Extreme idealism is also extremism

Cheyanne 2022-03-23 09:02:50

Tarkovsky's praises and eulogies for the madman Dominic's extreme idealism are undoubtedly pathological. He has fallen into a false sense of responsibility "for your own good" and lacks the spirit of humanism and humanitarianism.

Tarkovsky said in the sculpture time that the madman Dominic criticized the degeneration and material hedonism of modern society, and firmly believed that this was the road to destruction. Moreover, Dominic believes that he has a redemptive and moral responsibility for his family and others, and does not want them to go out into the apocalyptic fallen world. So he imprisoned his family and let them get rid of the materialistic world outside like himself. But did his child say it was the end of the world after he was rescued? It shows how comfortable, comfortable and wonderful the outside world is for his wife and children, but for Dominique, it is a sinking. It is giving up the body to serve spiritual pursuits, and instead makes human beings captive by their own fleshly desires and biological instincts. Tarkovsky said, "Dominic is a bit like a stalker, he sticks to his own ideas, does not succumb to the pursuit of utility and materialism by the whole society, chooses the path of painful martyrdom, and tries to prevent it through personal efforts and self-sacrifice. Human beings have embarked on that crazy road of self-destruction. The most important thing is that people's never-ending conscience keeps him from coveting comfort and food all day long." In Dominique's view, material desire and utilitarianism are the end of the world, and the spiritual world is the eternal place. Toh, it's really good to pursue this thing yourself. Many poets grow up poor and harmless in the rich spiritual world. The bad thing is that Dominic and Tarkovsky think that they are alone in their spiritual beliefs. Pursuit is not enough, he also needs a sense of responsibility, dedication and sacrifice to others, he needs to influence others, force others to get these good things, and selflessly give others these beliefs, which is very evil. He imprisoned his family for 7 years until he was rescued, went to the Roman Forum to preach for many days, and then self-immolated as a martyr. These actions are very consistent with his consistent beliefs. But in the modern concept, imprisoning others and self-immolation are extreme idealism after breaking through the humanitarian bottom line, wanton harm to others and themselves. Universal values ​​and humanitarianism draw a bottom line for human beings, and the biggest characteristic of all extremism is to ignore this bottom line.

View more about Nostalghia reviews

Extended Reading
  • Alia 2022-03-17 09:01:06

    The perfect composition at your fingertips, the homesickness of countless long shots. Tarkovsky put the complex feelings and fragmented memories of going home to the country in this movie. Carving time.

  • Demetrius 2022-03-21 09:02:48

    Dark and damp. Sovietized Italy through Tarkovsky's mirror: Unfamiliar "third-party" space. Eternal worshiper of the earth spirit wandering like a cloud. Only madmen have grasped the truth, so they are saints, and Andre and Dominic are the incarnations of the old tower outside and inside respectively. Voluntary death: With Beethoven's symphony self-immolation in the square, there is a hint of Nietzsche's philosophy. The cause of loneliness is the rejection of boredom and vulgarity

Nostalghia quotes

  • Andrei Gorchakov: What are you reading?

    Eugenia: Arseny Tarkovsky's poems.

    Andrei Gorchakov: In Russian?

    Eugenia: No, it's a translation. Quite a good one.

    Andrei Gorchakov: Throw it away.

    Eugenia: Why? The translator's a very good poet.

    Andrei Gorchakov: Poetry is untranslatable, like the whole of art.

    Eugenia: You may be right that poetry is untranslatable. But music? Music for example...

  • Eugenia: So what did God say to St. Catherine?

    Domenico: "You are she who is not, but I am He who is."