Animals don't need human "protection"

Fabian 2022-03-21 09:02:50

The 1994 film, I just saw it today, I'm really ashamed. . . But precisely because it is a work from 1994, the director's advanced cognition is even more admirable. (The following is all personal understanding)

Today, many animal protection organizations are calling on people to protect the environment. When protecting animals, they always like to put some miserable pictures of animals. Animals are killed and dying. What can human beings do to "protect" these animals from harm, and One phenomenon is that Western countries criticize China for eating dog meat tirelessly. Don't these phenomena just prove that these people don't put animals and humans on the same level? If animals have the same status as humans in the eyes of humans, animals do not need human mercy and "protection" at all. This kind of "protection" is completely from the perspective of God, thinking that human beings are higher animals, and these lower animals are so pitiful. And it is this kind of "discrimination" from the bottom of the heart that will lead to greater contradictions between humans and animals.

Everything in the world has the same feelings as people. They have wisdom, communication, hierarchy, happiness, sadness, unity, and disagreement. They even have their own persistence and dreams. It is precisely because human beings simply do not believe that some animals have these as well, so they have no hesitation in mutilating them. But at the same time, some countries are still brooding about eating dog meat, because humans believe that dogs have these abilities, and dogs and human society have already blended together (or dogs have actually become humans to a large extent), so humans will Pay more attention to them, and the mutilation of dogs will be more blamed. (In this way, dogs can really be regarded as the first species in the animal kingdom to give up their dreams and "figured it out";) Just like the last choice of these raccoons.

This film is many levels higher than the propaganda of the Animal Protection Association! The director did not design the final confrontation between the raccoon and humans, did not accuse the "evil" of human beings, and did not exaggerate the "miserable" of the raccoon. You can endure this kind of high-pressure life every day.” Some people understand this sentence as a satire of human society, but I feel more that the raccoon understands human beings. It is precisely in the absence of such mutual understanding and equal treatment between human beings and nature that conflicts will continue to escalate. (Of course, it seems even more unrealistic to do this? After all, the survival of the fittest is also a law of nature, and there may be discrimination of this kind among animal species, maybe?)

In short, I feel that the director wants to express a lot, and the concept is not generally advanced. It still seems to be a very deep masterpiece today!

View more about Pom Poko reviews

Extended Reading
  • Nicola 2022-03-28 09:01:08

    Ghibli's first-class masterpiece, with sentiment and more feelings. Many of Studio Ghibli's works have such characteristics, deconstructing one problem after another with the contemptuous thinking of mature people, stubborn and naive kindness, but taking off the coat of kindness, there are still children with innocence. It is a complete philosophical system. F: Friends who like Abe's fine name and Baigui Yaxing can come and recognize some monsters.

  • Easter 2022-03-26 09:01:11

    Laughing all the way, ending in pain. Not because it was a tragedy, but because it was cruel and sad, especially in the end, the civet cats tried their best to imagine their former hometown, forests, fields, streams and the beautiful life of the past. --Short comment on "Lab" of "Heisei Tanuki War"

Pom Poko quotes

  • Seizaemon: All pray!

    [the tanuki put their hands together and bow]

    Osho: I'd like to say a prayer for the victims of this operation.

    [At this point, some of the tanuki start to snigger]

    Osho: We wish that we could save our forest without harming any humans. That was never our intention, but our forest is near and dear to us, and we...

    [the tanuki all burst into raucous laughter and head for the exit]

  • TamasaburôBuntaTanuki: [singing] Let's turn into every sacred icon we can think of. Some are this and some are that...

    [They do backflips into the air and turn into various items; stone Buddhas, lucky cats, painted eggs, kitsune sculptures, gold carp sculptures, monkey sculptures and Tanuki sculptures. Ponkichi rushes to join in and tries copying them. He does various poses but is unable to transform]

    Shokichi: [narrating] Back then, all I thought about was transforming. I never dreamed that my friend Ponkichi might just want to be a normal raccoon.