Realism and Formalism

Horace 2022-03-21 09:02:38

A realistic work: ① It tells the story of Ivan, a war orphan who insisted on carrying out the reconnaissance mission despite the orders of his superiors and died. The first half revolves around Ivan's emotional life of not going to the military school and an officer, and the second half revolves around performing a new mission. ② Ambiguity, in addition to the story of Ivan, there is also a branch line where the colonel and the captain pursue the same female military doctor. In the end, the captain and the general doctor were transferred from the front line, and the colonel also died in battle. This does not promote the story of Ivan, its purpose is to show the suppression of human nature by war. For example, the kiss between the two on the ditch is full of danger. ③Long shots and on-site scheduling. For example, after the two returned from their mission, Ivan was waiting in the bunker. The military doctor came in and walked to the foreground. In a stable triangular relationship, the dominator is the captain of Jingshen, and the prospect of the military doctor has become the target of the two.

Tarkovsky's feature debut was a work of socialist realism, but it was already riddled with formalism. The high contrast and low profile of photography, the use of scenery, the use of unstable light sources, the battle of Ivan in the bunker, the sound and picture alignment in the concentration camp scene at the end, the use of camera lenses and the shaping of the atmosphere by environmental shooting, it is unimaginable to express war There isn't a single war scene or a gun battle scene in a movie that kills humanity. It is worth mentioning that the dreams, the dreams are all high-profile, so beautiful. But the dream at the beginning is in the green woods, and the dream at the end is in the beach with a dead tree.

View more about Ivan's Childhood reviews

Extended Reading
  • Hailey 2022-03-27 09:01:14

    [B-] It cannot be said that Laota's debut novel is immature, and many scenes and exquisite ideas have already begun to emerge; but it is definitely imperfect, and the style is broken, so there is such an easy-to-understand book. The old tower, but it just lost its charm. It is said that it is "seeing World War II from the perspective of children", but the war itself is almost never depicted, let alone the cruelty of war. Children are also endowed with strength even stronger than adults. I just want to use the beautiful picture in my dream as a contrast, but the contrast has no foothold. Thematic is missing. At the same time, the fantasy in the dream seems like a fantasy, but the reality part is monotonous. It's more like Laota's first attempt to use semi-realism to freehand brushwork. Maybe it's the success of this (Golden Lion Award) that allowed Laota to start unscrupulously creating poetry films.

  • Maurine 2022-03-23 09:02:39

    I don't really like war movies, but it's a really good old movie

Ivan's Childhood quotes

  • Ivan's Mother: If a well is really deep, you can see a star down there even in the middle of a sunny day.

  • Ivan: Is he a Fritz too?

    Galtsev: He's either a German doctor or writer.

    Ivan: They have no writers. I saw them burning books in a square. They poured gasoline on them and set them on fire. There was soot in the air for a week.

    Galtsev: That writer lived 400 years ago.

    Ivan: Well, then maybe.