1.25suspect, 1killer: All analyses are based on the premise that the only killer exists among the 25 suspects.
2. Assume that all shots, except for memories, are basically in accordance with the timeline.
3. Try not to involve motives, and only demonstrate criminal traces.
-------------------------------------------------- ----------------------
List of 25 suspects (up to episode 7, divided into three groups):
Alien group:
henry: groom
trish: bride
shea: sister
mrs wellington: stepmother
madison: sister's daughter
sully, danny, booth*: best man four of four
beth: bridesmaid
chloe: bridesmaid
cal: chloe's boyfriend
abby: heroine
JD: groom brother
islanders group:
sheriff: sheriff , heroine father
jimmy: fisherman, heroine ex-boyfriend
shane: fisherman friend
nikki: bar girl
maggie: wedding planner
death group:
marty: groom's uncle
kelly: distressed female
hunter: bride ex-boyfriend
lucy: bridesmaid
wellington: father-in-law
richard: brother-in-law
malcom: One of the best man
*booth is not included in the death group because there is no way to tell if he really died. One is that the body is not seen, and the other is that someone posted a picture in Baidu Tieba to prove that he is not dead.
-------------------------------------------------- ----------------------
Analysis, doubt and exclusion
1.cousin ben event //////// Can't rule out whether anyone who
died is cousin ben ? Why use such a troublesome killing method?
Two oxygen cylinders can be seen on the screen, and the time for two oxygen cylinders to breathe is generally no more than 5 hours; but the island 37 miles (about 60 kilometers / about 32 nautical miles) away from Seattle, at the cruising speed of the yacht, It will be there in about 2 hours. The above data is not necessarily accurate, but it shows that the islanders' suspicion of committing crimes cannot be ruled out through this incident.
2. Uncle marty event //////// It cannot be ruled out whether
the bridge that anyone Chloe has crossed (no accident happened), the bridge that the seventh episode chased after JD Sheriff and others (visibly intact) is the same bridge? Is Uncle Marty a middle-level agency or is overweight (it is possible that the murderer just followed along and seized the opportunity to kill the uncle), is it still worth scrutinizing?
3. Priest incident //////// Exclude cal, abby, nikki, sully, chloe, danny, booth
personally believe that when the priest was killed, the murderer was nearby. The reason is: the priest's weak hearing seemed to hear the sound of metal friction; the priest was smashed to pieces, and the agency only cut off the priest's head, it is difficult to believe that it can cut him into pieces, and at the same time, it is also difficult to believe that the priest's The corpse hangs in place for a long time.
Before the priest was killed, foreign tourists were preparing to go on a scavenger hunt. After the priest dies, the screen switches to the bar. At this time, cal and abby of the blue team were in the bar with the two generals. And another group of people: sully, chloe, danny, booth, together, looking for jw's cemetery. I don't think these people are likely to walk away alone in the game, based on the assumption that there is only one killer, excluding cal, abby, nikki, sully, chloe, danny, booth.
As for the newlyweds, the priest was making out in the kitchen before he was killed, and reappeared after the death of the priest. The bride sat alone in the room, and Lucy entered the room to talk to her; the groom met Abby in the hotel. The two were unable to escape suspicion.
This reasoning adds the assumption that the killer was at the scene when the priest was killed.
4. Kelly Incident //////// It cannot be ruled out that anyone has
no obvious trace of homicide.
5. Hunter Incident //////// Two details cannot be ruled out for anyone
: hunter seems to have walked straight onto the speedboat; close-up of the speedboat after hunter's death: made for candlewick inn. Tend to think it's not random killing.
6.lucy incident //////// In the event of excluding chloe, sully, malcom, abby, and cal
lucy, the murderer was confirmed at the scene. After Lucy went to look for the puppy, the group of four went to look for Cal, so chloe, sully, malcom, abby, and cal were not suspicious.
The question that exists is: Is it possible for cal to put himself down, kill people in secret, and at the same time follow the search team to hang himself up a moment in advance. Based on the analysis of the priest's incident, his suspicion is ruled out.
7. The booth event //////// Can't rule out anyone
Whether Booth is dead or not is a big mystery so far. Malcom once spoke in front of a pile of dirt, seems to be really dead, otherwise it's hard to explain. But, anyway, booth has a lot of open issues.
8. Wellinton Incident //////// Can't rule out anyone
9. Richard Incident //////// Exclude Shane, Madison In fact, Madison
can be ruled out early in the morning, no matter how weird the little girl is, no matter how strange she may be with the murderer There is no connection, she can't complete all the operations of killing.
When the sheriff and Henry cleaned up the animal carcasses in the church, he said that Shane would be locked in the police station before the wedding as a wedding gift.
In addition, it is added that Richard's call does not seem to be like a call with a lawyer. It may be the murderer, and the murderer uses this to determine his location.
10.malcom incident //////// Excluding JD
, this incident cannot determine the time, and it is not sure where the place where malcom burns money is. At the same time, it makes the mystery of whether booth died or not.
The only thing that can be sure is that JD has been arrested as a suspect at this time.
-------------------------------------------------- ----------------------
List of remaining suspects:
foreign group:
henry: groom
trish: bride
shea: sister
mrs wellington: stepmother
beth: bridesmaids
island group:
mills : sheriff, heroine's father
jimmy: fisherman, heroine's ex-boyfriend
maggie: wedding planner
-------------------------------------------------- ----------------------
Other questions:
1.Is booth dead?
2. Abby's conversation with the driver in the taxi is interesting at first: "you look familiar" "yes, i grew up in this island" "yes, you are the daughter of the sheriff"
This conversation happened in Seattle On the pier, why did the driver mention the island? A plausible explanation is that the driver was familiar with or was a person on the island and recognized Abby; or, a more dire assumption, that Abby had landed at another pier and she had just returned from the island.
3. In front of the hotel on the island, someone (without showing his head on purpose) took a bag from the luggage cart. Comparing clothes, booth was the one who took the bag first at the restaurant. (What does this mean?)
5. When the sheriff and Henry were cleaning animal carcasses in the church, Abby called the sheriff. Henry thought his phone was ringing, so he said: Maggie was looking for him. The sheriff replied: There is no doubt that this woman is half a pit bull.
6. JD claimed to be going to dig JW's grave and was held in a hotel room by the sheriff. Before long, Madison walked into the hotel room where JD was being held. JD asked: how you get the key. Madison replied: Maggie kept it in a drawer and no one paid attention to the little ones.
To sum up, so far, I personally tend to end up with Maggie, the wedding planner.
View more about Harper's Island reviews
