Pioneer's Sorrow

Kris 2022-03-22 09:02:35

Will you choose to die while you can?

to die or to live, it is always a question...

euthanasia has always been a point of contention. There is an old saying in China, "It is better to die than to live", but is this true?

When survival becomes a pain, when breathing is unbearable, when sickness and old age torture us to the point of loss of dignity and inhumanity, can we choose a peaceful and decent way to die? I think, maybe at that time, liberation was the only thought!

Death is also a human right and choice. I know that people who have not experienced it have no position to comment, but if it were me, I would probably choose to leave in peace instead of struggling in pain. This may be selfishness, or cruelty to the relatives around him, but it may not be another kind of relief.

Jack's sadness lies in his persistence in his beliefs. He is a pioneer in supporting euthanasia, but he is the object of rejection by religiousists. He challenged the law to legislate euthanasia, but the law eventually defeated him. At the end of the film, the female judge's sentence to him is inseparable from the law, "No one can be above the law", but isn't the law made by people? Isn't it for people? Those whose survival has become a torture are deprived of the right to die peacefully, can their pain be redeemed by the law? No, this is the tragedy of the law, but also the tragedy of human nature.

I'm not a supporter of euthanasia, but I sympathize with Jack and see him in prison at age 71.

Al Pacino is too nb, his acting skills are really worthless, he alone is enough to support the whole film~!

View more about You Don't Know Jack reviews

Extended Reading

You Don't Know Jack quotes

  • Geoffery Fieger: The court of appeals' ruling just came in and they ruled in our favor. They said that the law was so poorly worded that it could not be upheld.

    Jack Kevorkian: Oh. Well, I'm glad to hear there's still some smart people in power left.

    Geoffery Fieger: That was the good news. They also ruled that there's no constitutional right to commit suicide...

    Jack Kevorkian: I take back what I just said.

    Geoffery Fieger: ...and that aiding in one falls under an old common-law definition of murder.

    Jack Kevorkian: Common law? What the hell is that?

  • Jack Kevorkian: Oh, the lingering of death. What a business. Keep death alive. Hospitals don't make money otherwise. Drug companies either. If you're rich and you have the money, you can pay to die. But the poor, they can only afford to stick it out and suffer.