetlands are sinister. The comics and several scenes from the old version have been performed cleanly and neatly. The details of the new version have been described for a long time. The classic character display scene of Hisoka playing the examiner game has also been adapted into being provoked and counterattacking, bad! 】
[In terms of originality, a. I think the controversial part of the battleship island is very good, and there is no peacekeeping. Rape is relatively cold, but the unity of Gunkanjima is not warm, but rational and practical. It is also a good contrast to the cruelty of the hunting chapter, and by the way, gives Kurapika a role. The purpose of changing rooms is to relax, it is not good, nor bad. After all, the new version of the 12-episode Little House has also played most of the episodes, which is very unnutritious. . Some people say that Ilmisiso's character is ruined. Have it? ? No! ! ! Why should Ilmi help? Because Xi Suo wants to help Xiaojie! ! Xiao Yi is a person who doesn't care if everyone lives or dies, but he has always been kind to Hisoka. If Western University wants to help Xiaojie, he will help Western University. For them, it's just a small effort, and it's not a loss to help. Sisso pulled Xiaojie, and Ilmi took the helm for a while. It was too small for a case. You can refer to the mentality of the manga GI chapter of Hisoka's promise to form a team to clear the customs - anyway, he is idle, and he will play if he thinks it is fun. b. The increase in the appearance of female assassins on the airship is not to say "if the target is a good person, don't kill", nor is it to whitewash Qi Ya (Qi Ya is not black in the first place!), but just to a person who runs away from home and decides to wash his hands improperly to kill For a child, this is an event that shows his determination. If only I could just kill it at will. But now Qi Ya has to go his own way, so he doesn't kill, and also said "that guy is still working hard for you, if I kill you now, he will be angry", so if he doesn't kill, he just doesn't kill by the way. . As for letting her know that her family is doing bad things, she is just unilaterally educating this girl and expressing the values of the production team. c. After the exam, Ilmi killed Xiaojie and was kicked. It's easy for Xiaoyi to kill Xiaojie, but just like Hisoka, she has the mentality to play. At first, I didn't plan to rush up to kill and leave as if I had completed the mission. After all, it is the child who stole the younger brother who he doted on to death. Let's see what it looks like! Being kicked is an exaggeration, but it’s not a big mistake, but it’s not a big mistake.]
2. Let’s take a look at the seiyuu. In order to be eligible to comment, I re-watched the new version [from episode 1 to episode 7] a few days ago. The seiyuu is really inappropriate (can't use good and bad comments, but it's really inappropriate)! !
Xiaojie: The voice is not as "wild" as it used to be, it is not "boyish" enough, and I can't hear the enthusiasm for adventure. The voice that used to be a little hoarse is very vivid;
Qi Ya: It's ok, but there is no old version of "boys", no transformation between innocent little boys and ruthless killers, no self-confidence of rich and noble boys and disdain for resistance to life experience. I feel that the new version is very thin and the old version is very rich;
Kurapika: It has also become feminine, not very distinctive, and always speaks out of anger, thinking that it is not enough. The old version is more aristocratic, gentle but bold, calm and firm with wisdom (listen carefully to his tone every time he makes a decision);
Leorio: I haven't paid much attention to it, but the old version is more manly, the new version is more manly. The voice is younger;
Lord Hisoka: What a big failure! ! The old version sounded really good! To express this guy's bt incisively and vividly, that kind of weird laugh that enjoys killing and suppresses killing intently, it's addictive! The usual conversation is always with a mocking and teasing smile. The new version has a strong baritone voice (Daisuke Namikawa likes it very much, but it's too strange to match with Hisoka), it feels too decent, and it doesn't match Hisoka's charming smile at all! Let's put it this way, if I listened to Lang Chuan's voice for the first time, I wouldn't fall in love with Hisoka at first sight, I wouldn't be impressed, and I wouldn't be my favorite character.
3. Soundtrack. Needless to say, when everyone mentions XHunter, they can hum the old version of the soundtrack casually. It is too classic, and it is difficult to surpass it. The new version of the soundtrack is incomprehensible. . Appearing in strange places with strange tone. .
By the way, forgot to mention the color. . . Although the changes are not big, they are all ugly. . . Even if you use your own color scheme, it's not bad. . How can the new version be so ugly! Please compare with the manga for details.
PS: See other comments saying that because the traitor dragged the draft for too long, it led to the suspension of the broadcast and the change of animation production company. . . Ugh. . Will he repent when he sees the new version of VT? But even if you know your mistake now, you can't undo it. . Some things are really wrong and can't be fixed. The hunter has come this far, it is the pain and regret in my heart forever. .
View more about Hunter x Hunter reviews
