They were supposed to be free like butterflies

Ettie 2022-03-22 09:02:01

The film is adapted from the novel of the same name by the German writer Remarque. It tells the tragic story of the German frontline during the First World War. A group of teenagers in their early 20s, under the instigation of school patriotism education, went to the battlefield with the dream of a great hero, but they did not see anything. Flowers and applause, only mountains of corpses and blood-stained ditches.

At the beginning of the movie, young students are immersed in the romantic fantasy of war under the instigation of the teacher. At that time, the European youth did not know what war was. They thought that war was wearing tall and straight military uniforms, like a heroic adventure like a knight in a legendary novel. , even blood-stained armor is a noble honor, women and wine, music and roses, is another color of war. However, when they actually went to the front line and heard the hail of bullets on the battlefield, they realized that it was the sound of broken dreams.

Under the bombs, the limbs of the comrades flew in the air, the smell of blood was sprinkled on the mud like rain, the excrement and urine on the battlefield mixed with the putrid corpses, stirring the acid in the stomach. "Serving the country is false, only death is true". Boimer said this to the students, but those immature faces had long been bruised by the slogan "The country needs you". The teenager not only turned a deaf ear to his words, but also called him a "coward".

The film finally freezes on the hand of Boimer that did not touch the butterfly. If there was no war, he should have been as free as this butterfly and lived only for himself, but he finally died on the "calm" western front. On the battlefield, this moment has become a classic in film history.

Released in the 1930s, this film is still hailed by fans as "one of the greatest anti-war films" today, and it is meant to tell us that all wars are absurd frauds and that the medal on the shoulder is not The reward for your madness is the bloodthirsty sin of primitive humanity. What a war film should arouse should not be the surging passion and courage of the viewers, but the disgust.

View more about All Quiet on the Western Front reviews

Extended Reading
  • Deangelo 2022-01-03 08:01:12

    8.5 Considering the era of this film, this work deserves to be the greatest anti-war film adaptation of Remark's novel of the same name. In addition to the repulsive acts of war and absurd patriotic education, what I remember is that The robes of Paul and Kaczynski are ironic that it worshipped the war and was ruthlessly taken away by it. In addition, the scene where Paul returned to his hometown in the bar surrounded by the Minke generals at the back reminds me of the forgotten soldier. People who have not experienced the baptism of war in World War II memoirs will talk about war as a trifle, and for those who have really experienced war, everything about them has been changed. Just as the original said-the times are burning. My soul has gone out. I hope to have a German version. After all, there is still some sense of violation when watching Americans play the German army.

  • Conor 2022-03-24 09:02:11

    Great! Naked description of the meaninglessness of war. For the first time, the close-quarters combat in the trenches made me feel that the war was so close that I could almost feel the enemy coming towards me offscreen. Hot-blooded young people who are looking forward to serving their country are hiding in the camp on an empty stomach, waiting for the air strikes to pass by. A group of people discussed in a playful manner why this battle was fought, and in the end they could only believe that it must be do someone's good. The war was brutal, but the home in the rear could not be returned. Only friends who have been through war together can understand each other. In the end, when the soldier who stole the food said, "The war will really end only if I die," he suddenly hit a teardrop, and the hand that could no longer reach the butterfly immediately exploded, breaking down and crying.

All Quiet on the Western Front quotes

  • Katczinsky: I'll tell you how it should all be done.

    [spits]

    Katczinsky: Whenever there's a big war comin' on, you should rope off a big field...

    Cigar-smoking soldier: And sell tickets.

    Katczinsky: Yeah. And -

    [glares at interrupter]

    Katczinsky: And on the big day, you should take all the kings and their cabinets and their generals, put 'em in the center dressed in their underpants, and let 'em fight it out with clubs. The best country wins.

    [everybody murmurs in agreement]

    Paul Bäumer: Well, now that Kat's settled everything, let's go see Kemmerick.

  • Paul Bäumer: We live in the trenches out there. We fight. We try not to be killed, but sometimes we are. That's all.