The story is still successful, but because I had high hopes before, I was actually disappointed. After thinking about it, it may be because the hope that I hold in itself is not reasonable.
Looking at the poster, I thought that the children in this class all have their own stories, which should be not so good stories, which is the reason why they must come to this place. Not all of them must be at least half of them, and the teacher should use music to add beautiful paragraphs to these children's stories one by one.
But in fact, the film didn't show any of the children's complete stories, didn't tell them why they came here, so I felt too unfamiliar with most of the children in it, and I didn't think they needed to go there. What bad thing can that little kid who's been waiting for his dad do? Even the child who was called an angel face devil or something did not do anything particularly unreliable. So logically, I first developed a sense of distance from this film. On the contrary, the guy named Mengdan made me feel a little less distance, because there is more time to introduce his background and describe his behavior in the film. To understand is to recognize.
But it is this recognition that makes me even more disappointed in this film.
Personally, I think the child in this class who needs saving the most is Meng Dan. If this child can be saved, it seems that I will admit the teacher's ability from the bottom of my heart and praise this film. But almost everyone gave up on the child, the teacher didn't put much effort into the child, and when he left, he was still considered hopeless, and probably worse.
However, the teacher is indeed a mortal, and it is impossible to ask for higher. Besides, it is not easy to build such a choir in such a place. The more demanding it is, the harsher it is.
But I still don't think it's right to think about it this way. Maybe the poster and my feeling are too different from the film. There are too few detailed descriptions for the whole class of children, basically only two children are well written, if the poster is this teacher Gabon Pino and Pierre, I may not be disappointed.
I have watched very few foreign films that responded to teachers and students. The one I feel is good is "The Great Will Hunting". That film moved me very much. I don't know if this comparison is reasonable, but the only reference is This, so I couldn't help but compare it. "The Great Will Hunting" is a one-on-one story. Basically a teacher and a student, the movie has enough time and energy to dig into the story. But the cattle-herding class is a story about a teacher and multiple students. It is normal for such a short film, such a large class of children, to not dig deep into the story. So I can only use an eccentric method to write the stories of one or two children with force, and other children take it with one stroke. But this might work elsewhere, but it's hard in school, because the teacher's taboo is eccentricity.
And this teacher is indeed a little biased. He obviously attaches more importance to Pierre than other children. This emphasis includes not only appreciating Pierre's excellent voice, but also the teacher's love for Pierre's mother. There is nothing wrong with being a good student, but bringing emotions outside of the classroom to school is not an appropriate way to be a teacher.
In the end, I am actually curious about the life of the child who became a music stand. I think this is what makes me feel unreasonable by this teacher. Maybe most people think it's nothing, but I think being a music stand is not teaching this child in accordance with his aptitude, but an insult at all.
Because it's a very strange and eye-catching position, and it's not a position that you get for being good, and no one with a normal mind will like that position. If I were that teacher, I would say to the kid privately that you sing softly, instead of telling everyone who came to the show that the kid is tone deaf.
And from a physiological point of view, it is very tiring to hold a score like this. Why is it that other children are enjoying the music created by themselves while they are easily putting down their hands, while he has to pretend to be an inanimate object and can only appreciate others? ? (Those who want to say that I am too hypersensitive, please feel at ease and think that I am willing to be that music stand.) In the
end, it was confirmed that this child stole the money, but the reason was not explained, which is too sloppy. Hehe, the evil point is that this is the only kid left behind by the music, so I really find it hard to think of this as a successful teacher.
But anyway, teachers are also human, so I can't ask too much, but I'm just not too impressed.
Again, no matter how good a teacher is, it is impossible to take care of every student. This is impossible. No matter how good a movie is, it is impossible for everyone to give five stars. This is impossible.
View more about The Chorus reviews
