Kieslowski is dualistic, at least not monistic. The second commandment says not to take the name of the Lord in vain to swear falsely. After reading it, I found that sometimes people can lie and swear in the name of God. This is obviously overturning the precepts and questioning the monolithic God. The old doctor was an honest man, coldly honest—and the appearance of truth is often cold. He had no ability to predict life and death, no matter how good a doctor he was. So in the face of a woman's pressing question, he will tell her: the only thing I know is that I know nothing. Yes, how could he know about the future, about the life and death of others? Some people die suddenly, and some people are sentenced to death by a disease but they can recover miraculously - what determines all this is not science (reason) or religion (faith) in the first commandment, but more chance. , is fate, or a higher level of mystery, a seemingly irregular law. This is the choice the old doctor makes when faced with a dilemma for the first time, and he chooses to tell the truth, the truth is that he knows nothing - even though he notices that the man's condition has improved. He did not make judgments, which in itself is an insistence on dualism. With the development of the situation and the change of the environment - although the fact that the woman is pregnant has always existed, for the old doctor, when he learned about this, there was an additional message in his objective world - to him In this case, this message from the outside is enough to change his subjective experience, coupled with the fact that things are getting more and more urgent (the woman is still an hour away from having an abortion), in this case, we see One exception is the fact that the internal cause is determined by the cause: in the face of the changed reality, he changed his attitude of not being able to predict the life and death of a man before, and happily told the woman that a man will surely die. He lied. We'd even be surprised at his 180-degree turn: a man so honest, lying so neatly. This is the choice the old doctor made in the second dilemma: he simply told a big lie. This is where the film reaches its climax, which is the essence of the second commandment. And this time, the old doctor's choice showed the compassion under his ruthless exterior: for a new life, he violated the commandments. —this is his own God, the negation of his negation; and thus the truth behind the lie emerges. The negation of negation is still the insistence on truth, the insistence on dualism: God warns not to take the Lord's name in vain to swear, and he does not stubbornly believe this, he still trusts in his own God. His own God is: there is no true God, not even his own God, who changes as circumstances change of uncertain existence. This existence is always inexact, and can be overturned and denied at any time - so, it can be said that this existence does not actually exist. Compared with the calmness of the wise, women appear weak and powerless in the face of difficult choices between dilemmas. Although the old doctor was also tormented by the dilemma, the woman was more helpless to be tormented by this dilemma. Did the director intentionally tell us that women are women after all? Downstairs and upstairs, one is simple and the other is luxurious. The old doctor in the humble room carefully caresses his weak-looking cactus, full of leisure and leisure. The woman in the luxurious room is breaking off the leaves of her seemingly strong plant. At the time, she seemed so lonely and helpless, even her efforts to break the stem of the plant were in vain - after all, a woman could not find an outlet to solve the problem. Or it can be said that when women face problems, they are not looking for a solution to the problem, but keep smoking, take out a plant or even a cup, or simply avoid the problem (don't answer the phone), and finally The decision to abort the child comes when the problem has to be resolved (abortion is a helpless option, not a wise choice). Clearly, women are weak and helpless, stupid (betraying her husband and pregnant with her husband's friend's child) and superficial. But we are powerless to make fun of a woman, because we are not necessarily stronger than this woman when faced with a dilemma. To believe that your husband can recover means killing your own children; to keep your own children means to confirm that the husband will die (even if the husband dies without being informed of his wife's betrayal) - really "there is no law in the world" : When there are only two paths in front of you, no matter which one you take, it leads to the Nether Valley, with a sword on the left and a sword on the right... what a painful choice. And most people can only wait at this time, just like the old doctor said to a woman before she knew she was pregnant, the only thing you can do is wait. Waiting is a last resort, or a helpless procrastination. This kind of procrastination shows the inertia of human beings, but it also shows people's hope and wisdom-before quantitative changes lead to qualitative changes, waiting for opportunities seems to be the only way. way out. ——After all, we are all mortals, and our souls always have to rely on them. The science and religion of the first commandment cannot save people. The second commandment of not believing in God, denying God and even denying ourselves seems to make us see a ray of light: there is nothing is absolutely true, the negation of the negation is also infinitely continuous - no