Our little people under the background of grand narrative

Geraldine 2022-03-23 09:03:19

Goya's soul is not a recent photo of Goya's personal soul, but a glimpse of the soul of history. The era in which Goya lived has experienced ups and downs, and he has gradually evolved from a court-style painter to an era depictor who is obsessed with revealing reality.
And Inas or her daughter is the typical image of ordinary people in such ups and downs times. They have no resistance when facing the wheels of history. They may slide in any direction with the promotion of the times. Life. It may be tragic madness (the pitiful Inas at the end of the film), it may be a momentary glory (Alyssa who clings to the ruling regime, Lorenzo when the rebellion succeeds), and more may be just a person who is in power The blinded fools (those who crowd and cheer at the gallows). They have unknowingly entered a role in the grand historical narrative, small and insignificant.
The style of the film reminds us of Yu Hua's novels—big backgrounds with splattered thick lines, ordinary but delicately depicted small characters. These little people have been ill-fated with the rolling tide of history, but in the end what condensed in their hearts is the most real love-for ordinary people, it is the love for family and friends, just like Inas in the film at the end A kiss condenses her love for Lorenzo from the beginning; for the artist, it is a broader sense of love or obsession, like the paintbrush that Goya never wants to put down.

(The above content is from the discussion assembly of the "Unicorn Movie Salon" event on April 17, 2010)

View more about Goya's Ghosts reviews

Extended Reading
  • Michele 2022-03-28 09:01:13

    After being reminded, I noticed that Ghosts is plural, and the spirits of Goya are actually the souls written by Goya. At the end of the film, I realize that this is not a biographical film of Goya. Criticizing the hypocrisy of the church is the main theme, but the whole is still too superficial.

  • Gaylord 2022-03-22 09:02:53

    A bit heavy, don't like it very much

Goya's Ghosts quotes

  • Hooded Monk: Are you prepared to swear on the holy cross that you're telling the truth?

    Inés: About the pork?

  • Tomás Bilbatúa: Forgive me, Father Lorenzo, but um, have you ever been put to the... to the Question, yourself?

    Brother Lorenzo: Have I ever been?

    Tomás Bilbatúa: Yes. Have you ever been subjected to the Question?

    Brother Lorenzo: Of course not.

    Tomás Bilbatúa: Do you think that if you were, and they asked you to confess something grotesquely absurd... say... say you were told to confess that you're really a monkey.

    [laughter around the table]

    Tomás Bilbatúa: You're sure that god would grant you the fortitude to deny it? Or would you rather confess to being a monkey? To avoid the pain.

    Goya: I know I would.

    Tomás Bilbatúa: I know you would. So would I.

    Tomás Bilbatúa: [to Lorenzo] Would you?

    Goya: What is this Tomás, are you playing some sort of silly game with you guest? Nobody would ever ask Father Lorenzo to confess something so absurd.

    Tomás Bilbatúa: I would.

    [leaves the table]