Looking back at Pearl Harbor from the perspective of East Asians

Alexander 2022-03-21 09:02:47

In 1970, Japan and the United States co-produced "Tiger! Tiger! Tiger! , is the beginning and end of the Pearl Harbor incident from the two main lines of Japan and the United States. This film was shot very carefully, and it is not the same as the subsequent visual effects blockbusters "Pearl Harbor" and "Battle of Midway". The degree of reduction is quite high, the granularity of details is very complete and rich, and the pure and soothing narrative style makes the causal context clearer.

In one segment, the US Navy intelligence officer tried to report the possible Japanese raid on Pearl Harbor several times. The big boss, Admiral Marshall, was either sleeping or riding a horse early in the weekend. Others dared not call the shots. . The bureaucracy shaped by the bureaucracy makes it difficult to pass information. There are many similar small details in the film, and some of them almost become laughing points.

The joke about horseback riding reminded me of how unreliable it was in the epidemic. I played golf for the 265th time when more than 100,000 people died of illness in the country. It was a typical case of American (negative) freedom and normalization. In fact, I watched the entire film with the current situation in front of me, and I could find many one-to-one correspondences:

From the beginning to the end, there was a lot of information pointing directly to Japan's imminent raid on Hawaii, but out of "invincible" honeyed confidence, deep-rooted arrogance and prejudice from racial superiority and institutional superiority, and serious vanity, the authorities put the black in front of them. Treated as white, or even turned a deaf ear, until he was beaten into a sieve and turned into a compulsive force. (familiar recipe)

Moreover, I always feel that the grassroots people in Laomei are still very good, but once they reach the decision-making level, perhaps because they pay too much attention to decentralization and checks and balances, it is easy to lag and disconnect in decision-making.

Large-scale structural arrogance and prejudice, decentralized equilibrium strategies amplify disorder, anti-authority and anti-experts to anti-intellect... under specific parameters will produce wrong algorithms. For example, MacArthur in the Korean War, Pearl Harbor Incident, Black Hawk Incident in Somalia, and the fight against the epidemic this time. (familiar taste)

When I watched Pearl Harbor in the past, I saw it from the perspective of an American. After all, as a resident of Nanjing, I have a physiological immune response to the little Japan. And for so many years of brainwashing American values, it is inevitable that there will be a little sense of subjectivity;

Only this time, assuming the possible variables that have not undergone major changes in a hundred years, from the perspective of an East Asian, entering a situation of a deadly war with the United States (the United States had blocked Japan's oil, rubber, iron ore, etc. at that time, although there was no war yet. , is also a trapped beast). At that time, Japan was able to make such a creative and courageous raid decision, and could not help but be in awe.

Although Japan has always been a gambler, and is good at tactics and strategies, it is meticulous, rigorous, brave, and not afraid of death, which is enough to stand proudly among the nations. If we want to successfully complete this relay, we must use our hearts, our brains, and our guts, and we must not miss any of them.

View more about Tora! Tora! Tora! reviews

Extended Reading
  • Hayden 2022-03-26 09:01:10

    "There are many Japanese people who think that American democracy is a politics of personal alienation, that Americans' longing for a luxurious life is a moral and moral corruption, and that the so-called strong country is a strong foreign country. This is a great misunderstanding. Once the two countries go to war, The United States will be the most powerful enemy Japan has ever faced"

  • Troy 2022-03-17 09:01:06

    Panoramic tiled restoration of war history. The advantage is to restore the true event process of all parties from a large and comprehensive perspective, which is different from the approach of personal perspective in recent years. From before the raid, the Japanese side carefully prepared for war and even conducted exercises; the United States had numerous early warnings, and even had many opportunities to fight seriously before the raid, but it was a series of accidental coincidences, mainly a mistake caused by a relaxation of mentality. The most embarrassing thing is the phrase "I'm off work at seven o'clock," and he didn't enter the state of preparation at all. From the perspective of the battle, Japan was easier to win than expected, and Yamamoto Fifty-Six had clearly seen the reversal a year later; on the US side, all kinds of armament preparations were already adequate, and all that was lacking was mental preparation. The final tone of the movie is also the same. Both parties seem to be caused by communication problems, but the victor of the battle awakens the terrible enemy.

Tora! Tora! Tora! quotes

  • Admiral William F. Halsey: If we're going to probe, let's probe.

  • Cook #1 (Japanese version only): You know today's date?

    Cook #2 (Japanese version only): December 1st.

    Cook #1 (Japanese version only): Yes, but tonight will be November 30th.

    Cook #2 (Japanese version only): What?

    Cook #1 (Japanese version only): When we cross the International Date Line we'll push the clock ahead five hours and turn the calendar back a full day, making today yesterday.

    Cook #2 (Japanese version only): Don't be silly! Today can't change into yesterday!