Turn it off, turn it off, turn it off!

Zane 2022-03-22 09:02:11

When chatting with friends about Foucault, she found this film and took time to watch it while traveling. It's been a long time since I watched a documentary, is this the way it is shot now? interesting. But "Social Dilemma" translated as "surveillance capitalism" is boring.

An intuitive feeling I have had for a long time: no need to be implanted in the body, mobile smart terminals have become a new organ for everyone, and human beings are continuing to evolve in this form.

The film is of course more profound, and it explains the role of social media algorithms in both micro and macro aspects: 1. Algorithms are subtly controlling and changing the thinking mode of individuals, and the changes of each individual human being can be seen as a whole. It is a population-based evolution (degeneration?); 2. Algorithms are gradually eroding the basic operating rules of human society. Internet social media can promote human beings to achieve wider dialogue and deeper communication, but it intentionally or unintentionally makes individual Imprisoned in the information cocoon, inciting contradictions, deepening dissent, hindering negotiations, and tearing society apart.

The film also recalls the original intention of social media algorithm design. Their original design purpose was not to "control" or "incite", but due to the requirements and restrictions of the profit model (selling advertising), the algorithm gradually "degenerates", and the technology is no longer human-oriented. Therefore, the fundamental cause of technological alienation of people is still the profit-seeking nature of capital. In the final analysis, it is still the alienation of capital from people.

The few specific suggestions given when the credits are broadcast at the end of the credits are highly actionable. In the past few years, I still had the energy to fight a little bit. During the holiday months, I would completely shut down social media for peace and quiet, and now I have surrendered. However, after watching this film, I still deleted some notifications of software to close several programs.

One more sentence: One of the myths in my junior high school days: What is the relationship between "capital" and "power"? Later, it suddenly dawned on me that the two are basically the same thing, an existence that allows people to achieve domination and control. So translating the title of the film as "surveillance capitalism" seems too narrow, and of course it is appropriate based on the content of the film.

Capital corrupts technology and alienates people, and power is doing the same thing, so we are both visibly monitored and controlled by authoritarianism, but also seduced and teased invisible by capital. It's quite romantic to have someone know and resist.

View more about The Social Dilemma reviews

Extended Reading
  • Kristoffer 2022-03-26 09:01:08

    It is quite convincing to invite a group of former high-ranking social media officials to appear in person, and the progression of the narrative level is relatively clear, but it is very funny to simulate the virtual space operation by real people. There is no qualitative change in the evolution of the brain structure. In the unprecedented rapid development of science and technology, there is obviously some kind of unfortunate disconnection. However, if you think about it, if you take off this high-tech coat, isn't it another version across human history? Truman". The core ideas about being occupied by social platforms, distracting attention, and being easily misled by fake news are not original, but we should study how “algorithms” sneak into thinking from browsing traces/habits/time, accurately locate personal preferences under the blessing of big data, and invest in What it likes to push and guide until it changes the concept and mindset of real life, and achieves manipulation without revealing traces - "Any sufficiently advanced technology is similar to magic", it is still chilling to think about. After watching this film, I took a look at my screen usage time and froze again. Can we still wake up from the matrix?

  • Therese 2022-04-24 07:01:15

    There are so many "previous xx" platforms, most of the time, with a face of "you know" and a sigh, what's the use? The analogy between drug user and social network user is simple and crude, just for brainwashing. The data support is pitiful, and how to break the game is not mentioned. The fact is not well done, and the point of view is not established. For a documentary of this level, 30 minutes is enough.

The Social Dilemma quotes

  • Self - Founding Father of Virtual Reality: It's the critics who are the true optimists.

  • Tristan Harris - Google, Former Design Ethicist: If you're not paying for the product, then you are the product.