Subject vs. Sovereign

Hosea 2022-03-22 09:01:36

Despite Dustin Hoffman, Morgan Freeman, and a skinny Kevin Spacey, I didn't really like the movie because of its overt personal heroism, dispensable emotional lines, and monotonous rhythm.

What struck me was the decision by the military to blow up the town of Cedar Creek when it could not control the epidemic, sacrificing a small number of lives to ensure the safety of the continental United States. And how familiar is this logic? Isn't that what Thanos means in Avengers 3? Sacrifice half of life in the galaxy for the future of the galaxy.

So the question is, in such extreme circumstances, does the military/state have the right to decide to sacrifice a small number of people (including townspeople who are not infected with the flu) in order to safeguard the interests of the vast majority/preserve sovereign? So where does the line lie between the individual will and the sovereign will that is supposed to represent the individual wills in totality?

This is really an issue of political philosophy.

View more about Outbreak reviews

Extended Reading

Outbreak quotes

  • [Jimbo is calling up Rudy about the monkey]

    Rudy Alvarez: When did you get it?

    Jimbo Scott: Just today, Rudy. We still on?

    Rudy Alvarez: Yeah, he still wants it.

    Jimbo Scott: Great. Great.

  • [Jimbo prepares to leave the lab with the monkey He approaches a gate. A guard walks up]

    Biotest Guard: [hearing the monkey chattering] Oh, I see. So your ship came in again, eh, Jimbo?

    Jimbo Scott: Our ship, Neil.

    [laughs]

    Biotest Guard: Our ship.

    Jimbo Scott: [pulls out some money] Africa, land of great beauty and untold riches.

    [Jimbo hands the money to the guard]

    Biotest Guard: Absolutely untold.

    Jimbo Scott: Keep it that way.

    [the guard opens the gate]

    Jimbo Scott: [taking off] Take care.