something above human words

Michel 2022-03-28 09:01:14

When I convened the group to watch a movie together that night, I used the predicate "appreciate," and I really didn't think much of it; I realized that I had used the wrong word less than a minute after the end of the sweet mother-daughter dialogue beyond the opening credits.
Well, this is just a title, the heroine's expression is too contrived, the connection between the supporting characters is too blunt, and the scene switching is abrupt - well, I have put up with all of these, even in the scene where the male protagonist appears, such problems still exist As always. . .
Actually, none of these are the big problems of this movie, and I don't want to criticize such a gospel movie at all for these technical reasons. After all, we need to take into account various practical constraints, such as funding. And, as I've discussed with some friends, such a film is strong, out of concern for practical issues of society—or rather, out of concern for neighbors (in the reverse sense of Samaritan's neighbors)— In my opinion, it is far better than some movies with huge investment, crowded stars, grand and beautiful scenes, but only satisfying the dreams of some directors, leaving the society from old to young and confused and chaotic. Blockbusters (a lot of blockbusters in China in recent years have been such a tragic situation).
In my opinion, the biggest problem with this gospel movie is that it doesn't understand the "movie", so it is impossible to use the elements of the script and movie to tell a story that is not only moving but also convincing, and has a deeper thought.
From a person like me who is not even an amateur, the feature of film, or multimedia imaging method, is that it contains a much richer amount of information than a single voice communication. The biggest difference between watching American dramas and Japanese and Korean dramas is here. Most of the former are eager to dump a lot of information on you and bring you into a more vivid scene-to a large extent, it is also a smoke tactic, hehe, while Japanese and Korean dramas have The consistent style is a single-line narrative, and the scene is simple or even similar to a stage play (the most recent comparison is CSI and the Japanese drama BOSS, the latter has the suspicion that painting a tiger is not an anti-dog).
However, the flaw of Japanese dramas - this is a mode of "hard work" in the current mainland and Taiwan idol dramas - is that they like to use language to express the content that is implied in various non-verbal expressions in the daily context. . Well, brake before I seem to be going any farther. . . To make an inappropriate analogy, watching Fireproof feels like an American drama "imitation" of a Japanese drama - the theme is clear, the clues are clear, and there are many deep lines, but the content is too thin and empty. What is uncertain is whether this "imitation" effect can be caused by the screenwriter or director, or is it the result of limited ability?
The above mentioned are just the differences between Japanese dramas and American dramas. The reasons may involve different aesthetics, literary styles, psychological structures, etc. between the East and the West, and I have no intention of digging holes here. But here at Fireproof, in a community of believers and church traditions we are familiar with, we can at least say one thing is clear: the distance between the Protestant tradition of evangelism and the multimedia means of cinema.
Fireproof inserted some humorous passages, such as the one in the bathroom and the part where the "chili sauce" is fired, and the career and life of the male protagonist are also revealed through several rescue events throughout the book, but, from the whole film Judging from the film, these accounts for almost one-third of the content but did not provide any subtle help for the main theme of the film, or the transformation and sublimation of the protagonist's heart - at least the director or screenwriter (or actors?) The touches that may be contained in it are expressed. So much so that in the conversion scene of the male protagonist, which should be the first climax of the whole film, the result is extremely abrupt, although his previous question about why he should love a person who has repeatedly rejected him is very shocking and can indeed guide He turned to Christ's love, but it wasn't enough to convert him (incidentally, it's irritating that the acting is blunt here).
A certain brother said that he can already remember some classic lines in the movie. I'll admit, there's no shortage of classic lines in this movie, and according to some, it's not easy for a movie to have memorable lines - are we talking about Zhou Xingxing? In my opinion, most of the classic lines of this film are actually interpretations from another angle of the doctrines we agree with, and the success of the lines is only a result of the tradition of Christian "words". So, is the film a success? In my opinion, no. As in rational theology, we start from a common problem, and in the process of seeking answers, we gradually turn to a particular belief—belief in Christ. Now, the question is a good one—how love and marriage are created and sustained, but the process of answering it seems too hasty, and it just gives a quick Christian answer, which may not be convincing to those who are not Christians. And it's only expressed through verbal persuasion - it's as if 8 lanes are only used for one lane. For Fireproof, in addition to failing to develop the story sufficiently to make it convincing, it's tempting to question the need for multimedia—why would there be a few more lanes to speak. . .

Words of a hole. . . . . .

I deeply feel that how to spread the gospel beyond words is a problem, not only in the use of multimedia means, but also in the inner and the behavior.

View more about Fireproof reviews

Extended Reading
  • Clemmie 2022-03-26 09:01:15

    A bit far-fetched but still touching

  • Vincent 2022-03-29 09:01:10

    Deduct one star for ubiquitous religious persuasion, plus one star for Mike Seaver

Fireproof quotes

  • Catherine Holt: What are you doing?