beginning, no end. Appears weak when choosing. Although the old doctor was also tormented by the dilemma, the woman was more helpless to be tormented by this dilemma. Did the director intentionally tell us that women are women after all? Downstairs and upstairs, one is simple and the other is luxurious. The old doctor in the humble room carefully caresses his weak-looking cactus, full of leisure and leisure. The woman in the luxurious room is breaking off the leaves of her seemingly strong plant. At the time, she seemed so lonely and helpless, even her efforts to break the stem of the plant were in vain - after all, a woman could not find an outlet to solve the problem. Or it can be said that when women face problems, they are not looking for a solution to the problem, but keep smoking, take out a plant or even a cup, or simply avoid the problem (don't answer the phone), and finally The decision to abort the child comes when the problem has to be resolved (abortion is a helpless option, not a wise choice). Clearly, women are weak and helpless, stupid (betraying her husband and pregnant with her husband's friend's child) and superficial. But we are powerless to make fun of a woman, because we are not necessarily stronger than this woman when faced with a dilemma. To believe that your husband can recover means killing your own children; to keep your own children means to confirm that the husband will die (even if the husband dies without being informed of his wife's betrayal) - really "there is no law in the world" : When there are only two paths in front of you, no matter which one you take, it leads to the Nether Valley, with a sword on the left and a sword on the right... what a painful choice. And most people can only wait at this time, just like the old doctor said to a woman before she knew she was pregnant, the only thing you can do is wait. Waiting is a last resort, or a helpless procrastination. This kind of procrastination shows the inertia of human beings, but it also shows people's hope and wisdom-before quantitative changes lead to qualitative changes, waiting for opportunities seems to be the only way. way out. ——After all, we are all mortals, and our souls always have to rely on them. The science and religion of the first commandment cannot save people. The second commandment of not believing in God, denying God and even denying ourselves seems to make us see a ray of light: there is nothing is absolutely true, the negation of the negation is also infinitely continuous - no beginning, no end. Appears weak when choosing. Although the old doctor was also tormented by the dilemma, the woman was more helpless to be tormented by this dilemma. Did the director intentionally tell us that women are women after all? Downstairs and upstairs, one is simple and the other is luxurious. The old doctor in the humble room carefully caresses his weak-looking cactus, full of leisure and leisure. The woman in the luxurious room is breaking off the leaves of her seemingly strong plant. At the time, she seemed so lonely and helpless, even her efforts to break the stem of the plant were in vain - after all, a woman could not find an outlet to solve the problem. Or it can be said that when women face problems, they are not looking for a solution to the problem, but keep smoking, take out a plant or even a cup, or simply avoid the problem (don't answer the phone), and finally The decision to abort the child comes when the problem has to be resolved (abortion is a helpless option, not a wise choice). Clearly, women are weak and helpless, stupid (betraying her husband and pregnant with her husband's friend's child) and superficial. But we are powerless to make fun of a woman, because we are not necessarily stronger than this woman when faced with a dilemma. To believe that your husband can recover means killing your own children; to keep your own children means to confirm that the husband will die (even if the husband dies without being informed of his wife's betrayal) - really "there is no law in the world" : When there are only two paths in front of you, no matter which one you take, it leads to the Nether Valley, with a sword on the left and a sword on the right... what a painful choice. And most people can only wait at this time, just like the old doctor said to a woman before she knew she was pregnant, the only thing you can do is wait. Waiting is a last resort, or a helpless procrastination. This kind of procrastination shows the inertia of human beings, but it also shows people's hope and wisdom-before quantitative changes lead to qualitative changes, waiting for opportunities seems to be the only way. way out. ——After all, we are all mortals, and our souls always have to rely on them. The science and religion of the first commandment cannot save people. The second commandment of not believing in God, denying God and even denying ourselves seems to make us see a ray of light: there is nothing is absolutely true, the negation of the negation is also infinitely continuous - no beginning, no end. Even her efforts to break the stalk of the plant were in vain - after all, the woman could not find an outlet to solve the problem. Or it can be said that when women face problems, they are not looking for a solution to the problem, but keep smoking, take out a plant or even a cup, or simply avoid the problem (don't answer the phone), and finally The decision to abort the child comes when the problem has to be resolved (abortion is a helpless option, not a wise choice). Clearly, women are