    Caleb Holt: I see you left me no pizza.

    Catherine Holt: Caleb, I just lit that candle. I like the way it smells.

    Caleb Holt: Well, I don't! Did you leave me any dinner at all?

    Catherine Holt: I assumed you were eating with Michael.

    Caleb Holt: Does it not occur to you that there are two people living in this house and both of them need to eat?

    Catherine Holt: You know what, Caleb, if you would communicate with me, maybe I can have something for you.

    Caleb Holt: Why do you have to make everything so difficult?

    Catherine Holt: Oh, I'm making everything difficult? Seems to me like I'm carrying the weight around here while you're off doing your own thing.

    Caleb Holt: Excuse me? I'm the one working out there to pay this mortgage, and I pay for both of the cars.

    Catherine Holt: Yeah, that's all you do! I pay for all of our bills with my salary!

    Caleb Holt: Which you agreed to do. That's fair! Do you not like this house? Do you not like your car?

    Catherine Holt: Oh, Caleb, who takes care of this house? Me! Who washes all the clothes? Me! Who gets all the groceries? Me! Not to mention that I'm helping my parents every weekend! You know I've got all this pressure on me, and the only thing you ever do for anybody is for yourself!

    Caleb Holt: Let me tell you something: you don't know the first thing about pressure. All right, you think I put out house fires for myself? Or rush to car wrecks at 2AM for myself? Or pull a child's body out of a lake for myself? You have no idea what I go through!

    Catherine Holt: Oh, yeah, but what do you do around here other than watch TV and waste time on the Internet? You know what? If looking at that trash is how you get fulfilled, that's fine, but I will not compete with it!

    Caleb Holt: Well, I sure don't get it from you!

    Catherine Holt: And you won't! Because you care more about saving for your stupid boat and pleasing yourself than you ever did about me!

    Caleb Holt: SHUT UP! I'M SICK OF YOU! YOU DISRESPECTFUL, UNGRATEFUL, SELFISH WOMAN!

    Catherine Holt: I'm not selfish...

    Caleb Holt: HOW DARE YOU SAY THAT TO ME! YOU CONSTANTLY NAG ME AND YOU DRAIN THE LIFE OUT OF ME! I'M TIRED OF IT! IF YOU CAN'T GIVE ME THE RESPECT I DESERVE... LOOK AT ME! THEN WHAT'S THE POINT OF THIS MARRIAGE?

    Catherine Holt: I want out. I just want out.

    Caleb Holt: If you want out, THAT'S FINE WITH ME!

  • Latasha Brown: Honey, I agree with you. You gotta get out. He don't deserve you.

    Deidra Harris: You can say that again. A real man's got to be a hero to his wife before he can be to anybody else, or he ain't a real man.

    Ashley Phillips: Catherine, do you need a place to stay? I can't imagine living in the same house as that man.

    Catherine Holt: No, I decided last night that I am not the one who's leaving. He's the problem, not me.

    Deidra Harris: That's right, girl, stand your ground. Make him respect you. If there's one thing a man understands...

    Caleb Holt: [Cuts to Caleb and Michael, discussing the same situation] ... .it's respect. That's the issue. That's the reason our marriage is failing. She shows me no respect at all. And the saddest part about it is...

    Catherine Holt: [Cuts back to Catherine and her group of friends] He doesn't have a clue. He thinks our marriage has been fine for the most part. You know, he probably thinks...

    Caleb Holt: [Cuts to Caleb and Michael] Our marriage has been fine until this year. Now all of a sudden she goes off the deep end.

    Michael Simmons: Do you really think this happened all of a sudden?

    Caleb Holt: I don't know what to think. I don't understand her. She's emotional about everything, she's easily offended, and way too sensitive.

    Catherine Holt: [Cuts to Catherine, starting to sob] I mean, he's so insensitive. You know, he doesn't truly care how I feel, he doesn't listen to me. Even if I say it over and over and over again.

    Caleb Holt: [Cuts to Caleb and Michael] And then she starts nagging me and saying I don't listen to her... or something like that. It drives me crazy. I feel like I'm going...

    Catherine Holt: [Cuts to Catherine] Insane. You know, he doesn't understand my needs. It feels like we are completely and totally...

    Caleb Holt: [Cuts to Caleb and Michael] Incompatible. She's probably whining to her friends, making me sound like a criminal. I can see them all right now: crying, having some sort of group hug.

    Latasha Brown: [Cuts back to the women crowded around Catherine, comforting her, giving her a group hug] It's gonna be OK, sweetie. It's gonna be all right.

    Ashley Phillips: You'll get through this.

    Deidra Harris: We have your back. Whatever you want. Whatever you need. Whatever you need.

    Michael Simmons: [Cuts to Caleb and Michael] So, you think it's past the point of no return?

    Caleb Holt: I don't have a reason to return.