weak and helpless, stupid (betraying her husband and pregnant with her husband's friend's child) and superficial. But we are powerless to make fun of a woman, because we are not necessarily stronger than this woman when faced with a dilemma. To believe that your husband can recover means killing your own children; to keep your own children means to confirm that the husband will die (even if the husband dies without being informed of his wife's betrayal) - really "there is no law in the world" : When there are only two paths in front of you, no matter which one you take, it leads to the Nether Valley, with a sword on the left and a sword on the right... what a painful choice. And most people can only wait at this time, just like the old doctor said to a woman before she knew she was pregnant, the only thing you can do is wait. Waiting is a last resort, or a helpless procrastination. This kind of procrastination shows the inertia of human beings, but it also shows people's hope and wisdom-before quantitative changes lead to qualitative changes, waiting for opportunities seems to be the only way. way out. ——After all, we are all mortals, and our souls always have to rely on them. The science and religion of the first commandment cannot save people. The second commandment of not believing in God, denying God and even denying ourselves seems to make us see a ray of light: there is nothing is absolutely true, the negation of the negation is also infinitely continuous - no beginning, no end. Even her efforts to break the stalk of the plant were in vain - after all, the woman could not find an outlet to solve the problem. Or it can be said that when women face problems, they are not looking for a solution to the problem, but keep smoking, take out a plant or even a cup, or simply avoid the problem (don't answer the phone), and finally The decision to abort the child comes when the problem has to be resolved (abortion is a helpless option, not a wise choice). Clearly, women are weak and helpless, stupid (betraying her husband and pregnant with her husband's friend's child) and superficial. But we are powerless to make fun of a woman, because we are not necessarily stronger than this woman when faced with a dilemma. To believe that your husband can recover means killing your own children; to keep your own children means to confirm that the husband will die (even if the husband dies without being informed of his wife's betrayal) - really "there is no law in the world" : When there are only two paths in front of you, no matter which one you take, it leads to the Nether Valley, with a sword on the left and a sword on the right... what a painful choice. And most people can only wait at this time, just like the old doctor said to a woman before she knew she was pregnant, the only thing you can do is wait. Waiting is a last resort, or a helpless procrastination. This kind of procrastination shows the inertia of human beings, but it also shows people's hope and wisdom-before quantitative changes lead to qualitative changes, waiting for opportunities seems to be the only way. way out. ——After all, we are all mortals, and our souls always have to rely on them. The science and religion of the first commandment cannot save people. The second commandment of not believing in God, denying God and even denying ourselves seems to make us see a ray of light: there is nothing is absolutely true, the negation of the negation is also infinitely continuous - no beginning, no end. There are only two paths in front of you. No matter which one you take, it leads to the Nether Valley. When the sword is on the left and the sword is on the right... What a painful choice. And most people can only wait at this time, just like the old doctor said to a woman before she knew she was pregnant, the only thing you can do is wait. Waiting is a last resort, or a helpless procrastination. This kind of procrastination shows the inertia of human beings, but it also shows people's hope and wisdom-before quantitative changes lead to qualitative changes, waiting for opportunities seems to be the only way. way out. ——After all, we are all mortals, and our souls always have to rely on them. The science and religion of the first commandment cannot save people. The second commandment of not believing in God, denying God and even denying ourselves seems to make us see a ray of light: there is nothing is absolutely true, the negation of the negation is also infinitely continuous - no beginning, no end. There are only two paths in front of you. No matter which one you take, it leads to the Nether Valley. When the sword is on the left and the sword is on the right... What a painful choice. And most people can only wait at this time, just like the old doctor said to a woman before she knew she was pregnant, the only thing you can do is wait. Waiting is a last resort, or a helpless procrastination. This kind of procrastination shows the inertia of human beings, but it also shows people's hope and wisdom-before quantitative changes lead to qualitative changes, waiting for opportunities seems to be the only way. way out. ——After all, we are all mortals, and our souls always have to rely on them. The science and religion of the first commandment cannot save people. The second commandment of not believing in God, denying God and even denying ourselves seems to make us see a ray of light: there is nothing is absolutely true, the negation of the negation is also infinitely continuous - no beginning, no end.
View more about Dekalog reviews
